One thing I've noticed is that a lot of AS folks are perfectionists, and in line with that, many of us like to complain and be argumentative. A lot. And when you have a forum where there are a lot of AS folks, it becomes easy for a lot of disrespectful mudslinging to occur.
In contrast, there really isn't enough emotionally-supportive feedback that happens here, not enough "that is awesome and you are so cool" or compliments on specific things. I mean, it's just like in the real world out there, where people will complain if something wrong happens, but people don't say anything when everything is ok. I think there are a few people who do give positive supportive feedback, but they're most likely to do it with people who will reciprocate. Why? Because positive feedback is something that snowballs and feeds itself, just like negative feedback. The more that you give praise and say, "hey I actually like that, please keep doing it", the more favorably people will respond to you, and that in turn helps you to feel better... something that I think everybody on WP needs. There might be an "in-crowd" of sorts in WP, but I think it's at least partially due to this group of people having found that they are likely to give praise to one another. The in-crowd didn't come before the praise; the praise came first. So if you want to be more welcomed, start giving more positive feedback then. When I first started posting here, I didn't get ANY responses at all to what I had to say, until people got to know me better and responded favorably every time I would try to be supportive and positive. People want support and optimism. If we wanted to be cut down and made to feel like sh*t, seriously we don't need WP for that. All we'd need to do is turn off the computers and go outside.
There are very very few people on WP whom I dislike, and they are pretty much the low-post-count people who sign up on WP and then immediately go in PPR to flame away, call people names, saying stuff like, "if you disagree with me, you're stupid". Then they wonder why they aren't liked, and point fingers at an in-crowd as though there were some kind of conspiracy.
It's no surprise if you think about it! Everybody else I either like or have no strong opinion about, and that's fine. That just means I'll do my best to give constructive feedback as well as positive reinforcement to you if you look like you need it, or if you say or do something particularly poignant. I try my best to be fair and understanding, but I'm also human so please forgive my transgressions.
I don't have any clue if I'm in an "in-crowd" or if I'm particularly well-liked. Regardless of the answer, I'll continue to try to be genuinely positive and supportive. There just aren't enough people who are positive and supportive in this world, and we need more of them. I can't stress that enough. Sure I don't always agree with what people say here, but that doesn't mean that I cannot learn and change my mind. We can only learn from people who aren't like us, who think differently. So learn to discuss more respectfully and supportively, and you may learn something.
_________________
Won't you help a poor little puppy?