Suicide is painless
OliveOilMom
Veteran
Joined: 11 Nov 2011
Age: 62
Gender: Female
Posts: 11,447
Location: About 50 miles past the middle of nowhere
Actually, the song itself "Suicide Is Painless" reminds me of nachos.
Dead people don't though.
_________________
I'm giving it another shot. We will see.
My forum is still there and everyone is welcome to come join as well. There is a private women only subforum there if anyone is interested. Also, there is no CAPTCHA.
The link to the forum is http://www.rightplanet.proboards.com
In my opinion, those who commit suicide or murder are either narcissistic or sociopathic. They're both centered on themselves and end up doing something that is traumatic to others. Of course, my opinion, being subjective, may be invalid; but aren't all subjective opinions that way?
Have you ever been depressed?
That's the thing- depression is in a sense an extremely perverse ailment. Most lethal conditions kill in their own right- by creating an environment in which the brain cannot be supplied sufficient oxygen, causing death. For example, heart attacks kill because the brain is deprived of oxygen when the circulatory system is compromised.
Depression is different. It kills by making its sufferer kill him or herself by using self-violence to deprive the brain of oxygen. Perverse. Monstrous. That is why I think depression is the most disturbing, sick ailment of all time.
I do not think you can judge depressed people on the same standards as non-depressed folk. It's not fair.
OliveOilMom
Veteran
Joined: 11 Nov 2011
Age: 62
Gender: Female
Posts: 11,447
Location: About 50 miles past the middle of nowhere
I do understand how someone feels that way. I've tried it before myself.
I didn't mean to be smug at all.
I only wanted to voice the huge pain that others feel after someone they love does that. I thought of it because of so many on here talking about suicide.
I do think that if people truly want to do it, there should be easier and less painful ways of it. Doctor assisted. But only after they have talked to those who will be devistated by it, or who will bury them.
If I had a seriously painful incurable disease, I would probably opt out before the pain got just too bad. Then again, I might not. I know that for myself it was the idea of commiting suicide moreso than the fact of actually dying that was the lure. I'm not saying that everyone else feels this way. I'm only saying I did.
I can really only try to understand someone else's experience by looking at it with my own experiences. Thats all that most of us (humans, not use those of us on the spectrum) can do.
_________________
I'm giving it another shot. We will see.
My forum is still there and everyone is welcome to come join as well. There is a private women only subforum there if anyone is interested. Also, there is no CAPTCHA.
The link to the forum is http://www.rightplanet.proboards.com
I have arthritis. I've been injured in falls and beatings. I've received several electrical shocks, one of which stopped my heart, and another which re-started it. I am in constant pain, and often sleep less than 4 hours out of 24 because of it.
My father physically and emotionally abused me. I have been mugged and beaten. I've experienced first-hand the deprivations of military service and battlefield conditions.
I know chronic and intense pain, both physical and emotional.
I have not committed nor even attempted suicide.
Pain is inevitable. Misery is a choice.
Are you for real?
I purposefully left the thread title ambigious so that maybe those who are suicidal will read it.
Now, I won't try and talk you out of it. Hell, I've thought of it before. I've tried it, but apparantly I suck at it. Now, if you want to off yourself, go ahead and go get your pills ready, or load your gun or sharpen your knife but just read this first. Cause it's not about you. Or your feelings.
Yes it is.
Yes
Yeah, you're that important. Is that REALLY HOW you want to be remembered?
When you do successfully carry out this mission (if you choose to accept it) you will have a huge impact on everybody who even vaguely knew you.
They will have horrible guilt and anger and sadness.
But you wont be there to enjoy it.
Enjoy it???????????? Why would anybody enjoy it?
No
What happened was, was this.
I finally stopped talking to him. He apprantly (I know this from his own notes left by him in the freaking mail to me delivered the Monday after his death!! !!) thought he was going to go out like Socrates his hero, or some romantic Shakesperean dude. Well, he didnt. Know how he died?
He snorted a whole buttload of Ketamine then he drank a pint of whiskey then the cut his wrists. That didn't kill him. Know what did? Choking on his own vomit. His mother found him in his room puking and chocking. She called 911. Oh he was conscious. I talked to the doctors. I talked to his preacher who came up there even. He was talking and conscious but they couldn't oxygenate him. He had soaked his own lungs with vomit to the point that he couldn't breathe.
He was there right up until the end. He said "Mama stay with me" Then he breathed real hard a lot and then he died. There was nothing they could do. His mother had to stand there and watch that.
Real romantic suicide huh?
I doubt that his intentions were to be romantic.
I had a lot of therapy after.
Heres the thing though. That you folks might want to know.
It's been 21 years this May. May 26th actually. Know what I remember? Not some romantic notion. Not something I should have done. I remember the pain he threw at me from the freaking grave. The hurt. The depression! I don't remember HIM ever, when his name comes up, I remember the pain I felt at his death!
In other words, it did not turn out the way he wanted.
Ever thought that it may not have been just about you?
I do visit his grave, once a year, on his death. I tell him "kiss my a** you have no power over me now!"
The fact that you have to do this every year suggests otherwise.
How do you know what he wanted?
It never does.
So, do you just want to end your pain, or do you just want to screw everybody else up?
It's up to you.
The song says suicide is painless, and it might be. For you.
But its damn sure not for us!
Yes because that's what I would be thinking if I was on the brink of suicide, what would this uncaring witch think after I am gone?
I have arthritis. I've been injured in falls and beatings. I've received several electrical shocks, one of which stopped my heart, and another which re-started it. I am in constant pain, and often sleep less than 4 hours out of 24 because of it.
My father physically and emotionally abused me. I have been mugged and beaten. I've experienced first-hand the deprivations of military service and battlefield conditions.
I know chronic and intense pain, both physical and emotional.
I have not committed nor even attempted suicide.
Pain is inevitable. Misery is a choice.
Good for you Fnord, you have once again proved how tough and non empathetic you are.
OliveOilMom
Veteran
Joined: 11 Nov 2011
Age: 62
Gender: Female
Posts: 11,447
Location: About 50 miles past the middle of nowhere
Yep
I purposefully left the thread title ambigious so that maybe those who are suicidal will read it.
Now, I won't try and talk you out of it. Hell, I've thought of it before. I've tried it, but apparantly I suck at it. Now, if you want to off yourself, go ahead and go get your pills ready, or load your gun or sharpen your knife but just read this first. Cause it's not about you. Or your feelings.
Yes it is.
This thread isn't. It's for those left here.
Yes
I bet you are wrong, that people do care. You just can't feel it when you are that depressed. I know I couldn't
Yeah, you're that important. Is that REALLY HOW you want to be remembered?
When you do successfully carry out this mission (if you choose to accept it) you will have a huge impact on everybody who even vaguely knew you.
They will have horrible guilt and anger and sadness.
But you wont be there to enjoy it.
Enjoy it???????????? Why would anybody enjoy it?
Sometimes suicidal gestures or attempts that actually succeed are gestures to make others see how actually bad their pain is. That's why.
No
Did this really need a seperate answer? It was rhetorical.[b]
What happened was, was this.
I finally stopped talking to him. He apprantly (I know this from his own notes left by him in the freaking mail to me delivered the Monday after his death!! !!) thought he was going to go out like Socrates his hero, or some romantic Shakesperean dude. Well, he didnt. Know how he died?
He snorted a whole buttload of Ketamine then he drank a pint of whiskey then the cut his wrists. That didn't kill him. Know what did? Choking on his own vomit. His mother found him in his room puking and chocking. She called 911. Oh he was conscious. I talked to the doctors. I talked to his preacher who came up there even. He was talking and conscious but they couldn't oxygenate him. He had soaked his own lungs with vomit to the point that he couldn't breathe.
He was there right up until the end. He said "Mama stay with me" Then he breathed real hard a lot and then he died. There was nothing they could do. His mother had to stand there and watch that.
Real romantic suicide huh?
I doubt that his intentions were to be romantic.
Thats not what his letters said.
I had a lot of therapy after.
Heres the thing though. That you folks might want to know.
It's been 21 years this May. May 26th actually. Know what I remember? Not some romantic notion. Not something I should have done. I remember the pain he threw at me from the freaking grave. The hurt. The depression! I don't remember HIM ever, when his name comes up, I remember the pain I felt at his death!
In other words, it did not turn out the way he wanted.
Ever thought that it may not have been just about you?
I do visit his grave, once a year, on his death. I tell him "kiss my a** you have no power over me now!"
The fact that you have to do this every year suggests otherwise.
How do you know what he wanted?
From his letters.
It never does.
So, do you just want to end your pain, or do you just want to screw everybody else up?
It's up to you.
The song says suicide is painless, and it might be. For you.
But its damn sure not for us!
Yes because that's what I would be thinking if I was on the brink of suicide, what would this uncaring witch think after I am gone?

I doubt you and I would be friends so close that I would feel that over you. I'm not saying at all that you don't deserve that kind of compassion and love, I'm just saying I bet we wouldn't hit it off to begin with. So I doubt I would ever be an issue to you in that kind of a big decision.
But I bet there are some who would.
My point is, that one person's suicide can really mess up many other people's lives. And if you do care about them so much, ie; "they would be better off without me" reasoning, then why wouldn't you truly consider the feelings they will actually have after? This is not a blanket statement.[b]
_________________
I'm giving it another shot. We will see.
My forum is still there and everyone is welcome to come join as well. There is a private women only subforum there if anyone is interested. Also, there is no CAPTCHA.
The link to the forum is http://www.rightplanet.proboards.com
My father physically and emotionally abused me. I have been mugged and beaten. I've experienced first-hand the deprivations of military service and battlefield conditions. I know chronic and intense pain, both physical and emotional. I have not committed nor even attempted suicide. Pain is inevitable. Misery is a choice.
Virtuous aspects, indeed!
The alternatives would be "weak" and "sensitive" - two traits common to losers.
OliveOilMom
Veteran
Joined: 11 Nov 2011
Age: 62
Gender: Female
Posts: 11,447
Location: About 50 miles past the middle of nowhere
My father physically and emotionally abused me. I have been mugged and beaten. I've experienced first-hand the deprivations of military service and battlefield conditions. I know chronic and intense pain, both physical and emotional. I have not committed nor even attempted suicide. Pain is inevitable. Misery is a choice.
Virtuous aspects, indeed!
The alternatives would be "weak" and "sensitive" - two traits common to losers.
I wouldnt say that all those who are weak or sensitive are losers. I'd say that they have different abilities than we might. Someone who you might consider a loser might be able to talk to an actual suicidal person better than you or I might. I would say thats probably pretty successful then.
_________________
I'm giving it another shot. We will see.
My forum is still there and everyone is welcome to come join as well. There is a private women only subforum there if anyone is interested. Also, there is no CAPTCHA.
The link to the forum is http://www.rightplanet.proboards.com
I have worked at two suicide hotlines - one in America, and one at an overseas military base. In both cases, I was taught the "Empathy Model", where the counselor (1) paraphrases and repeats back what the caller has stated, (2) identifies the caller's emotions with phrases like "You seems to be feeling _________" ("anger", "anxiety", "sorrow", et cetera), and (3) guides them toward a resolution with phrases like, "When someone does ________ to me, I usually ________" ("insult me / ignore it", "threaten me / laugh it off" et cetera)
Empathy is as easy to fake as sincerity, and usually people just want someone to acknowledge their feelings and affirm their existence.
Last edited by Fnord on 22 Jan 2012, 7:28 pm, edited 2 times in total.
My father physically and emotionally abused me. I have been mugged and beaten. I've experienced first-hand the deprivations of military service and battlefield conditions. I know chronic and intense pain, both physical and emotional. I have not committed nor even attempted suicide. Pain is inevitable. Misery is a choice.
Virtuous aspects, indeed!
The alternatives would be "weak" and "sensitive" - two traits common to losers.
OH and god forbid anybody ever thought of you as weak, sensitive or a loser! wouldn't want that now would we?
Your tough guy shtick is getting old.
I think it's probably a false notion that all suicidal people are doing it to 'get back' at someone. (Not that the OP specifically said that.) Personally, I've never understood the point of leaving a note. If I thought there was anyone who would care to read a note I probably wouldn't contemplate offing myself in the first place. OTOH, depression does tend to convince you that nobody cares or will care. Then again, not everyone has connections to the world. In ten years I expect to be down to zero, and if I do off myself no one who ever knew me will know about it.
Side-thought re: Layne Staley -- it seems like it would be hard to afford that much heroin and coke unless you were a rich musician like he was. I also recall that he said something like he didn't want his life to end the way that it was going to (and did) -- he just didn't see a way out of his addiction problems.
While I agree with the notion that there is not a single rational thing in actually going through with suicide or attempting suicide, the simple fact of the matter is that there is nothing rational about wanting to kill yourself. When you're in such a state of mind, logic vanishes and the power of negative emotion takes over. Thus far, I've been fortunate as the moments I've felt myself in such a frame-of-mind have been overtaken by the thoughts of the pain I'd leave behind. What I worry about most is the impulse ... the moment of swinging my car towards a tractor-trailer or putting a gun in my mouth before logic has a chance to grab me and slap me in the face. I've gone through long periods of my life where such thoughts are completely absent and other periods where I just can't shake them no matter how hard I try. Depression is an illness and minimizing it's power is like dismissing the power that any other major illness can have in ending your existence.
