naturalplastic wrote:
Another "whose holocaust was the worst?" debate. Whoooopeeeee.
Part of the problem is its peaches to pears. Comparing Stalin to Hitler is like comparing dengue fever to cancer, or either to the bubonic plague, or to alzheimers. You cant compare. you just know that you wouldnt want any of the four.
You could go by the dictator's body count.
But then you would have to take into account the...body count relative to the population size that the dictator had control over. And then THAT relative to the length of time the dictator was in power.
Mao had the highest body count. But he ruled the largest population sized nation, and ruled it for a longer time than most everyone else on the list. Stalin and Mao ruled vast continental sized nations. Hitler, Tojo, and Mussolini ruled middle sized nations, but nations that managed to seize control of continental sized regions of the planet by force of arms for brief periods during WWII. But only for brief periods.
Idi Amin, and Pol Pot, never controlled more than small countries with small population sizes. But still managed to murder a lot of people.
If I had to pick I would say Hitler: because he is the only one who started a world war (the 60 million plus deaths in WWII could be added to the 11 million victims of his concentration camp system). Further, if he had won the war he likely would have continued to commit other vast genocides. And Hitler gets bonus points for the general grotesqueness of his creation of an industry of genocide. Subjective yes. But ya know. Points for style.
At second place I would say Pol Pot. He killed the most relative to the small population size of the one country heruled, and gets added grotesqueness points for creating a unique industry of genocide similar to that of Hitler.
Consider the following:
- Philosophical nature of genocide (whether there is a driving ideology that augments the dictators action, with worse moral consequences)
- Implicit or explicit genocide. What I mean by this is whether there is a driving principle or ideology that can clearly be derived from the said action of the person, and the nature of 'targeting' a certain group of people or none specifically at all.
- Technically speaking a higher body count, and evil intentions ascribed to the evil acts would make the said person more evil in comparison.
_________________
Sebastian
"Don't forget to floss." - Darkwing Duck