The Savage War of Peace is an excellent book. I read it, and would recommend it. Bush has been known to read very high end stuff (I don't remember all of it but he I do remember reading he had read The Unknown Mao by Jung Chang and Jon Holliday).
Bill Clinton was very intelligent as well. Just because you disagree with someone doesn't mean the person you disagree with is stupid.
Civil liberties were much more "compromised" during World War II, and certainly World War I. Blatant abuses of power took place in the Nixon, (Lyndon) Johnson, and Kennedy administrations. Then again at the time no one seemed to take much notice of it compared to today.
The criticisms regarding Bush's domestic power grabs tend to be about things like this:
Quote:
The Pentagon has been using a little-known power to obtain banking and credit records of hundreds of Americans and others suspected of terrorism or espionage inside the United States, part of an aggressive expansion by the military into domestic intelligence gathering.
(link to New York Times article)
Of course, what this is talking about like the Patriot Act is completely legal programs that have been used in the past. In addition it is not unusual in war-time for the U.S. government to use the powers available to it. During the Second World War it certainly did (and some extra-legal programs) to round up hundreds of German spies operating in the United States. Similarly today, it is not suprising the the administration would use methods available to fight terrorism within the United States.
George W. Bush will be out of power in two years. Another President, Republican or Democrat (my money would bet Democrat, although that could change based on events) will be sworn in.