Woman calls cops another Black Jogger

Post Reply New Topic

I think both of them made big mistakes:

1) The mistake that the guy made is that he took upon himself the role of the ranger and came up with his own ideas on how to punish the supposed violations of the law. If the "actual" ranger -- or an officer -- were to see a dog off the leash, they would have given a fine, or whatever the punishment is. They wouldn't have tried to lure the dog.

2) The mistake that the girl made is that, instead of saying she was given a vague threat, she said her life was threatened. The part about threat is true: "I will do something you wouldn't like" is a threat. But the part about "life" threat is false, because he didn't specify it.

However, in order to see who is "more" at fault, you have to keep in mind that the guy pre-meditated everything, as evident from the fact that he had the food ready. On the other hand, the girl was taken up by surprise and had to act on the spot. And human beings are not robots, you can't expect them to act on their feet in the situations they were TOTALLY unprepared for.

And, by the way, even though he dind't threaten her life, he DID scare her. The phrase "I will do something you won't like" doesn't say that its murder -- but it doesn't say that it isn't, either. So maybe he had in mind just call her a couple of names and thats it, or maybe he had in mind that he was going to kill her, or maybe it was something in between. What was she supposed to think? Its perfectly reasonable for the instinct of self preservation to make one think of the worst possible scenario.

I guess there are two things playing a role here. On the one hand, there is self preservation -- so she has to think of worst possible scenario. On the other hand, there is a presumption of innocence, so she can't say that he was going to do something if she doesn't have 100% evidence for it. So I guess what she "should have" said is "he threatened me with something, I don't know what it is, I am concerned it might have to do with murder, but thats just one of several concernes because I don't really know so I won't accuse him of it, but since I have this concern I want to do something". But that requires quite a bit of thought, doesn't it. And can you really expect someone to think when they are feeling scared? I can say crazy things when I get scared and I am sure you do too.

The bottom line is basically what the guy did was pre-planned, and the girl was put in a scary situation she was totally unprepared for.

10 Pages and counting about two a**holes having what should have been considered a minor dust-up that has somehow turned into a Rorschach test on racism, sexism, privilege, and Karen's.(SMH)

Pandemic, what pandemic?

Actually the black dude called her Central Park "Karen"?

Me, I thought Sally fits better

the truly scary thing is that she was only one of the less cagey ones who got caught. the majority get away with their domination games, nobody ever knows but their victims. there are MANY "karens" out there ready to harm us if they happen to catch wind of us or cross our path. aside from the ones who wear that silly@$$ed red cap, you can't tell what they are until they got you.

I happen to like the name Karen.

Why not call both combatants “nebbishes”!