That means that Google had done half the espionage work for the government. All the NSA has to do is set up a SQL server to document mail with certain keywords for their project Echelon and have a copy sent to an FBI SQL server foir their project Carnivore.
This is an informative thread. Looks like I won't respond to Gmail accounts anymore.
Are you joking? I mean that seriously, because some people do not respond to gmail accounts, although I think that's extreme. It's no different than any other major e-mail provider. As they always used to say, treat your e-mail like a postcard, if you're looking for more security, the only way is to encrypt it. Last I checked, the government needs a warrant to look at your e-mail, unless it's >180 days old, in which case they need a subpoena. Either way, I don't think it's any more difficult for them to get information from any other e-mail provider. If you want to be really secure, run your own e-mail server and delete the logs/messages.
I've been reading more on this, and while it is slightly disconcerting, their policies don't seem any worse than other providers to me. EPIC released a statement on it, and while I usually agree with them, I'm not so sure on this one. To me, the biggest qualm I have is the long data retention, the fact that they will transfer that data to a new company if they're bought out, and their loose claims about when they have to disclose data.
Quote:
As a standard email protocol, when you send an email from your Gmail account, Gmail includes your email address and user name in the header of the email. Beyond this, we do not disclose your personally identifying information to third parties unless we believe we are required to do so by law or have a good faith belief that such access, preservation or disclosure is reasonably necessary to (a) satisfy any applicable law, regulation, legal process or governmental request, (b) enforce the Gmail Terms of Use, including investigation of potential violations thereof, (c) detect, prevent, or otherwise address fraud, security or technical issues (including, without limitation, the filtering of spam), (d) respond to user support requests, or (e) protect the rights, property or safety of Google, its users and the public. - Gmail
privacy policy However, even
Walla's privacy policy (who EPIC recommended) says the same thing. I'm really not concerned about them using bots to tailor ad content. If you want really safe e-mail, IMO the only way is to encrypt.
Here is another anti-Gmail page. I'm still keeping my account.