United Methodist Church To Split Over Same-Sex Marriage
We also talk about differing belief systems. It’s a natural extension of the the books on history that we’ve been reading together. He finds it interesting, but he’s a natural sceptic.
He’s used to exercising discretion with religious family members and friends. We are respectful towards others, but I’m not going to say that something is positive when it isn’t. It’s about balance.
I seek to emphasize rationalism. He’s going to be presented with conspiracy theories as well which is not cool. At least he likes science. That’s half the battle.
It sounds like you've already decided that science is "rational" and "correct", and that you are pointing this out to your son in counterbalance of his grandparents who are "wrong". That's your opinion. Please realise your son has every right to decide for himself what is rational or correct.
You said "I'm not going to say something is positive when it isn't". I wasn't suggesting that you need to say "religion is positive", or that parents have to glorify the other point of view. I'm saying that freedom of choice is positive, and a child's ability to decide independently with critical thinking is "positive". It sounds like your son is beginning to do this.
Science usually is rational and correct when it is backed by substantial evidence.
He is not drawn to religion in any way. He’s a chip off the old block.
Anyway, at 8, he should NOT have complete freedom of choice when it comes to religion. I wouldn’t let him join a cult for example, and I wouldn’t let my parents take him to their church or study the Bible with him. Not that he’d want to. He could want to join through peer pressure, I suppose, but that hasn’t happened yet.
You really do have to make responsible choices when you are a parent, especially if there are any risk factors that should be taken into account.
_________________
“The darkness shall be the light, and the stillness the dancing.”
— from Four Quartets by T.S. Eliot
Of course he's young. What I meant was, you can say "Some people believe in God. Some people believe the world was created in a different way. Some people believe God is something completely different". Those are all concepts he seems familiar with at this point in his development. You certainly don't need to get heavy with examples at this stage. Regarding gay marriage, "some people believe marriage is between a man and a woman. Some people think gender doesn't matter. Lots of families have two dads or two mothers (or other variations). " Again, it's simple and accepting of all.
I don't think it's necessary to talk about religious people not being "sane or rational", being "the worst people you know", or "wearing tinfoil hats". It's not helpful to mock groups of people or laugh about them for having different opinions.
If you want to teach your child that liberal lifestyles are valid (e.g., gay marriage), he will also need to learn that traditional lifestyles are valid too. The whole point is that adults are free to make informed choices, either way.
_________________
I never give you my number, I only give you my situation.
Beatles
We also talk about differing belief systems. It’s a natural extension of the the books on history that we’ve been reading together. He finds it interesting, but he’s a natural sceptic.
He’s used to exercising discretion with religious family members and friends. We are respectful towards others, but I’m not going to say that something is positive when it isn’t. It’s about balance.
I seek to emphasize rationalism. He’s going to be presented with conspiracy theories as well which is not cool. At least he likes science. That’s half the battle.
It sounds like you've already decided that science is "rational" and "correct", and that you are pointing this out to your son in counterbalance of his grandparents who are "wrong". That's your opinion. Please realise your son has every right to decide for himself what is rational or correct.
You said "I'm not going to say something is positive when it isn't". I wasn't suggesting that you need to say "religion is positive", or that parents have to glorify the other point of view. I'm saying that freedom of choice is positive, and a child's ability to decide independently with critical thinking is "positive". It sounds like your son is beginning to do this.
Science usually is rational and correct when it is backed by substantial evidence.
He is not drawn to religion in any way. He’s a chip off the old block.
Anyway, at 8, he should NOT have complete freedom of choice when it comes to religion. I wouldn’t let him join a cult for example, and I wouldn’t let my parents take him to their church or study the Bible with him. Not that he’d want to. He could want to join through peer pressure, I suppose, but that hasn’t happened yet.
You really do have to make responsible choices when you are a parent, especially if there are any risk factors that should be taken into account.
Are your parents extremely religious or something?
Of course he's young. What I meant was, you can say "Some people believe in God. Some people believe the world was created in a different way. Some people believe God is something completely different". Those are all concepts he seems familiar with at this point in his development. You certainly don't need to get heavy with examples at this stage. Regarding gay marriage, "some people believe marriage is between a man and a woman. Some people think gender doesn't matter. Lots of families have two dads or two mothers (or other variations). " Again, it's simple and accepting of all.
I don't think it's necessary to talk about religious people not being "sane or rational", being "the worst people you know", or "wearing tinfoil hats". It's not helpful to mock groups of people or laugh about them for having different opinions.
If you want to teach your child that liberal lifestyles are valid (e.g., gay marriage), he will also need to learn that traditional lifestyles are valid too. The whole point is that adults are free to make informed choices, either way.
*shrug*
I’m not going to present the fact that some people think that gay marriage is wrong as a positive thing. That would hurt my personal sense of morality, especially since these views are so damaging to gay people who are raised in these religions. I can respect the people even if I have no respect for certain beliefs they hold which are offensive to me. I’m not going to uphold Nazism, either.
I don’t respect the religion I was brought up in, but I have lots of love and respect for some of the people.
I didn’t think of the tin foil hat as being a religious thing. I thought it was more of a conspiracy theorist, fringe belief.
_________________
“The darkness shall be the light, and the stillness the dancing.”
— from Four Quartets by T.S. Eliot
We also talk about differing belief systems. It’s a natural extension of the the books on history that we’ve been reading together. He finds it interesting, but he’s a natural sceptic.
He’s used to exercising discretion with religious family members and friends. We are respectful towards others, but I’m not going to say that something is positive when it isn’t. It’s about balance.
I seek to emphasize rationalism. He’s going to be presented with conspiracy theories as well which is not cool. At least he likes science. That’s half the battle.
It sounds like you've already decided that science is "rational" and "correct", and that you are pointing this out to your son in counterbalance of his grandparents who are "wrong". That's your opinion. Please realise your son has every right to decide for himself what is rational or correct.
You said "I'm not going to say something is positive when it isn't". I wasn't suggesting that you need to say "religion is positive", or that parents have to glorify the other point of view. I'm saying that freedom of choice is positive, and a child's ability to decide independently with critical thinking is "positive". It sounds like your son is beginning to do this.
Science usually is rational and correct when it is backed by substantial evidence.
He is not drawn to religion in any way. He’s a chip off the old block.
Anyway, at 8, he should NOT have complete freedom of choice when it comes to religion. I wouldn’t let him join a cult for example, and I wouldn’t let my parents take him to their church or study the Bible with him. Not that he’d want to. He could want to join through peer pressure, I suppose, but that hasn’t happened yet.
You really do have to make responsible choices when you are a parent, especially if there are any risk factors that should be taken into account.
Are your parents extremely religious or something?
Jehovah’s Witnesses
_________________
“The darkness shall be the light, and the stillness the dancing.”
— from Four Quartets by T.S. Eliot
I don't think you understand what I'm saying. I didn't say you should tell him "anti-gay rights is positive". I didn't say anything like that whatsoever. The "positive" is that you can teach him people live in a free society where they can make their own decisions about a number of issues, as they grow up.
The "positive" is that no one has to be something they aren't. The "positive" is that you are openminded to accept him whatever he chooses in any number of decisions. The "positive" is that even though his grandparents are JW, they love him and you do too, regardless of what he believes down the road.
Expose your son to age appropriate books or videos or other examples where there are gay parents or gay children, so he knows that you are openminded. When you talk about families make sure you mention that families come in all forms. He will learn from what he's exposed to, and what you treat as valid. That's what's positive.
_________________
I never give you my number, I only give you my situation.
Beatles
Any good stories?
I’ve got several from the other side of the equation. LOL
But I’ll maybe save that for another time.
_________________
“The darkness shall be the light, and the stillness the dancing.”
— from Four Quartets by T.S. Eliot
I don't think you understand what I'm saying. I didn't say you should tell him "anti-gay rights is positive". I didn't say anything like that whatsoever. The "positive" is that you can teach him people live in a free society where they can make their own decisions about a number of issues, as they grow up.
The "positive" is that no one has to be something they aren't. The "positive" is that you are openminded to accept him whatever he chooses in any number of decisions. The "positive" is that even though his grandparents are JW, they love him and you do too, regardless of what he believes down the road.
Expose your son to age appropriate books or videos or other examples where there are gay parents or gay children, so he knows that you are openminded. When you talk about families make sure you mention that families come in all forms. He will learn from what he's exposed to, and what you treat as valid. That's what's positive.
What makes you think that I don’t do that?!?
I didn’t come on here asking for parenting advice today. What we are doing is working for us, our situation, and environment.
_________________
“The darkness shall be the light, and the stillness the dancing.”
— from Four Quartets by T.S. Eliot
I don't think you understand what I'm saying. I didn't say you should tell him "anti-gay rights is positive". I didn't say anything like that whatsoever. The "positive" is that you can teach him people live in a free society where they can make their own decisions about a number of issues, as they grow up.
The "positive" is that no one has to be something they aren't. The "positive" is that you are openminded to accept him whatever he chooses in any number of decisions. The "positive" is that even though his grandparents are JW, they love him and you do too, regardless of what he believes down the road.
Expose your son to age appropriate books or videos or other examples where there are gay parents or gay children, so he knows that you are openminded. When you talk about families make sure you mention that families come in all forms. He will learn from what he's exposed to, and what you treat as valid. That's what's positive.
What makes you think that I don’t do that?!?
I didn’t come on here asking for parenting advice today. What we are doing is working for us, our situation, and environment.
I didn't say that you don't do that. You thought I was advocating for something totally different, so I was explaining what I meant. This thread is supposed to be a news article celebrating change and forward thinking in the church. You have written several posts about your personal life, saying that the church is harmful to your son. You cracked jokes about people in the church even when they stated they support gay marriage. You didn't ask for parenting advice but you made a lot of generalisations about religion based on your son and your family, and you mentioned him repeatedly. I was speaking up for people who don't like to be misunderstood.
_________________
I never give you my number, I only give you my situation.
Beatles
Any good stories?
I’ve got several from the other side of the equation. LOL
But I’ll maybe save that for another time.
One time I had a couple of JW's at the door and they asked about three or four questions before saying "We want to talk to you about the good book." And I said, "I was reading until you knocked. I thought Playboy is a good book."
I don't think you understand what I'm saying. I didn't say you should tell him "anti-gay rights is positive". I didn't say anything like that whatsoever. The "positive" is that you can teach him people live in a free society where they can make their own decisions about a number of issues, as they grow up.
The "positive" is that no one has to be something they aren't. The "positive" is that you are openminded to accept him whatever he chooses in any number of decisions. The "positive" is that even though his grandparents are JW, they love him and you do too, regardless of what he believes down the road.
Expose your son to age appropriate books or videos or other examples where there are gay parents or gay children, so he knows that you are openminded. When you talk about families make sure you mention that families come in all forms. He will learn from what he's exposed to, and what you treat as valid. That's what's positive.
What makes you think that I don’t do that?!?
I didn’t come on here asking for parenting advice today. What we are doing is working for us, our situation, and environment.
I didn't say that you don't do that. You thought I was advocating for something totally different, so I was explaining what I meant. This thread is supposed to be a news article celebrating change and forward thinking in the church. You have written several posts about your personal life, saying that the church is harmful to your son. You cracked jokes about people in the church even when they stated they support gay marriage. You didn't ask for parenting advice but you made a lot of generalisations about religion based on your son and your family, and you mentioned him repeatedly. I was speaking up for people who don't like to be misunderstood.
If you dislike my posts, report them instead of repeatedly complaining about them.
The news item isn’t entirely good. The church isn’t making a complete move from not accepting the LGBT community to accepting them. It’s caused a huge split.
It’s still a problem in a lot of churches. It’s still something that needs to be worked on. There are churches who are accepting, but there are many still that aren’t.
I don’t think I said anywhere that no church was.
_________________
“The darkness shall be the light, and the stillness the dancing.”
— from Four Quartets by T.S. Eliot
I did report instances where you mocked individuals and groups of people with sarcasm.
If you don't like religion, don't practise it .... instead of repeatedly mocking it, or the people who do.
It's against the rules.
_________________
I never give you my number, I only give you my situation.
Beatles
Any good stories?
I’ve got several from the other side of the equation. LOL
But I’ll maybe save that for another time.
One time I had a couple of JW's at the door and they asked about three or four questions before saying "We want to talk to you about the good book." And I said, "I was reading until you knocked. I thought Playboy is a good book."
LOL
That’s pretty good! Nobody ever said anything that funny to me.
When I was 12, I got carsick and threw up on a homeowner’s shoes. It wasn’t funny at the time but it is in retrospect.
There were a bunch of oddballs but nothing demonstrably funny. Every now and then someone would answer the door almost nude when he or she was expecting someone else.
_________________
“The darkness shall be the light, and the stillness the dancing.”
— from Four Quartets by T.S. Eliot
If you don't like religion, don't practise it .... instead of repeatedly mocking it, or the people who do.
It's against the rules.
“Attacking an opinion, belief, or philosophy is acceptable.”
Continue to report what you don’t like.
_________________
“The darkness shall be the light, and the stillness the dancing.”
— from Four Quartets by T.S. Eliot
"Personal attacks.
This includes insinuation, ridicule and personal insults, regardless of whether direct or indirect. Attacking an opinion, belief or philosophy is acceptable, but attacking the person making the comments is not."
Please stop making fun of people who are religious (Christian, Jewish, Muslim or other), people in traditional communities, people who like dresses, people who wear hijabs, people who are sex workers, and other people who have different lifestyles than your own.
Over and out.
_________________
I never give you my number, I only give you my situation.
Beatles
| Similar Topics | |
|---|---|
| Abandoning Marriage and Parenting goals PERMANENTLY!!! |
17 Jul 2026, 12:48 pm |
| Abandoning Marriage and Parenting goals PERMANENTLY!!! |
31 Dec 1969, 7:00 pm |
