Why do Neo-Marxists hate the "New Atheists"?

Post Reply New Topic

Because "Neo-Atheists" do not need Communism to tell them what not to believe in - they can think for themselves, which is anathema to secular religions like Communism.

From the New York Times bestselling author of American Fascists and the NBCC finalist for War Is a Force That Gives Us Meaning comes this timely and compelling work about new atheists: those who attack religion to advance the worst of global capitalism, intolerance and imperial projects.

Chris Hedges, who graduated from seminary at Harvard Divinity School, has long been a courageous voice in a world where there are too few. He observes that there are two radical, polarized and dangerous sides to the debate on faith and religion in America: the fundamentalists who see religious faith as their prerogative, and the new atheists who brand all religious belief as irrational and dangerous. Both sides use faith to promote a radical agenda, while the religious majority, those with a commitment to tolerance and compassion as well as to their faith, are caught in the middle.

The new atheists, led by Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens and Sam Harris, do not make moral arguments about religion. Rather, they have created a new form of fundamentalism that attempts to permeate society with ideas about our own moral superiority and the omnipotence of human reason.

I Don't Believe in Atheists critiques the radical mindset that rages against religion and faith. Hedges identifies the pillars of the new atheist belief system, revealing that the stringent rules and rigid traditions in place are as strict as those of any religious practice.

Hedges claims that those who have placed blind faith in the morally neutral disciplines of reason and science create idols in their own image -- a sin for either side of the spectrum. He makes an impassioned, intelligent case against religious and secular fundamentalism, which seeks to divide the world into those worthy of moral and intellectual consideration and those who should be condemned, silenced and eradicated. Hedges shatters the new atheists' assault against religion in America, and in doing so, makes way for new, moderate voices to join the debate. This is a book that must be read to understand the state of the battle about faith.

I am a neo-Marxist and I have no problem with the respectful non-nihilistic atheists.

The reason is that modern atheism is often associated with nihilism. Marxists usually believe that there is meaning to life.
Many Marxists are atheists so I don't understand why any Marxist would be opposed to all atheists.
That's no way to achieve a Marxist society.

Communism isn't a religion, it is a system of economics and government.

That's no way to achieve a Marxist society.

... nothing but flowery, unverifiable, literary critic nonsense and tangential ramblings.

Not in modern times, but it *is* possible. Look at the culture the North American Indians had before the Europeans arrived, it could be defined as Communistic or Marxist.