MizLiz wrote:
My post wasn't about bioethics: it was about whether or not Gareth Nelson, who has been praised by the "elites" of this world (I think Simon Baron-Cohen had some wonderful things to say about him), was encouraging the people on his site to break the law.
He was.
What a dick.
Let's say I'm a carrier for hemophilia. I know for a fact that some of my eggs contain the gene Now, if I personally didn't see something like that to be all that bad of a thing (thinking that if more hemophiliacs were brought into the world, then more research would be done and so on), do I then donate an egg without telling the parents just because I'm on some kind of f**** up agenda?
Not saying it's the same thing, but I *am* saying that if the law says that you disclose, then you disclose.
And a previous poster was right. Just because the donor sperm came from a man with AS doesn't mean the child won't be lower on the spectrum. LFA people (and AS people... though I don't extend that attitude to people like Nelson) deserve to live, but a lot of parents just aren't prepared for that.
Basically, anyone following Nelson's advice is going to get sued. Then again, a lot of the people on that site appear to be self-diagnosed so there's no way to prove they knew. In fact, I believe he himself said "that's just another reason not to get a diagnosis"
The mind of this man... I've often doubted he was on the spectrum and wondered if he was more of a sociopath.
But it's different. When you have a disease you should tell someone, AS is completely different then Hemophilia.