Odin wrote:
twoshots wrote:
Michjo wrote:
Heh, i would suggest quite the opposite. It seems uneducated to take offense or even try to change how someone speaks.
Well, getting bent out of shape over pronunciation differences seems in turns ignorant or silly, but the social function is primarily education & class status signaling.
The entire practice of monitoring the grammar of others is an interesting social phenomenon; I was listening to an NPR program on grammar and language one time, and this being NPR the callers were *quite* concerned about correct grammar usages; it was interesting to note that this coexisted with a blatant lack of familiarity with even the most basic of linguistic principles. This strange passionate ignorance seems pervasive among some social classes.
I hate Prescriptivist Grammar Nazis, and the smug English teachers that know "Real English Grammar" but know squat about lingustics. How it has become a political issue, usually because of conservatives decrying criticisms of the Gammar Nazis by real linguists as "evil liberals destroying the language and letting those stupid N*****s in the ghetto speak bad English" mystifies me.
Conservative types seem the worst when it comes to the idea that bad grammar is destroying thought or some such nonsense. But getting picky about grammar seems to crop up among the public radio crowd and the perpetual targets of
Stuff White People Like rather a lot.
I of course am not entirely pure of heart. Affected "proper" pronunciation is a pet peeve of mine, though not so much for the actual pronunciation as the attitude that motivated it.

You get such silly things as forcing an intervocalic t (or, I swear I've heard this, flapping it, and then
aspirating the flap), or inexplicably objecting to some instances of palatalized consonants on the grounds that it's lazy, without any problem with others (steɪʃən and fɪʒən are fine, but whoa, mətʃuːɹ is destroying our language?). Or everyone on NPR speaking general American, but they
all "just happen" to preserve an exaggerated form of the hw/w distinction (a distinction made at this point by maybe 17% of all speakers in North America)?
BTW welcome back Odin. How've you been?
_________________
* here for the nachos.