If God exists, why does He hide from us?

Post Reply New Topic

No, they aren't. It usually starts with some brainwave doing something abnormal (epiphany!) or some psychological illness/delusion (the brain tricks you), and then you're left with two possible choices: systemize it, get people involved with it (the social group), write a book about it, threaten people to believe it, preach about it and convince people - OR - try to be rational and contemplate/figure out what has happened. So with telepathy you could either have come up with a new world-changing ideology, or you could have experienced a normal delusion (symptom of psychological illness).

How does God knowing your choice in advance make it any less your choice? He didn't choose for you, he simply knew what you would choose.

Well, there is the view that if there is a God, you will one day be called to account for all of your actions during your life, while if there is not, then there will be no final reckoning, and you will not be held responsible for your actions.

I think it's all a lot of hairsplitting - you get responsibility for your actions whether you like it or not - but it's a fun way for theologians to pass an evening...

Thanks for explaining, that's exactly what I wanted to say.

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QVgZqnsytJI[/youtube]

Because he's got some explaining to do.

Well for a start, God created the world, and he shaped me in my mother's womb. He has set up the world in full knowledge that I will choose what I choose.

I do not have a choice. I can only choose one thing because God has already seen what I will choose. To genuinely have free will, I have to have the ability to choose between options.

If God seems to be hiding, you're looking for him in noisy places.

The justification and explaining in this thread are of very poor quality, made on completely random, insignificant grounds (made up logic).

Something different you was expecting, maybe?

This forum especially but NOT only the R parts, you got plenty fall please into my trap questions and folks too dumb to realize or too zealous to stay away.

Forget dispassionate.

I could an if I would, but piles [intentional] bdfore swine.

Hard to find ANYONE who actually wants to discuss ANYTHING let alone + / - God.

How does him knowing which option you will choose in advance make all other options suddenly not exist?

Because he's a hikkikomori!

How could there only be one,there's not one of anything.If there is one there would have to be more.A whole passel of 'em. And why would "he"be a He?Why would he need a giant god penis??
And.....since it is.

"He" would be a "He" because English doesn't have a good neuter case to ascribe to living beings; "it" is generally taken to refer to objects. Therefore, we have to ascribe gender, even if it's not actually relevant - and the gender was assigned by a rather sexist society, one that did not consider that a "She" could possibly be an all-powerful Creator (even though, given human biology, that would have been a logical assumption).

The believer should ideally do more than that. Not working and just praying for money, for example, is obviously avoiding responsibility as well, yes. You should do whatever you can, besides just trusting in God.

Of course it is possible. That's kind of a stupid question, IMO. Many times I find myself having trouble remembering to do things with God in mind, instead of just helping people first and considering my intentions later. Besides, does doing something because you are told to mean you did not act altruistically? If someone tells you to donate money to a charity, will it not be altruistic for you to do so, even if that person has at that point no way of knowing whether you did or not? On top of that, I consider religion to be not as much a reason to do good works, as a guide on what is good. If someone is totally selfish, will the threat of Hell really deter them? Or will they just convince themselves not to believe in it?

Because God only exists in the mind.