Exterior wise, I like athletic and healthy looking men, but to me what matters more is the person inside and how true they are. A lot of people fake act to get sex or get married to someone, then afterward they change and show their true colors which might be the opposite of what they first presented. It's nice to find someone who looks good, but that isn't always an option, especially when you are like me and 40 years old, when people start getting older and probably fatter looking. By now all the good looking people near my age are probably already taken.
I am not into 'hypermasculine', pushy, arrogant, narcissistic, lying, mean, thuggish men.
I am more drawn to men who are honest, smart, nice (I do not mean an ass kiss or weak), with some reasoning ability, nerdy, maybe into athletics, who have integrity, and some patience (no one without patience will want to live with me), loyal, not too rash and getting himself hurt, not into drugs, does not do things that overload my sensory problems. I think I am the type of person who is more attracted to the kind of people who would also make good friends with me. I am not much drawn to opposite end personalities. There would be too much clashing and conflict. I don't need the added unnecessary stress.