Pie vs Cake you decide.

Post Reply New Topic

I like cake myself

Why pie, of course.

Pie's nice, but I can hardly ever turn down a yummy-looking cake!

For most of my life, I've preferred pie. When I was turning three, I wanted a birthday apple pie. Pie with any kind of fruit is good, basically - apple, blueberry, and cherry are good. I had a good strawberry rhubarb pie once. Pumpkin pie is also good.

Some cakes are better than others. I like vanilla cake fluffy and chocolate cake dense and moist. I LOVE really fluffy vanilla frosting laid really thick on a cake (that stuff doesn't even need the cake - it's good all by itself!)

Cheesecake. It's not a pie, but not a cake. It's like piecake, with cream cheese.

I love cake. I just had some for my birthday.

Even though the cake's a lie and all.

Login: CJOHNSON
Password: tier3
thecakeisalie

Red velvet cake FTW.

Carrot cake with cream cheese frosting. Nummers...

Hmm... I think it has to be pie. Soz.

Definitely pie. Any flavor, except lemon meringue.

That all depends now doesnt it? What KIND of cake are we talking about here.

If its those sad, industrial sized birthday cakes covered with that greasy, sugary crap they call frosting on top.... i will take the pie.

Buuuuuuuut... If we are talking about a homemade chocolate cake with thick dark ganache frosting, get me a glass of milk and a fork, cause I'm going in!! !! Once you go ganache, you never go back.

but wait.... what kind pie do you have going on there?....... Rhubarb? ( mmmm, tangy like a strawberry lemonade.) Peanut butter? (okie favorite) coconut cream.... banana....chocolate...? Made em all... still like em.
um, do i have to decide right away?

Yes this is a war after all and you must choose lest you be caught w/o any cake or pie at all.

You wouldn't like a world w/o cake or pie I promise you this.

Also whatever kind of pie/cake you want.

I'll happily eat both, but I always love a good slice of pie and will take it over cake any day.

I'm especially fond of pumpkin, pecan, apple, blackberry, key lime and cheesecake (I believe cheesecake is technically a pie...)

I chose Other just to be contrarian.

Pie>Cake

I've never been a fan of cake. Some cakes are good, but most of them are just tolerable. And I loathe most icings.

I prefer pies. And brownies. Also ice cream.