Page 11 of 12 [ 183 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1 ... 8, 9, 10, 11, 12  Next

OliveOilMom
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 11 Nov 2011
Age: 62
Gender: Female
Posts: 11,447
Location: About 50 miles past the middle of nowhere

12 Jan 2012, 12:47 pm

What I am asking is, what can we do that will help you feel better?


_________________
I'm giving it another shot. We will see.
My forum is still there and everyone is welcome to come join as well. There is a private women only subforum there if anyone is interested. Also, there is no CAPTCHA. ;-)

The link to the forum is http://www.rightplanet.proboards.com


Sweetleaf
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 6 Jan 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Female
Posts: 35,278
Location: Somewhere in Colorado

12 Jan 2012, 12:53 pm

OliveOilMom wrote:
What I am asking is, what can we do that will help you feel better?


I don't really know exactly.....as I've said I try to be open to advice and support/understanding can be nice, but I don't really know of anything more specific. I mean if I had all the answers I probably would not feel the need to post these threads.


_________________
Tis the time to melt the Ice.


OliveOilMom
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 11 Nov 2011
Age: 62
Gender: Female
Posts: 11,447
Location: About 50 miles past the middle of nowhere

12 Jan 2012, 1:11 pm

I've been extremely depressed before, where I saw no hope. I've been there several times. When I'm there, it's like I'm in the mddle of a pitch black labrynth underground and there is one way out, but many false paths. Everytime I try something, it turns out to be a false path. Eventually, I give up hope. I don't want to wander in the dark down those dark corridors, feeling my way along, in pain, only to run into a wall at the end of it instead of seeing a glimmer of light. Doing that makes me feel more hopeless. It gets to a point where I don't want to try, because when it doesn't work, I end up hurting worse.

It sounds to me like that is where you are.

The therapists that didn't work with you, the meds that you tried that didn't work, everything you have tried that didn't work, those are the false exits. I've tried many meds, some didn't work, some made me suicidal. I've been to many therapists and actually only found two in all these years that I actually liked. I've been to some real jerks before. I actually told one of them, halfway through the session that his New Age bs was a crock of sh*t and got up and walked out.

But if I hadn't gone down those false paths, if I hadn't tried, and tried again and again, I would have never found the true exit. The one combination of meds, and the right therapist, that helps me feel better when I get to that point.

You have said several times that you drink and smoke weed to help. I totally feel you on that. Well, not on the weed, I'm one of those people that weed is horrible for. It makes me depressed and paranoid and I hate it, but I'm the unusual one for that, because it makes most people happy and chills them out. I am guilty of sometimes drinking to stop the pain for a while. I know that when I wake up the next day I will feel worse, and it takes me three days to feel halfway normal again and not wish I was dead, but that doesn't stop me from drinking that bottle (yeah, the whole bottle, when I do something I do it up good) because those few hours of being pain free are more tempting than staying in the limbo that I'm in, even though I know I'll pay worse for those few hours later. I'm trying not to do that right now. I won't today, I can't tell you for sure about tomorrow though. I'll deal with tomorrow when it comes.

So, I do understand your feelings about booze and weed.

I know when I get to the point you are at, where I'm overwhelmed and have no hope, I want somebody to step in and make it better. Nobody can make my situation or my depression better but me. A doctor can help by giving me the script, a therapist can help by listening and talking to me and helping me see my feelings and situation and actions differently. But I have to be willing to try. I had to be willing to try the meds that were horrible, and risk another horrible med, and keep going until I found the one that worked. I had to be willing to deal with the jerks in the psych profession until I found one that wasn't a jerk. Yes, it can be more painful, and very exhausting. It can get worse for a while. But, if you don't get help and at least try then six months from now you will be right where you are now. If you do try and nothing has worked, you won't have lost anything if you are still where you are now in six months. However, I think that with continual trying and seeing a doctor and being open to meds, that in six months you will be better.

Have you thought about a hospital for a few days or so to find the right meds and get them regulated? Even without insurance, if you tell them you are suicidal, they have to admit you and treat you. You could get the help you need there.

There are always reasons not to do something, and reasons that we can't do something, but many of those reasons can be overcome. Depression makes obstacles look insurmountable. Everything seems worse than it is and problems seem bigger than they are. It's natural to feel overwhelmed about them.

Have you thought about telling your mother that you are very depressed and want some help and see if she can help you see a doctor?

That's really the only thing I know to do and I do wish I knew more, but that's all I've got. I do hope it helps and I do hope you find a way out of this horrible place you are in.


_________________
I'm giving it another shot. We will see.
My forum is still there and everyone is welcome to come join as well. There is a private women only subforum there if anyone is interested. Also, there is no CAPTCHA. ;-)

The link to the forum is http://www.rightplanet.proboards.com


hyperlexian
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 21 Jul 2010
Age: 54
Gender: Female
Posts: 22,023
Location: with bucephalus

12 Jan 2012, 1:18 pm

Sweetleaf, when members give you support, does it reach you? you had quite a few members in this thread and in your other threads who gave you some straightforward encouragement, but did it help you at all?


_________________
on a break, so if you need assistance please contact another moderator from this list:
viewtopic.php?t=391105


Sweetleaf
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 6 Jan 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Female
Posts: 35,278
Location: Somewhere in Colorado

12 Jan 2012, 2:56 pm

OliveOilMom wrote:
I've been extremely depressed before, where I saw no hope. I've been there several times. When I'm there, it's like I'm in the mddle of a pitch black labrynth underground and there is one way out, but many false paths. Everytime I try something, it turns out to be a false path. Eventually, I give up hope. I don't want to wander in the dark down those dark corridors, feeling my way along, in pain, only to run into a wall at the end of it instead of seeing a glimmer of light. Doing that makes me feel more hopeless. It gets to a point where I don't want to try, because when it doesn't work, I end up hurting worse.

It sounds to me like that is where you are.

The therapists that didn't work with you, the meds that you tried that didn't work, everything you have tried that didn't work, those are the false exits. I've tried many meds, some didn't work, some made me suicidal. I've been to many therapists and actually only found two in all these years that I actually liked. I've been to some real jerks before. I actually told one of them, halfway through the session that his New Age bs was a crock of sh*t and got up and walked out.

But if I hadn't gone down those false paths, if I hadn't tried, and tried again and again, I would have never found the true exit. The one combination of meds, and the right therapist, that helps me feel better when I get to that point.

Well true the only way to find out if something works is to try it, but under no circumstance would I be willing to try any SSRIS, now something like Xanax i could probably tolerate but the SSRIs just made me anxious and psychotic. But then of course I don't know the psychiatrist/psychologist would agree with my reasoning that I more need something to calm down not to do whatever it was the SSRIS were doing.

You have said several times that you drink and smoke weed to help. I totally feel you on that. Well, not on the weed, I'm one of those people that weed is horrible for. It makes me depressed and paranoid and I hate it, but I'm the unusual one for that, because it makes most people happy and chills them out. I am guilty of sometimes drinking to stop the pain for a while. I know that when I wake up the next day I will feel worse, and it takes me three days to feel halfway normal again and not wish I was dead, but that doesn't stop me from drinking that bottle (yeah, the whole bottle, when I do something I do it up good) because those few hours of being pain free are more tempting than staying in the limbo that I'm in, even though I know I'll pay worse for those few hours later. I'm trying not to do that right now. I won't today, I can't tell you for sure about tomorrow though. I'll deal with tomorrow when it comes.

So, I do understand your feelings about booze and weed.

Yes that is pretty much how it goes, though I am trying to just stick to weed for 'killing the pain' that usually turns out better in the long run for me then if i try and use alcohol for it. But yeah my natural state of being consists of feeling on edge, anxious and severely self concious and sensative then at the age of 20 I found regularly smoking cannabis greatly reduced it. Lately I've just been feeling guility about everything so that's interfering but I'll get over it I'm sure.

I know when I get to the point you are at, where I'm overwhelmed and have no hope, I want somebody to step in and make it better. Nobody can make my situation or my depression better but me. A doctor can help by giving me the script, a therapist can help by listening and talking to me and helping me see my feelings and situation and actions differently. But I have to be willing to try. I had to be willing to try the meds that were horrible, and risk another horrible med, and keep going until I found the one that worked. I had to be willing to deal with the jerks in the psych profession until I found one that wasn't a jerk. Yes, it can be more painful, and very exhausting. It can get worse for a while. But, if you don't get help and at least try then six months from now you will be right where you are now. If you do try and nothing has worked, you won't have lost anything if you are still where you are now in six months. However, I think that with continual trying and seeing a doctor and being open to meds, that in six months you will be better.

Well I've decided to re-apply for disability and I have a friend who can help some, so if that works out then maybe I can afford to actually talk to a psychiatrist or something. Though it would be easier to get on disability if I had already done that but it comes back to not being able to afford it. Also, I would be open to trying anxiety meds since as a rule as much as the depression sucks I have been dealing with it so long I'm used to it so its not my most dehabilitating problem the on edge, tense, anxious state I tend to be and there's been lots of times when I have anxiety attacks in public or when I was walking to class at the college and end up having to go hide in a bathroom till I can calm down. But yeah after my experiance on Prozac I don't even want to be in the same room as someone who tells me I should take SSRIs.

Have you thought about a hospital for a few days or so to find the right meds and get them regulated? Even without insurance, if you tell them you are suicidal, they have to admit you and treat you. You could get the help you need there.

I've considered it but I am even more uncomfortable with that then the interactions applying for disability will probably require...but yeah I suppose if I can't figure anything else out I might not have much of a choice.

There are always reasons not to do something, and reasons that we can't do something, but many of those reasons can be overcome. Depression makes obstacles look insurmountable. Everything seems worse than it is and problems seem bigger than they are. It's natural to feel overwhelmed about them.

Have you thought about telling your mother that you are very depressed and want some help and see if she can help you see a doctor?

That's really the only thing I know to do and I do wish I knew more, but that's all I've got. I do hope it helps and I do hope you find a way out of this horrible place you are in.


Also my mom knows about my depression, PTSD and anxiety and the AS self diagnoses confirmed by a therapist but still not official.....but she tends to do more harm then good when she tries to help. She did try that and when I called the number it seems the services offered were not what I was looking for according to them when I told them I was looking to start some sort of diagnoses process because they only offered counseling. So yeah there is not a whole lot she could help me with, and in fact being around her and her boyfriend makes me paranoid....because I don't trust them to keep my best intrests in mind should they try and 'help.'


_________________
Tis the time to melt the Ice.


Sweetleaf
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 6 Jan 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Female
Posts: 35,278
Location: Somewhere in Colorado

12 Jan 2012, 3:10 pm

hyperlexian wrote:
Sweetleaf, when members give you support, does it reach you? you had quite a few members in this thread and in your other threads who gave you some straightforward encouragement, but did it help you at all?


Well it makes me feel a little better and then I seem more able to actually try and think more about some of the advice people give. I mean I pretty much have no self esteem so its hard for me to take any advice if I feel like there's no support...so yeah it does help me some.


_________________
Tis the time to melt the Ice.


OliveOilMom
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 11 Nov 2011
Age: 62
Gender: Female
Posts: 11,447
Location: About 50 miles past the middle of nowhere

12 Jan 2012, 3:43 pm

I would like to point out that all SSRI's are different. Prozac did nothing for me at all. Other SSRI's have made me worse, and made me suicidal. Some helped a tiny bit but not much. It's the particular drug itself that does the job or doesn't do th job. Some have horrible side effects with some people, while others have hardly any. You cannot judge all SSRI's by one particular drug. It's the same as with Benzo's. Valium makes me horribly depressed, Clonopin gives me panic attacks, Ativan does nothing at all, while Xanax stops panic and anxiety in its tracks for me. The class of drugs (SSRI) is just the class, it's not the particular drug. They all work differently. I really encourage you to do some research into that.

I understand being afraid of trying something similar if you had a bad reaction to one, especially your first one. There are other antidepressants out there that may help, the tricyclics are still prescribed but they are usually much more sedating. Either way, I would discuss the options and the fear of another bad reaction with a doctor.

I believe Prozac was the first, or one of the first, SSRI's on the market. They have really advanced since then.

Also, about self esteem. I struggle with that too. This is going to sound really corny, but nobody can help your self esteem except you. I looked for years for someone or something to help me have some self esteem and as a result I made some horrible choices. What works for me is to try and look my best, (because I tend to focus on that for myself, for you it might be something different and more action oriented) and when I notice that I am thinking something negative about myself I stop the thought by telling myself "stop" in my head and then say the opposite in my head to myself, even though I don't believe it at the time. It sounds simple, but it does help, to a point.

Positve feedback is very important, but it's not as important as the feedback you give yourself. Try acting as if you were the person you want to be. As if you had the things going for you that you feel that you don't have. Stop negative thinking when you notice it and tell yourself something positive even if you don't believe it. It doesn't work overnight, it takes persistance which is very difficult when you feel that there is no use in doing anything or trying anything, but it does help somewhat.


_________________
I'm giving it another shot. We will see.
My forum is still there and everyone is welcome to come join as well. There is a private women only subforum there if anyone is interested. Also, there is no CAPTCHA. ;-)

The link to the forum is http://www.rightplanet.proboards.com


Sweetleaf
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 6 Jan 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Female
Posts: 35,278
Location: Somewhere in Colorado

12 Jan 2012, 4:13 pm

OliveOilMom wrote:
I would like to point out that all SSRI's are different. Prozac did nothing for me at all. Other SSRI's have made me worse, and made me suicidal. Some helped a tiny bit but not much. It's the particular drug itself that does the job or doesn't do th job. Some have horrible side effects with some people, while others have hardly any. You cannot judge all SSRI's by one particular drug. It's the same as with Benzo's. Valium makes me horribly depressed, Clonopin gives me panic attacks, Ativan does nothing at all, while Xanax stops panic and anxiety in its tracks for me. The class of drugs (SSRI) is just the class, it's not the particular drug. They all work differently. I really encourage you to do some research into that.

I understand being afraid of trying something similar if you had a bad reaction to one, especially your first one. There are other antidepressants out there that may help, the tricyclics are still prescribed but they are usually much more sedating. Either way, I would discuss the options and the fear of another bad reaction with a doctor.

I believe Prozac was the first, or one of the first, SSRI's on the market. They have really advanced since then.

I have looked into SSRIs there are differences between them but they are simular types of medications, so they are bound to have simular effects. based on what the prozac did and what I have read on other SSRIs I would not get much benefit. Not to mention I am not sure SSRIs are safe with my lifestyle....SSRIs also have nasty side effects and from what I've read they would interfere with a few things I don't particularly want interfered with. but as I said if there is anything that could help with the constant tense on edge feeling or when it gets to the point of an anxiety attack then I'd be willing to try it but I have no intrest in anti-depressants.

Also, about self esteem. I struggle with that too. This is going to sound really corny, but nobody can help your self esteem except you. I looked for years for someone or something to help me have some self esteem and as a result I made some horrible choices. What works for me is to try and look my best, (because I tend to focus on that for myself, for you it might be something different and more action oriented) and when I notice that I am thinking something negative about myself I stop the thought by telling myself "stop" in my head and then say the opposite in my head to myself, even though I don't believe it at the time. It sounds simple, but it does help, to a point.

Well yeah something like that could help, but it seems like my attempts at stopping negative thoughts about myself tend to fail....I have a very hard time stopping my thought process sometimes I feel like I'm fighting myself over it. But yeah maybe i need to try and do that more and it might work better.

Positve feedback is very important, but it's not as important as the feedback you give yourself. Try acting as if you were the person you want to be. As if you had the things going for you that you feel that you don't have. Stop negative thinking when you notice it and tell yourself something positive even if you don't believe it. It doesn't work overnight, it takes persistance which is very difficult when you feel that there is no use in doing anything or trying anything, but it does help somewhat.


And this is probably true....however I am not quite sure what the person I want to be is and am not so sure I can imagine how it would feel to have things going for me because I've never really experianced that. Also as much as I try to stop any negative thinking it almost seems to just bring more on so I would love to just stop negative thinking but I don't know that I can honestly...do you know of any ways to do that?


_________________
Tis the time to melt the Ice.


thedaywalker
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 26 Nov 2008
Age: 33
Gender: Male
Posts: 736

12 Jan 2012, 5:02 pm

sweatleaf maybe start wondering from within what gives happynis. try and grasp the feeling of what you should be doing and do it instead of looking at things you could do and evalutating them.



Sweetleaf
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 6 Jan 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Female
Posts: 35,278
Location: Somewhere in Colorado

12 Jan 2012, 5:12 pm

thedaywalker wrote:
sweatleaf maybe start wondering from within what gives happynis. try and grasp the feeling of what you should be doing and do it instead of looking at things you could do and evalutating them.


That might help some, I mean who gets to say what I should be doing anyways other then myself...it really is kinda my choice what I feel I should be doing, but yeah I kinda get too concerned with what others think sometimes and end up feeling unsure of myself.


_________________
Tis the time to melt the Ice.


Kelspook
Sea Gull
Sea Gull

User avatar

Joined: 6 Jun 2011
Age: 52
Gender: Female
Posts: 222
Location: Scotland

15 Jan 2012, 7:34 am

Wow, this thread is long. Having now gotten to the end of it, I want to add my own opinion. I'm not a psychiatrist, I'm just speaking from experience of coming into contact with people who are depressed/self harming/suicidal on a very regular basis during my working day. It's far more common that many people realise.

To the original question, I'd say that being a victim of something isn't a choice, but what you do after that, to a degree, is. In order for a person to be helped, they have to want that help. If you don't want to be helped, then nothing anyone says is going to have any impact whatsoever, and they will remain in that hopeless, depressive cycle. The first step is always to desire change.

Sweetleaf, in my view you seem to be in a complete vicious cycle, and I'm sorry, but the use of cannabis and alcohol are probably perpetuating it. Yes, smoking cigarettes is bad for you. But in your apparent situation, I would say that cannabis and alcohol are a thousand times worse.

Please don't get me wrong. I'm not preaching at you, I just wanted to give you some relevant information and advice. What you do with it is up to you, you're an adult.

I know that isn't what you want to hear, but it's scientific fact backed up by many years of medical research. Both of those substances are depressants, and cannabis is also widely known to cause anxiety and paranoia. Clicky below for more information- and the info isn't from wikipedia or anything like that, is from the Royal College of Psychiatrists, one of the leading bodies in the UK.

First, how cannabis can cause problems in people with mental illness:-

Cannabis and mental health

and secondly how alcohol and having depression can be self perpetuating:-

Alcohol and Depression

Try for a day at first. Then for two days. Then three. Go for walks outside when you think you can handle it, or if you're finding you have too much nervous energy. Do have special interests? Try focusing on those.

I reckon the main thing you're doing to yourself is expecting to fix everything at once. That's unrealistic, and setting yourself up for failure. This is why most peoples "get fit and healthy" plans fail. They try to change too many things at once and it's unsustainable. Pick out one aspect that you want to improve, and work on that.

Hope you get something from all that.



Tequila
Veteran
Veteran

Joined: 25 Feb 2006
Age: 38
Gender: Male
Posts: 28,897
Location: Lancashire, UK

15 Jan 2012, 9:02 am

Kelspook wrote:
Clicky below for more information- and the info isn't from wikipedia or anything like that, is from the Royal College of Psychiatrists, one of the leading bodies in the UK.


I wouldn't trust a whole lot of what the RCP say, mainly because they are prohibitionist (like many other UK bodies) when it comes to alcohol - i.e. making judgements that aren't really their damned business - and they have written some rubbish in the past. Also, I don't like psychiatrists much anyway - I think they are often quite useless if not harmful, but that's just my experience.

Yes, I believe Sweetleaf really would probably be best off cutting out the alcohol and the cannabis. Not only that, but alcohol can and does badly mess up people on medication anyway whether through all the various reactions but by far the most common one is that it makes depression worse (as it did with me). Alcohol is an absolutely fantastic substance and I believe that it is far too much maligned in our society... but it needs to be had at the right time mentally. Alcohol misuse isn't good. I drank when I was on medication before (and still do) and it hasn't given me any really bad after-effects but it can do if you're on a very heavy dose. Mainly it's dangerous because you don't know how it'll interact with other things you're taking. Different things work for different people in different ways.

Getting her medication sorted out will also help too.

Like I have been saying, Sweetleaf is in a depressive cycle where her thoughts - and thus her view of the world - are badly skewed. I'm not saying this like I don't have experience (and the one thing that grates me a bit is that she seems to think that only her experience of depression is the only one that counts!) - I have been depressed several times myself and my thoughts are and were messed-up at the time. I recovered though and got better, although I still do need to take medication during the winter months mainly.

Kelspook wrote:
Go for walks outside when you think you can handle it, or if you're finding you have too much nervous energy.


Only go places you can feel safe in - otherwise that will make you worse with all the worry and fear. If you live in a dodgy area, try travelling to somewhere you feel safer.



Kelspook
Sea Gull
Sea Gull

User avatar

Joined: 6 Jun 2011
Age: 52
Gender: Female
Posts: 222
Location: Scotland

15 Jan 2012, 11:58 am

Tequila wrote:
Kelspook wrote:
Clicky below for more information- and the info isn't from wikipedia or anything like that, is from the Royal College of Psychiatrists, one of the leading bodies in the UK.


I wouldn't trust a whole lot of what the RCP say, mainly because they are prohibitionist (like many other UK bodies) when it comes to alcohol - i.e. making judgements that aren't really their damned business - and they have written some rubbish in the past. Also, I don't like psychiatrists much anyway - I think they are often quite useless if not harmful, but that's just my experience.

Yes, I believe Sweetleaf really would probably be best off cutting out the alcohol and the cannabis. Not only that, but alcohol can and does badly mess up people on medication anyway whether through all the various reactions but by far the most common one is that it makes depression worse (as it did with me). Alcohol is an absolutely fantastic substance and I believe that it is far too much maligned in our society... but it needs to be had at the right time mentally. Alcohol misuse isn't good. I drank when I was on medication before (and still do) and it hasn't given me any really bad after-effects but it can do if you're on a very heavy dose. Mainly it's dangerous because you don't know how it'll interact with other things you're taking. Different things work for different people in different ways.

Getting her medication sorted out will also help too.

Like I have been saying, Sweetleaf is in a depressive cycle where her thoughts - and thus her view of the world - are badly skewed. I'm not saying this like I don't have experience (and the one thing that grates me a bit is that she seems to think that only her experience of depression is the only one that counts!) - I have been depressed several times myself and my thoughts are and were messed-up at the time. I recovered though and got better, although I still do need to take medication during the winter months mainly.

Kelspook wrote:
Go for walks outside when you think you can handle it, or if you're finding you have too much nervous energy.


Only go places you can feel safe in - otherwise that will make you worse with all the worry and fear. If you live in a dodgy area, try travelling to somewhere you feel safer.


These bodies are prohibitionist about alcohol for a reason, it has been scientifically PROVEN to makes things worse in people with clinical depression. They aren't being judgemental, they're giving people information to help themselves.

I can understand if you've personally had bother with psychiatrists in the past, but writing off an entire profession that has helped many, many people is hardly helpful in this case. Sweetleaf is clearly in need of help, and that attitude is rather unproductive. I used those links as it is a professional, educational body, not a site going on hearsay. I also had a look at the MIND website, and they say pretty much the same. (MIND, for those not from the UK, is a charity that assists mental health patients and tries to raise awareness and destigmatise mental disorders.)

MIND page on depression

Alcohol is harmful to the mental state of depressives, whether they are on medication or not.

Good point about safety. Even if you don't feel comfortable walking, you can still do exercise indoors, or in your yard if you have one. That 20 minutes of physical activity each day would possibly improve your state of mind is the thing I was getting at.

That cycle where it seems your in a black hole and there's no way out is very, very common. You just need to take the first step of contacting help, and want things to change, even if it doesn't seem possible from where you're at right now.

It can get better.



Tequila
Veteran
Veteran

Joined: 25 Feb 2006
Age: 38
Gender: Male
Posts: 28,897
Location: Lancashire, UK

15 Jan 2012, 12:05 pm

Kelspook wrote:
These bodies are prohibitionist about alcohol for a reason, it has been scientifically PROVEN to makes things worse in people with clinical depression.


It does when they start telling everyone how to live their lives, that alcohol should be restricted, that alcohol prices should go up, that sinister warnings should be placed on the bottle and so on. That's when they can get stuffed, frankly. We have enough neo-prohibitionist loons in the world, thanks.

Quote:
They aren't being judgemental, they're giving people information to help themselves.


As long as it ends there and doesn't end up with them telling people how to live their lives, or, rather, giving 'advice'.

Quote:
I can understand if you've personally had bother with psychiatrists in the past


All the ones I've seen have been entirely useless and clueless and in one case was vaguely sinister.

How clueless? Let me see.

One psychiatrist categorically told me that I didn't have Asperger's and then asked me what Asperger's was! What a twat.

Quote:
Alcohol is harmful to the mental state of depressives, whether they are on medication or not.


True, and I don't disagree with you that they are best off not drinking (alcohol often accentuates your mood and state of mind, whatever that may be at the time) but at the end of the day it is their choice and theirs alone.

Quote:
That cycle where it seems your in a black hole and there's no way out is very, very common. You just need to take the first step of contacting help, and want things to change, even if it doesn't seem possible from where you're at right now.

It can get better.


Indeed. :)



Sweetleaf
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 6 Jan 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Female
Posts: 35,278
Location: Somewhere in Colorado

15 Jan 2012, 12:25 pm

Kelspook wrote:
Wow, this thread is long. Having now gotten to the end of it, I want to add my own opinion. I'm not a psychiatrist, I'm just speaking from experience of coming into contact with people who are depressed/self harming/suicidal on a very regular basis during my working day. It's far more common that many people realise.

To the original question, I'd say that being a victim of something isn't a choice, but what you do after that, to a degree, is. In order for a person to be helped, they have to want that help. If you don't want to be helped, then nothing anyone says is going to have any impact whatsoever, and they will remain in that hopeless, depressive cycle. The first step is always to desire change.

Sweetleaf, in my view you seem to be in a complete vicious cycle, and I'm sorry, but the use of cannabis and alcohol are probably perpetuating it. Yes, smoking cigarettes is bad for you. But in your apparent situation, I would say that cannabis and alcohol are a thousand times worse.

Please don't get me wrong. I'm not preaching at you, I just wanted to give you some relevant information and advice. What you do with it is up to you, you're an adult.

I know that isn't what you want to hear, but it's scientific fact backed up by many years of medical research. Both of those substances are depressants, and cannabis is also widely known to cause anxiety and paranoia. Clicky below for more information- and the info isn't from wikipedia or anything like that, is from the Royal College of Psychiatrists, one of the leading bodies in the UK.

First, how cannabis can cause problems in people with mental illness:-

Cannabis and mental health

and secondly how alcohol and having depression can be self perpetuating:-

Alcohol and Depression

Try for a day at first. Then for two days. Then three. Go for walks outside when you think you can handle it, or if you're finding you have too much nervous energy. Do have special interests? Try focusing on those.

I reckon the main thing you're doing to yourself is expecting to fix everything at once. That's unrealistic, and setting yourself up for failure. This is why most peoples "get fit and healthy" plans fail. They try to change too many things at once and it's unsustainable. Pick out one aspect that you want to improve, and work on that.

Hope you get something from all that.


There is not a whole lot to change from my perspective except maybe my living situation but kinda hard to do that when you're broke and have pretty much no chance of getting a job. So yeah where I am at is just trying to cope with what I have because I am worn out from trying to force myself to look forward to things I guess. But yes I realise if I wanted to maybe improve the depression, anxiety or PTSD I would have to really want to......and I guess I feel like theres not much reason to bother not to mention there is no garantee I'm going to be cured of any of it.

I know alcohol does not really help, and ciggerettes don't really do anything........and I am in fact working to cut down on alcohol I've not been doing to bad usually the best option is just not to buy any alcohol also if I do drink I should already be in an ok mood not drinking to reach this ok mood. That said I have to disagree about the cannabis.......that is the one thing that really does seem to reduce most of my symptoms with the least amount of negative consequences well besides the possible legal ones. I mean normally I am always on edge, stressed/anxious feeling and kinda irritable and painfully depressed if cannabis decreases that then I see it as a good thing. Also I have done my research so its not an uninformed decision to continue. Also CNS depressant not depressant in the sense it would 'cause' depression if i remember right.

I do go for walks outside when I can handle it, which would be even less without the cannabis I am pretty certian, as for special intrests I do focus on those to some extent but I hardly have the energy for life at times, let alone trying to do anything with a special intrest. On my better days I can better focus on these intrests.....but if not then I can't seem to focus because I have so many anxious,repetitive, negative thoughts going on I just get sidetracked.

But yeah thanks for the advice...and you're right that it's easier to just start with one thing but part of my issue is not even knowing where to begin.....I have some ideas of where not to though.


_________________
Tis the time to melt the Ice.


Kelspook
Sea Gull
Sea Gull

User avatar

Joined: 6 Jun 2011
Age: 52
Gender: Female
Posts: 222
Location: Scotland

15 Jan 2012, 12:33 pm

Tequila wrote:
Kelspook wrote:
These bodies are prohibitionist about alcohol for a reason, it has been scientifically PROVEN to makes things worse in people with clinical depression.


It does when they start telling everyone how to live their lives, that alcohol should be restricted, that alcohol prices should go up, that sinister warnings should be placed on the bottle and so on. That's when they can get stuffed, frankly. We have enough neo-prohibitionist loons in the world, thanks.


Okay, that point I certainly do agree on. The law abiding people who enjoy the odd drink shouldn't be persecuted by the state for the actions of a few antisocial chavs. That wasn't what I was getting at though, I meant in the specific case of people with depression.

Quote:
They aren't being judgemental, they're giving people information to help themselves.

As long as it ends there and doesn't end up with them telling people how to live their lives, or, rather, giving 'advice'.


They shouldn't be telling or forcing people to live thier lives the way they think they should be lived, no. But if someone is unhappy with thier life, advice on how to improve it does no harm if it's freely available. Consent by the individual should always be sought, unless they are a danger to themselves or others.

Quote:
I can understand if you've personally had bother with psychiatrists in the past

All the ones I've seen have been entirely useless and clueless and in one case was vaguely sinister.

How clueless? Let me see.

One psychiatrist categorically told me that I didn't have Asperger's and then asked me what Asperger's was! What a twat
.


Every profession has its numpties, sadly. But there are only folks who are very, very good. You just need to keep trying until you find one who can actually help you.

Quote:
Alcohol is harmful to the mental state of depressives, whether they are on medication or not.

True, and I don't disagree with you that they are best off not drinking (alcohol often accentuates your mood and state of mind, whatever that may be at the time) but at the end of the day it is their choice and theirs alone.


I wasn't suggesting otherwise, if someone who has anxiety or depression chooses to carry on drinking or taking other substances, then that is indeed thier choice. I merely meant that it almost always makes those conditions worse. Pretty much every person I've had to go to who has been depressed and in crisis either had alcohol on board, or had a history of alcohol/substance use. The two certainly seem to go hand in hand, in my own experience.

Quote:
That cycle where it seems your in a black hole and there's no way out is very, very common. You just need to take the first step of contacting help, and want things to change, even if it doesn't seem possible from where you're at right now.

It can get better.

Indeed. :)


At least we agree on something eh? :)



cron