Do non-living things have personalities to you?
I don't think objects have personalities, but I do think objects have emotions.
We're going to have our bathroom done this week (possibly tomorrow), and that means we're going to have to take off all the tiles in order to place them with new ones, and I keep ''feeling sorry'' for the tiles that are to come off. Each time I go in the bathroom I keep looking at the tiles on the wall and I can almost hear them saying ''today might be our last ever day to be on show and then we're going to have to come off, it's not fair!''
Seeing emotions in objects is becoming a serious problem with me though. It's causing me to become a hoarder, and I think I'm also developing a fear of rubbish dumps.
_________________
Female
I read somewhere this one person talking about a television being (to them) a young boy, so they would never watch anything racy on that TV.
Interesting. I believe you are right.
Do they have personalities?
NO.
My brain interprets this idea as silly. Inanimate things are just that, objects.
HOWEVER: Do I treat them like they do?
YES.
The difference is that I know it's me who is "breathing life" in the interaction. As it is, my cars and computers are deemed stubborns, or snobs etc.
Heh, good fun.
Verdandi
Veteran

Joined: 7 Dec 2010
Age: 55
Gender: Female
Posts: 12,275
Location: University of California Sunnydale (fictional location - Real location Olympia, WA)
I read somewhere this one person talking about a television being (to them) a young boy, so they would never watch anything racy on that TV.
Interesting. I believe you are right.
Of course I am:
http://www.journalofvision.org/content/7/9/532.abstract
I have it more like Joe does - emotions, but not personality. Not as intense as she seems to, though.
I don't have the true synesthesia, but I've always been able to easily create a personality/name for an inanimate object if I need to do so for whatever reason. I don't do it automatically in my daily life, but since I do believe I have true spatial sequence and ticker tape synesthesia, I think that it's not a coincidence that I can create personalities for numbers, letters, and inanimate objects much easier than most people. The best example of my inanimate object personality traits is how I created a full-fledged personality for every one of the microwave girls in "Is This a Good Idea to Microwave This?" My microwave biographies are up on the microwave show's Wiki page. I am very proud of them. The girls who didn't last long are the ones where the personality was almost entirely created by me. I had an instant like/dislike for every girl. Hard to explain why/how.
_________________
Helinger: Now, what do you see, John?
Nash: Recognition...
Helinger: Well, try seeing accomplishment!
Nash: Is there a difference?
Very interesting and a bit strange. I can relate to this more when younger.
Overall, I find it a little amusing that 'intentions' are assigned with things rather than people. On this other side of the coin, one could say NT's have a Theory of Things impairment.

StarTrekker
Veteran

Joined: 22 Apr 2012
Age: 32
Gender: Female
Posts: 3,088
Location: Starship Voyager, somewhere in the Delta quadrant
Quote:
When I pet my stuffed animals I frequently have to touch every single one of them because if I didn't they would feel left out, and I don't want any of them to feel slighted.
I do this too; I have to hug each of them individually before I go to bed, and if I miss one, I feel guilty about it. I also don't buy new stuffed animals very often anymore; I'm convinced if I do, the others will get jealous. The tiny, utterly illogical piece of my brain that believes this is also slightly convinced that the whole "Toy Story" thing is real; all the toys/knicknacks/objects in my room come to life when I leave. Of course, this makes having garage sales very difficult and I feel guilty for ever getting rid of anything, so it's turned me into a bit of a hoarder. I even have a hard time throwing old shoes away (part of my need for routine is wearing the same thing every day, so I only ever have one pair of each type of shoe at a time, so they can spend years with me) it just makes me feel sad, like I'm abandoning an old friend or something. Not all of my anthropomorphising is involuntary though; I once gave a personality to the dish rag I used at work to keep my day more interesting; I couldn't talk to my coworkers, so I talked to her instead. I'm pretty sure if anyone had ever caught me talking to a dish rag though, I'd have been thrown in the looney bin. I wonder why we do this; considering the trouble we have empathising with other humans and understanding their emotions, the idea that we can understand the perceived emotions of inanimate objects is extremely bizarre.
_________________
"Survival is insufficient" - Seven of Nine
Diagnosed with ASD level 1 on the 10th of April, 2014
Rediagnosed with ASD level 2 on the 4th of May, 2019
Thanks to Olympiadis for my fantastic avatar!
When I pet my stuffed animals I frequently have to touch every single one of them because if I didn't they would feel left out, and I don't want any of them to feel slighted.
I do this too; I have to hug each of them individually before I go to bed, and if I miss one, I feel guilty about it. I also don't buy new stuffed animals very often anymore; I'm convinced if I do, the others will get jealous. The tiny, utterly illogical piece of my brain that believes this is also slightly convinced that the whole "Toy Story" thing is real; all the toys/knicknacks/objects in my room come to life when I leave. Of course, this makes having garage sales very difficult and I feel guilty for ever getting rid of anything, so it's turned me into a bit of a hoarder. I even have a hard time throwing old shoes away (part of my need for routine is wearing the same thing every day, so I only ever have one pair of each type of shoe at a time, so they can spend years with me) it just makes me feel sad, like I'm abandoning an old friend or something. Not all of my anthropomorphising is involuntary though; I once gave a personality to the dish rag I used at work to keep my day more interesting; I couldn't talk to my coworkers, so I talked to her instead. I'm pretty sure if anyone had ever caught me talking to a dish rag though, I'd have been thrown in the looney bin. I wonder why we do this; considering the trouble we have empathising with other humans and understanding their emotions, the idea that we can understand the perceived emotions of inanimate objects is extremely bizarre.
But this isn't empathy, it's projecting. Empathy requires relating to a persons frame of mind. Objects don't have a mind. Why we do this... My guess would be an intact drive to connect to those around us but faulty empathy wiring, like a lose wire that only send data intermittently. I would also guess that personifying objects seems much safer to a child with AS because they are often proven wrong in trying to read people but you can't be wrong with an object. Personifying objects is very common for young children but I think most kids grow out of it when they start to develop people skills and switch focus to people. I think that for people who have problems with empathy some don't make a transition to people because of negative feedback but rather continue to personify objects. Just a thought.
For me, I don't necessarily give objects any kind of complex personality. I just feel that they have feelings and that triggers an emotional response in me. I find it more difficult to have that connection to people. I don't think I would really fit into the synethsesia category.
I don't have a problem with hoarding myself - while I perceive personalities in objects, I don't have much of a problem getting rid of them. Although, I do have a problem getting rid of certain things, like instruments and sheet music - I don't need every single instrument I own, but I like having them. They all do have their own sounds - for example I have three fretless basses but they all sound different (all made from different materials and having different types of fingerboard/fingerboard coating). I only use two of them on stage - I could easily get rid of one of them, but I have a horribly difficult time parting with instruments - which is why I have never parted with one.
Verdandi
Veteran

Joined: 7 Dec 2010
Age: 55
Gender: Female
Posts: 12,275
Location: University of California Sunnydale (fictional location - Real location Olympia, WA)
But people who have no social impairments also do this, and it's pretty firmly established as a form of synesthesia.
I haven't got over childhood animism, I still feel that toys and alike have soul and and feelings. Mostly I feel it about things that have some kind of eyes or face (or had once or are supposed to have). Like when a toy car has eyes, then it is much more a personality than a usual toy car without a face drawn on it. And also pictures - a drawing of some imagination character is also a personality for me whereas a drawing that is a reproduction of a real being is not. I mean a Winnie Pooh picture in in any book is animate, but a photo or a drawing of a real human or animal is not. Therefore it is very hard to me throw away toys or childrens books. And somewhat my car and motorcycle have a personality too, but that's not as much clear.
Not personalities, but emotions. My mother used to pay me to massage her feet as a kid and I would always be sure to treat both feet equally so one wouldn't feel bad" eventhough I hated doing it. Also, always pulled blankets, etc. off of things with faces or made sure they weren't blocked in any way. I intellectually know it makes no difference, but I do it anyway. I treat objects respectfully. I collect naturally heart-shaped rocks, and one my son found a few years ago, he decided yesterday wasn't so heart-shaped and wanted to toss it. I said no, but he really wanted to, so I let him. He had found a better one earlier. I felt horrible. He did too afterwards and tried to find it. Didn't, but actually found another one very heart-shaped. Weird. I just felt so bad that the rock was being 'ousted' for no reason after being so comfortable lined up by size with the others for years. Like being kicked out for no reason with nowhere to go out into the cold. Stuff like that.
_________________
EQ-9
SQ-80
AQ-49
Your Aspie score: 165 of 200
Your Neurotypical (non-autistic) score: 32 of 200
You are very likely an Aspie
But people who have no social impairments also do this, and it's pretty firmly established as a form of synesthesia.
The study you linked was about someone who creates complex personalities for objects. What I'm saying is I don't create complex personalities, I create emotions in me that are tied to an object and an action. To me it doesn't seem like the same thing as the study you linked. My thinking is that one is based on biology and the other is based on reinforcement.
Verdandi
Veteran

Joined: 7 Dec 2010
Age: 55
Gender: Female
Posts: 12,275
Location: University of California Sunnydale (fictional location - Real location Olympia, WA)
You're looking at what that person does specifically and noting the differences from what you do specifically. What I do is more like what you do than what the person in that study does, and I don't think that difference is enough to say "That way is synesthesia, but this way never is." I'm not trying to tell you that you have synesthesia, but rather the way you categorized isn't accurate.
Also, I don't see the point of your false dichotomy - reinforcement happens because of our neurobiology. Without biology there can't be any reinforcement.
Similar Topics | |
---|---|
Things You Say As You Get Old |
09 Jul 2025, 5:15 pm |
Feeling that if you're not doing this you're not "living" |
14 Jul 2025, 2:52 pm |
Buying Things |
21 May 2025, 1:38 am |
How come some people do things at the same certain stage... |
16 Jul 2025, 2:54 am |