goldfish21 wrote:
NCC1701 wrote:
Aspergers community through Tumblr
Wait.. wut?
There are communities on Tumblr & people communicate with each other there?
Interesting. I've never bothered to click around Tumblr beyond porn that's relevant to my interests and didn't realize there were "communities," on there.
Yeah, like:
http://www.tumblr.com/tagged/actuallyau ... everything
http://www.tumblr.com/tagged/asd/everything
http://www.tumblr.com/tagged/aspergers/everything
Now you can see for yourself how autistic people on tumblr are doing things just as bad or worse by complaining about NTs as the things the NTs did that prompted the complaints.
Also, the tags don't really reflect a community where everyone has the same goals and ideals, but a tag where people talk about being autistic. It's not something where everything someone does is for the education and benefit of neurotypicals (and expecting that everything
should be is not a benign belief nor is it reasonable to expect everything an autistic person does to contribute to that education and nary a negative word about NTs.
And the generalized posts about neurotypicals (although I can't find very many) appear to apply a valid rhetorical concept known as metonymy:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metonymy
The OP's use of autistic communities on tumblr is not a very helpful use of metonymy, as it fails to actually encapsulate what is posted in these tags.
Anyway stuff that does get complained about is the way the media and the public take murdered autistic children and turn their killers (parents typically) into martyrs and saints because they "lacked support" (this is typically false) and other excuses to make it seem like such an act is exclusable and understandable. So, if I wanted to unfairly generalize the OP's argument (although it's not a huge generalization because this is a relevant topic in those tags) I'd say she's putting "I am angry at NTs and saying a few mean words about them" on the same level as parents killing their autistic children.
But it's more like she's putting autistic people being angry or frustrated at NTs on the same level as being harassed, bullied, denied resources, denied accommodations. Basically, she's saying that stuff that causes material challenges for autistic people is exactly the same as something that doesn't cause material challenges for anyone (venting about NTs).
Plus she's generalizing the activity in those tags to all be anti-neurotypical hate-filled screeds, which is precisely what she's complaining about autistic people doing in those tags, and thus "just as bad" by her own logic.
Also, yes, there are also aspie elitist posts in those tags, and stuff in general that is not really all that great to come across. Like being autistic doesn't make anyone immune to saying or doing horrible things. WP itself is a fine testament to that.
Last edited by Verdandi on 18 May 2014, 4:12 am, edited 1 time in total.