Do Relentlessly Positive People Annoy You?

Post Reply New Topic

I am an optimistic pessimist, meaning I'm cynical and jaded but say things like "It could be worse!" And then think of all the ways it could be worse.
I have a hard time constant cheerful bubbliness. With some people it feels so fake it physically makes me feel bad. I'm tired of being told to cheer up, or to "get over it". My mom always told me "No one likes a wet blanket" and that made me hide my feelings under a mask. I was never cheerful but I never let on how much I hurt inside. As I got older, I got more and more angry at hiding it. I still have a hard time letting it all out and it's unhealthy.
I don't mind a little positivity, but don't smother me in it. I guess I prefer positive reinforcement in a practical way. Like if I post a problem to a group of NT's, I just really don't like most of the replies. Things like *hugs* and "Thinking about you" don't really do much... eh... I have some issues I really need to work out.

Edit: I should say I haven't really seen any of that sickening positivity, just people telling us to "get over it". If I could, I WOULD.

Why?

What's so funny?

OK, forgive me if such a thing exists, because I tend to stick to only one or two parts of this site, and haven't fully explored the rest. Does Alex have a mission statement or something, where he states the intentions of this site, what it would like to achieve, who it would like to appeal to etc.?

We provide a discussion forum, where members communicate with each other

I personally thing that the General Autism Discussion forum is bound to have a certain amount of negative posts for the very fact of the difficulties people with an ASD often face ie if I was new to WP it would not surprise me in the least to see negative threads or posts on this main forum as that to me is the nature of Asperger forums and in fact most forums! The negative invariably attracts more attention than the positive. Dramas do not contain people all living wonderful lives and livign in a spirit of continual positivity! If that was what people preferred why on earth are programmes like Eastenders and Coronation Street so popular??

People like to moan - it's a fact!

But there are plenty of less negative threads to balance this out.

People can create threads on whatever subject they choose!

I see The Haven as somewhere to post if I was feeling really really depressed ie I would not want to just post a thread that discussed negative subject matter in the Haven as I dont' think it would be fair on people who are often suffering with really bad depression. The Haven is for people going through a bad time in my opinion and I dont' see that a thread about eg how annoying something NTs do is relevant for The Haven at all, as that has a predominantly supportive function and moaning or pointing something negative out or having a negative opinion may just be how someone chooses to express themself at that time ie they don't need support, they just want to express themselves.

I post both negative, positive, informational and supportive posts ie I post a variety of different types of post depending on what is going on in my life at the time and on my particular mood.

Surely one of the major problems with Aspergers is that we often get the following implied message from the majority of non-autistic people - 'We don't accept you because you are different to us'. The people moaning about negative posts make me feel it's just another version of the NT message ie another form of intolerance.

Agreed. I associate it very much with NT's too, which is why, whatever the diagnosis of the ANP's (Anti-Negativity People) doing
their ANP thing on here, I feel oppressed by it as I come to WP as a sanctuary, to escape from all things that are NT-associated
in my mind.

I agree with the OP.

I don't like negativity bashing. I suspect that the OP started this thread in response to some other thread(s) that was bashing negativity etc (if not, sorry).

I also think perceiving negativity in other people's words and actions could be the reflection of their own negativity. I say this because some posters here seem to perceive negativity in something in which I didn't see any negativity.

Telling people who are depressed (feeling extremely negative) to be positive is one of the worst things. It can make them attempt suicide. They need understanding, not lecturing, bashing etc.

Hey mate I'm on your side. I love your sense of balance, putting up a thread which turns Stoek's claims to the other side. I just think you have handled this deliciously. (Let's hope you can beat his thread count )

Hey mate I'm on your side. I love your sense of balance, putting up a thread which turns Stoek's claims to the other side. I just think you have handled this deliciously. (Let's hope you can beat his thread count )

(Let's hope you can beat his thread count )

I understand that you believe that a desire for "positive" posts is NT-associated.

I have tried in this debate not to impede people's desire to post what they want on WP, subject to the TOS. I personally advocate that posters should be aware that "General" is open to the public, and would be the first thing that newcomers see when they visit WP. This is the only board of it's type in the English speaking world. There are other boards, and without naming names, they all have problems and limited membership.

I don't believe anyone has an issue when new posters come on WP and post threads about how their lives "suck", and in many cases these postings are entirely deserved. I myself don't think we should throw every post of such nature to another sub-forum, we don't have the moderator staff for it. We do however want to be aware that what we post on WP could drive newcomers away. I believe that Aspies who come to WP are upset enough as it is, and that we should be welcoming. I would like posters to take more responsability to contact mods and ask for their own threads to be moved if they realize that the thread should be elsewhere.

I also am slightly annoyed that posting constructive advice for how to improve one's life is seen as "NT". I realize that the standard for what is "NT" is set by an individual reader, but that standard does seem rather....low. People should'nt be telling each other that "Oh, just make more eye contact, and read her non-verbal gestures", because that's a learned behavior that Aspies, by definition, don't have. However, "Go outside, meet people", is constructive advice. I realize that many posters have transporation difficulties and social anxiety, but I don't think we should accuse well-intentioned posters of being "NT".

What is the definition of a relentlessly positive person?
I understand they might be the never give up positive type, like maybe a self help guru? That type of person?