Should property taxes be swapped out for something else?
techstepgenr8tion
Veteran
Joined: 6 Feb 2005
Age: 46
Gender: Male
Posts: 24,693
Location: 28th Path of Tzaddi
visagrunt wrote:
But where are you getting your water? If you are drawing from a river, you have to address the riparian rights of those who live downstream. If you dig a well, you have to address the water table rights of other people who rely on the water table. Local municipalities are potential affected in either case.
Where are you going to put your garbage? You can certainly take it to a landfill yourself and pay the dumping charges, but what if you don't--what if you bury your garbage? What if you are creating hazardous waste in a business you run on your property? Is the community supposed to sit idly by while you bury drums of hazmats to pollute the water table?
You don't get to insulate yourself from the local community. You might be able to put fences up around your property, but you cannot put fences around the consequences of your occupancy. The tax obligation on your property doesn't merely pay for the services that you might choose to forego, it also provides a means to aggregate the responsibility for general services from which you are a beneficiary, whether you claim them or not.
Where are you going to put your garbage? You can certainly take it to a landfill yourself and pay the dumping charges, but what if you don't--what if you bury your garbage? What if you are creating hazardous waste in a business you run on your property? Is the community supposed to sit idly by while you bury drums of hazmats to pollute the water table?
You don't get to insulate yourself from the local community. You might be able to put fences up around your property, but you cannot put fences around the consequences of your occupancy. The tax obligation on your property doesn't merely pay for the services that you might choose to forego, it also provides a means to aggregate the responsibility for general services from which you are a beneficiary, whether you claim them or not.
Great examples of why I find the whole concept of anarchism dubious - you'd have these problems between cities and, if we wanted to talk about cross country commerce and interstates - thousands and thousands of localities per each.
_________________
The loneliest part of life: it's not just that no one is on your cloud, few can even see your cloud.
ruveyn wrote:
pandabear wrote:
Rather than declaring war on sodomy and non-marital coitus, the government really should be taxing these activities, as it taxes booze and tobacco, and should tax other drugs that are presently illegal.
And just how will the government quantify that which is being taxed? But putting meters on the nether parts of citizens?
I have it! Tax orgasms. It's the coming thing!
ruveyn
Some people might fake their orgasms.
Usually, however, the government only taxes when money is involved--barterers escape taxation. If I were to exchange tobacco for sex, that would presently be legal, and untaxed.
