?

Post Reply New Topic

Why do some people choose to take offense at things/comments by other people that they know werent meant to be offensive?

For instance I was talking with a friend, and described my other friend as being Black, and very cool/nice. The other person I was talking too, got all offended, and screamed "you shouldnt say hes black thats racist" me "you know I didnt mean anything offensive" and my other friend got even madder.

Seriously, Iv'e seen other situations like this, and wonder why do people take offense at things that arent meant to be offensive?There has got to be some philosophical answer to this question of mine, am I right?

Quite simply, we're not in Humpty Dumpty's world, and the words we use don't just mean what we want them to mean. Words have baggage, whether you like it or not, and you don't get a pass at using a word with negative baggage simply because "you don't mean anything by it". I mean, should I simply be allowed to call a dark-skinned person a "n*****" simply because I say I'm not racist? No, of course not! We are living in communities, and words are social constructs, with much further ranges than just what you mean to say at a single moment of time. Your words are not just yours, they are the whole community's, and you don't get to define them as you want (if everyone had their own private vocabulary, communication would be impossible). So you can be offensive even if you don't mean to be.

Of course, you may disagree on the community's treatment of a word, just as I find it a bit exaggerated to consider the word "Black" offensive. But that doesn't mean you can just ignore it and expect communication to flow smoothly. People have their own ideas of what a word means, and they can't read your thoughts. So if you use a word they find offensive, they will be offended, and there's nothing you can do about it. "I didn't mean anything offensive" isn't an excuse here, because no one but you knows what your meaning was. The listener only has your words to get to your meaning, and they will interpret them in their way, not yours, because they can't know your way.

I think your mistake here was to expect your listener to know in advance that you didn't mean anything offensive. Why should they? I mean, could what you said not have been understood as "despite being Black, he's cool/nice"? In that case their reaction was absolutely normal.

Having conversations is a complicated thing, and one of the important parts of it is to know your audience, and adapt your speech accordingly.

Some people are just overly sensative is all you said black thats fine most folks black dont care really! Would you be offended by being called white? Of course not its the minorities of the groups that do there are just people out there that just try to find reasons to be offended or are overly sensative! Now if ya said something like darky or N***** thats a whole different story then yeah thats racist! Its like being called a honkey or cracker or wh***y!

if a white person can be called white, then what is wrong with referring to a black person as black? enquiring minds want to know.

ive recently been reading a book called about NT's called 'a field guide to Earthlings' which someone on another thread on this very forum recommended.

Basically, NT's have an ability we don't called 'symbolic filtering'. Where autistics might associate one word with a specific context, NT's tend to associate words with multiple contexts. This is the major problem in the AS/NT communication barrier and its how we tend to cause offence unintentionally.

Because people can be reactive over all kinds of things....emotions clouding reason. Welcome to my personal life lol

Political correctness and the hairstring trigger of race.

Next time, omit any racial description. It's not important to know what color the individual is anyhow.

Of course, you can just say he's green... That will freak her out.