friedmacguffins wrote:
Quote:
The post apocalyptic fantasies ignore the fact that large numbers of people know how to use pre-digital technology.
Firstly, there is a part of your mind, which doesn't know the differences, between fact and fiction. You share the road and basic amenities with them, every day.
?
I don't understand what you mean by this.
Quote:
Secondly, have you ever rendered assistance, during an emergency. Just a minor one. Most people don't know how to provide basics for themselves.
Yes, I trained in CPR and very basic first aid and used that training at work and in the street. It's true that many, perhaps most, don't know how to provide basics, but it's also true that many do, and those who do would be able to teach those who don't but are willing to learn. In an emergency, that would be many. I was in Manhattan during 9/11, contrary to the dog-eat-dog fantasies post-apocalypse people like to dwell on, everyone was extremely helpful and cooperative.
Quote:
For instance --
a drink, where there is no obvious water source.
(I am frequently thirsty, outside. People, on jobsites, don't remember to bring it, when it comes from the store or tap.)
lighting a fire
(Most people can barely use the matches.)
a source of calories, which takes less energy to obtain than it will provide for you.
(Lots of people can't make do, if you lay the ingredients, right in front of them.)
My outdoor/low tech survival experience has mostly been on the trails of the Green Mountains of Vermont. I can make a fire and find and purify water. Calories can be more of a challenge depending on the time of year. But I know a lot of people who have the old skills and would be willing to teach in the event of some catastrophe.
In addition to the "Whole Earth Catalog" people in VT who use wood stoves, grow crops, dig wells, run water and windmills and so forth, there are communities like the Amish and Mennonite farmers who maintain a lot of 18th/19th century agricultural skill, and loads of "off grid communities" that are civilized but carry the knowledge of pre-digital or pre-combustion engine ways of living.
It seems to me that while there might be catastrophes that would kill many, there wuold almost certainly also survivors who would rebuild civilization with tools and skills appropriate to the new circumstances.
_________________
Don't believe the gender note under my avatar. A WP bug means I can't fix it.