Do you think Islam will outlive Christianity?

Post Reply New Topic

Islam of course, is 600 years younger, so it has that advantage. Do you think Islam will last longer than Christianity? Christianity is continuing to die in Europe, and there's signs it's starting to die in America and Latin America as well. On the other hand, it's growing in Africa and Asia.

Islam on the other hand, seems to be continuing to grow, though in some countries, like Turkey it is declining, and in some countries like Iran it's losing appeal among the youth.

Do you think Islam will outlast Christianity or will they both die out as religions around the same time? How long do you think it will take for them to no longer be major religions?

Could you see Christianity outliving Islam?

I haven't seen the stats on Latin America, but I'd be interested to see if there is a decline. I noticed that a lot of South American countries, even those with socialist governments, have very high rates of religiosity.

As for which religion will die first, it depends on whether the Arab countries begin to develop welfare states in the next 70 or so years. Extensive social welfare systems crowd out religious charities, secularizing the jobless poor, working poor, and broader working class.

M_P has a good point there. Its also possible there could be a serious backlash against religion in Muslim dominant countries due to the extremism that is very visible for the time being. I do think Islam will outlive Christianity though as the amount of extreme followers in that religion does outnumber Christianity. I also don't expect to see sects like the Sufi disappear overnight. If anything I expect the Sufi will outlive the rest of Islam. I would not be very surprised if Bahá'í outlives both Christianity and Islam as it is (imho) the most 'enlightened' religion out there. That probably has a lot to do with the fact that it is what you could consider a 'post-enlightenment' religion, whereby ideas such as the rights of man and equality that were really pushed and explored in that time influenced Bahá'í heavily

Since the Middle East is such a s**thole, religion fulfills a greater need. Islam will definitely outlive Christianity. Also since Islam is so deeply intrenched into their cultures, this will make it die a lot harder.

Unlikely. For one thing, Christianity is hardly "dying," and I suspect the number of reported Muslims is highly inflated by the fact that religious dissent is legally prohibited in the areas where Islam predominates. The Middle East does not actually consist of 99% Muslims. Those people are told that they are Muslim and counted as Muslim for the census, but as soon as those states adopt a modern permissive government the proportion of reported Muslims will plummet.

Also important to note that Islam's growth comes exclusively from high birth rates in Muslim-dominated regions, not from conversion. That's not a sustainable way for a religion to grow. The Baha'i, in contrast, grow almost exclusively through converts from other faiths and are growing at a higher rate than Islam.

They don't have any fundamental differences whereby one would be considered "just too ridiculous" while the other is still believable. As long as there are still people willing to buy the "omnipotent and omniscient being" premise, both will exist in some form.