HFA & PDD-NOS
If your goal is to compile data, it occurs to me that it would be beneficial to ask these questions on other webboards as well, so the focus here doesn't skew responses as you're asking from a range of diagnoses, and most here (I'd hazard a guess) identify as Aspie (obviously) whether self-diagnosed or no, and selection bias isn't the best thing for compiling data. Perhaps a mental health discussion forum since the answers about the diagnoses you're questing about for fall medically in the DSM.
And I'd be interested in artistic, spatial skill's, writing ect. questionaire. Very Interested. ![]()
_________________
It's a nice day to start again.
-'White Wedding', Billy Idol
And I'd be interested in artistic, spatial skill's, writing ect. questionaire. Very Interested.
Very true. I am asking these same questions on a few other webboards, albeit through PMs. And I realize the bias, not just towards AS on these sorts of boards, but a bias towards autistics who are drawn towards online communication with other autistics.
The main purpose in collecting this data was to illustrate that not all autistics fall in the poor or face blind categories (this was I think made a little clearer in the other poll thread I'd posted). Therefore, a bias in numbers isn't exactly a great downfall since ANY numbers falling within average to excellent ranges contradict the accepted blanket statement that we all have a deficit in this area.
I am probably going to be doing a little more "official" data collection next spring (before I look into face recognition in relation to other abilities). And so this bias will become a definite concern I will have to counteract.
The main problem though is it is easier for me to gather data on people who know and trust me more. And while I haven't been as active on WP as I used to be, I am not unknown, so I'm not some random stranger coming in and asking people for their info.
Thanks for the suggestions though. They will be helpful.
_________________
My Science blog, Science Over a Cuppa - http://insolemexumbra.wordpress.com/
My partner's autism science blog, Cortical Chauvinism - http://corticalchauvinism.wordpress.com/
richie
Supporting Member
Joined: 9 Jan 2007
Age: 67
Gender: Male
Posts: 30,142
Location: Lake Whoop-Dee-Doo, Pennsylvania
THE SURVEY
1. If you took the poll I mentioned previously, what was your selection? If you haven't done the poll, please answer here: If you had to rate your face recognition skills, would you say you were:
a) excellent
b) average
c) poor (or below average)
d) face blind
I would say my face recognition skills are between average and poor.
2. What's your age? 48
3. Are you male or female? Male
4. Currently diagnosed? No official diagnosis yet.
5. If you are diagnosed, what’s your precise diagnosis? Asperger’s? HFA? PDD-NOS? N/A
6. At what age did you begin speaking? Early (11 months or under), average (12-15 months), late average (16-23 months), or late (24+) Very late, past 36 months at least.
7. Did you have pronounced echolalia as a child? Yes
I've left a bunch of other posts elsewhere concerning how I came to my conclusions about myself:
http://www.wrongplanet.net/modules.php? ... ht=#617364
http://www.wrongplanet.net/modules.php? ... ht=#452181
http://www.wrongplanet.net/modules.php? ... ht=#452397
http://www.wrongplanet.net/modules.php? ... ht=#452511
http://www.wrongplanet.net/modules.php? ... ht=#496788
http://www.wrongplanet.net/modules.php? ... ht=#512898
_________________
Life! Liberty!...and Perseveration!!.....
Weiner's Law of Libraries: There are no answers, only cross references.....
My Blog: http://richiesroom.wordpress.com/
bump
_________________
My Science blog, Science Over a Cuppa - http://insolemexumbra.wordpress.com/
My partner's autism science blog, Cortical Chauvinism - http://corticalchauvinism.wordpress.com/
Can this be related to the differences between AS/NVLD and autism? Generally, those with autism have greater visual/spatial ability compared to their verbal, whereas it's the opposite with AS/NVLD.
1) Average I'd say.
2) 22
3) Female
4) Asperger's Disorder
5) Still diagnosed with AS, after all it's just a label
6) I was babbling when I was 7 months and kept opn babbling until I was a year old and then I stopped. I started saying single words again when I was 2 but I spoke my own language and I didn't start speaking correctly till I was 6. I was five when I was speaking a lot but I was hard to understand. When I was 3 and 4 I hardly spoke, I only said single words. I never spoke in sentances.
7) Yes
Can this be related to the differences between AS/NVLD and autism? Generally, those with autism have greater visual/spatial ability compared to their verbal, whereas it's the opposite with AS/NVLD.
Not to say there might not be some correlation (I really can't say); however, face processing in humans seems to be an odd-man-out. Ability in object recognition can have little tie to face recognition. So an autie who has a keen ability to recognize objects, may be unable to recognize faces in a holistic manner.
Prospagnosia is a very... unique agnosia, I think largely because face recognition is so important since we're such a social animal. It's part of "visual processing" but then is sort of off in an area unto itself as well. Neither here nor there.
_________________
My Science blog, Science Over a Cuppa - http://insolemexumbra.wordpress.com/
My partner's autism science blog, Cortical Chauvinism - http://corticalchauvinism.wordpress.com/
If you had to rate your face recognition skills, would you say you were:
c) poor (or below average)
2. What's your age? 23
3. Are you male or female? Female
4. Currently diagnosed? Yes
5. If you are diagnosed, what’s your precise diagnosis? Asperger’s? HFA? PDD-NOS? HFA/AS border
6. At what age did you begin speaking? Early (11 months or under)
7. Did you have pronounced echolalia as a child? Yes, and still do.
Fiz
Veteran
Joined: 29 Jan 2006
Age: 43
Gender: Female
Posts: 1,821
Location: Manchester, United Kingdom
1. If you took the poll I mentioned previously, what was your selection? If you haven't done the poll, please answer here: If you had to rate your face recognition skills, would you say you were:
a) excellent
b) average
c) poor (or below average)
d) face blind
poor
2. What's your age?
23
3. Are you male or female?
female
4. Currently diagnosed?
yes
5. If you are diagnosed, what’s your precise diagnosis? Asperger’s? HFA? PDD-NOS?
Autistic disorder.
6. At what age did you begin speaking? Early (11 months or under), average (12-15 months), late average (16-23 months), or late (24+)?
late
7. Did you have pronounced echolalia as a child?
I repeated the same sentences over and over. I did it until I was 18. If people talked to me then I would say the sentence. I do not know if it was echolalia I do not know if it was pronounced echolalia.
Metalwolf
Veteran
Joined: 24 Jan 2008
Age: 46
Gender: Female
Posts: 948
Location: Pennsylvania 78787878 787878 7878787878787878
THE SURVEY
1. If you took the poll I mentioned previously, what was your selection? If you haven't done the poll, please answer here: If you had to rate your face recognition skills, would you say you were:
a) excellent
b) average
c) poor (or below average)
d) face blind
c
2. What's your age?
28
3. Are you male or female?
Female
4. Currently diagnosed? Yes
5. If you are diagnosed, what’s your precise diagnosis? Asperger’s? HFA? PDD-NOS?
Asperger's by one doctor, and PDD-NOS by another.
6. At what age did you begin speaking? Early (11 months or under), average (12-15 months), late average (16-23 months), or late (24+)?
I was unable to speak until I was at least 3 1/2 or 4 years old. When I did start speaking, it was with simple words at first.
7. Did you have pronounced echolalia as a child? No
If you had to rate your face recognition skills, would you say you were
average
2. What's your age?
23
3. Are you male or female?
male[i]
4. Currently diagnosed?
yes
5. If you are diagnosed, what’s your precise diagnosis? Asperger’s? HFA? PDD-NOS?
PDD-NOS
6. At what age did you begin speaking? Early (11 months or under), average (12-15 months), late average (16-23 months), or late (24+)?
my parents said at the normal time so I guess 12-15 months
7. Did you have pronounced echolalia as a child?[/size][/quote]
yes kind of[i]
THE SURVEY
1. If you took the poll I mentioned previously, what was your selection? If you haven't done the poll, please answer here: If you had to rate your face recognition skills, would you say you were:
b) average (to below average)
2. What's your age?
28
3. Are you male or female?
female
4. Currently diagnosed?
No, not yet tested.
5. If you are diagnosed, what’s your precise diagnosis? Asperger’s? HFA? PDD-NOS?
N/A
6. At what age did you begin speaking? Early (11 months or under), average (12-15 months), late average (16-23 months), or late (24+)?
Early. My mom says I was speaking between 8-10 months.
7. Did you have pronounced echolalia as a child?
Occasional, but not pronounced.
_________________
?Be who you are and say what you feel because those who mind don't matter and those who matter don't mind.? _Theodor Seuss Geisel (Dr. Seuss)
1. If you had to rate your face recognition skills, would you say you were:
b) average
2. What's your age? 32
3. Are you male or female? Male
4. Currently diagnosed? Diagnosed around age 19
5. If you are diagnosed, what’s your precise diagnosis? Asperger’s? HFA? PDD-NOS? HFA
6. At what age did you begin speaking? Early (11 months or under), average (12-15 months), late average (16-23 months), or late (24+)?
From what I understand, I made sounds at age 1, then quit and did not talk until age 4.
7. Did you have pronounced echolalia as a child?[/size]
Unknown, I am assuming yes since Ive still been known to have it sometimes.
Also, a little down the line, I may be wanting to collect some more information on other skills in relation to facial recognition (spatial skills, artistic abilities, writing, etc.). Let me know if you'd be interested and I'll mark you down for when the time comes.
Why not? Suppose it cant kill me.
