Extreme audio rather than visual memory??
Have you read anything about, I forget the dude's name, his Multiple Intelligences theory. Musical Intelligence is one of the intelligences on his list, and strong auditory image recall is an attribute of Musical Intelligence. You, in my opinion, are still thinking in images, just not so much in visual images. I think in three forms of image: visual, auditory, and kinesthetic. I can't seem to figure out how to spell that right now. Please for give my spelling. It's not one of my gifts.
Honestly, don't worry your spelling is fine (in fact my spelling is probably worse - but my computer has inbuilt spell check
I've studied it briefly in psychology, so I know what you mean. But music isn't visual to me; I don't "see" it (there's no visual representation of it in my mind, except sometimes I imagine vivid visual scenarios to go with certain songs - like personalized music videos - for fun), I only hear it with good clarity.
I do often have intense visual daydreams - so I guess that counts as thinking in images? I thought that was fairly standard though; daydreaming, except I probably do it more often than most people.
_________________
Into the dark...
I just posted this in another thread and realized it was probably relevant:
My mum used to sing nursery rhymes to me when I was a very young child (2-4 years old I think), and she is tone deaf so she would sing them all off key. Then when I went to stay at my grandma's house I would sing perfect imitations of nursery rhymes I heard to my grandma - complete with all the exact same wrong notes, and she would laugh herself sick.
(my grandma's the musical person in the family - nobody in my immediate family was musical)
_________________
Into the dark...
Ambivalence
Veteran
Joined: 8 Nov 2008
Age: 48
Gender: Male
Posts: 3,613
Location: Peterlee (for Industry)
Honestly, don't worry your spelling is fine (in fact my spelling is probably worse - but my computer has inbuilt spell check
I've studied it briefly in psychology, so I know what you mean. But music isn't visual to me; I don't "see" it (there's no visual representation of it in my mind, except sometimes I imagine vivid visual scenarios to go with certain songs - like personalized music videos - for fun), I only hear it with good clarity.
I do often have intense visual daydreams - so I guess that counts as thinking in images? I thought that was fairly standard though; daydreaming, except I probably do it more often than most people.
I guess that was confusing. To me audio is also a type of image, just not visual. Never mind. Sorry to confuse you. I also get imagery from music. I love to compare the lyrics of songs to see if the imagery of the music it is set to, comes close to the meaning of the lyrics.
I use Mozilla Firefox which has a spell check, but the spell check wasn't helping me come up with the spelling of kinesthetic. It was just saying my version was wrong.
I have good audial memory. But I remember having good visual memory too but it seems to have deterioated with age. Well im only 19 but I dont even remember dreams being particurlarly visual anymore. I remember having memories from childhood before but I cant recall.
Its quite worrying. I think its because of lack of stimulance. When I was a kid it was me against the world. But after the diagnosis I have led a very pleasant and content life for the most part. Part of the test for the diagnosis was to draw a picture after seeing it.
And I did well. But I cant imagine doing that today.
My mum used to sing nursery rhymes to me when I was a very young child (2-4 years old I think), and she is tone deaf so she would sing them all off key. Then when I went to stay at my grandma's house I would sing perfect imitations of nursery rhymes I heard to my grandma - complete with all the exact same wrong notes, and she would laugh herself sick.
(my grandma's the musical person in the family - nobody in my immediate family was musical)
Fascinating and hilarious!
ValentineWiggin
Veteran
Joined: 15 May 2011
Age: 38
Gender: Female
Posts: 4,907
Location: Beneath my cat's paw
I don't really remember in sound or image.
Although if I had to pick, I'd say sound makes more of an impact, somehow.
_________________
"Such is the Frailty
of the human Heart, that very few Men, who have no Property, have any Judgment of their own.
They talk and vote as they are directed by Some Man of Property, who has attached their Minds
to his Interest."
Always had a very strong ability to pick up accents. Was told by my French teacher in high school that my accent was unusually natural in my first year. Currently learning Japanese and getting the same type of responses from close friends who are native speakers (after establishing that they weren't just being polite).
My own accent apparently shifted toward those around me (region) while moving around in my teens/20s. I still get asked "Where are you from? You have an accent!". Still haven't figured that one out.
Transcribing and performing a complex piece of solo jazz guitar by ear and aceing "blind" memory tests (where the tester played a series of abstract riffs with his back turned and I had to play back by auditory memory) resulted in my receiving a scholarship to a prestigious Music College.
_________________
(EQ SQ-R)
EQ: 14 SQ: 113 => Extreme Systemizing
(ASQ)
46/50
Reynaert
Yellow-bellied Woodpecker
Joined: 19 Dec 2011
Age: 53
Gender: Male
Posts: 73
Location: Netherlands
I'll chime in with a me-too here.
When it's silent, I usually have a song playing in my head, and whenever I play or sing a musical piece, I first have to recall that song in my head as well. That usually involves finding the beginning of the song and then 'playing the tape', so to speak. And when I do sing a song, I usually match the accent of the performer quite well. (I pick up accents easily anyway, when I hang out with a certain group I pick up their speech patterns in a day or two. And some of my friends do too.)
I do remember all the inconsistencies (sing them as well), and when I used to have a mix tape playing in the car, I knew which song followed each one.
And when singing along with a song, I can usually do all the different melodic lines, baseline, drums, et cetera.
Also, I remember a lot of other auditory things. Like the way somebody spoke a sentence, intonation and everything. And I can recognize people from their voices very easily, more so than from their faces. I believe I can still recall some things my very first love said, years ago, in exactly her voice.
So yeah, I guess phonographic memory is not that uncommon, huh? ![]()
ValentineWiggin
Veteran
Joined: 15 May 2011
Age: 38
Gender: Female
Posts: 4,907
Location: Beneath my cat's paw
My own accent apparently shifted toward those around me (region) while moving around in my teens/20s. I still get asked "Where are you from? You have an accent!". Still haven't figured that one out.
Transcribing and performing a complex piece of solo jazz guitar by ear and aceing "blind" memory tests (where the tester played a series of abstract riffs with his back turned and I had to play back by auditory memory) resulted in my receiving a scholarship to a prestigious Music College.
Same! My accent changes almost immediately to that of those around me. I don't even realize it, often.
_________________
"Such is the Frailty
of the human Heart, that very few Men, who have no Property, have any Judgment of their own.
They talk and vote as they are directed by Some Man of Property, who has attached their Minds
to his Interest."
I'm the same way...I bought the books but didn't really use them much. I went to class and I'd remember what the professors said.
~Kate
_________________
Ce e amorul? E un lung
Prilej pentru durere,
Caci mii de lacrimi nu-i ajung
Si tot mai multe cere.
--Mihai Eminescu
I think primarily in pictures. But I would not be able to "draw" a room one time I have seen it. Though my pictural memory is strong, as I can perfectly describe the appartment I lived in for example age three to six in detail. My auditive memory is better as I can also as the OP remember music up to the smallest details, especially classical music of couple hours long.
And: Les Miserables was a side-SI for a time and I know it by heart too!
To OP: We could - as I cannot sing - hum it together!
Well, I can "sing" the lines too in a way, but... ![]()
_________________
English is not my native language, so I will very likely do mistakes in writing or understanding. My edits are due to corrections of mistakes, which I sometimes recognize just after submitting a text.
