Chronos wrote:
Just for future reference to those who intend on traveling to Russia, though any airplane can crash, it might be something to keep in mind that Russian airliners do not fly in American air space because they do not meet FAA safety regulations.
You are most certainly incorrect in this.
The IL-96, Tu-204 and Yak-42 (the type involved in this incident) all certainly overfly the US, since Cubana is an operator of all three types and they have used the types for Canadian and European operations. The Tu-204 is routinely seen at Pearson and the Yak-42 at Halifax.
The Sukhoi Superjet and Tu-204 are both on track for EASA type certification, which is certainly indicative that they would receive type certification by the FAA were an operator to request it. At least one North American carrier has placed firm orders for the Sukhoi bird (although operating exclusively in Mexico and Central America, for now).
While not airliners, both the An-225 and An-124 both operate into the US (in fact, the US military has used An-124's to airlift equipment to Afghanistan).
It's important to distinguish between design flaws, and operational performance. The Soviets were actually very strong on the former--designing aircraft that could operate in a huge range of very challenging conditions. It is in the latter that they demonstrated themselves to be vulnerable, losing many airframes to pilot error (both poor training and poor cockpit management), maintenance and poor government oversight.
In that sense, one is just as safe on an Aeroflot IL-96 as one is on an Aeroflot 777. But when one descends into the murk of small, domestic operators in the former Soviet Union, one encounters the fly-by-night (pun intended) operators who do not maintain their aircraft or train their crews properly. One would be as much at risk on a DC-9 or older generation 737 operated by one of these carriers as one would be on a Tu-134 or a Yak-42.
It's not about the flying on a Soviet designed plane--it's about flying on a Russian maintained, fuelled and operated plane.
_________________
--James