Why do NTs turn nasty ...
Being empathic isn't always all it's cracked up to be. Sometimes hanging out here can be very depressing.
Sorry, Willmark.
I am just trying to understand. Does it accomplish nothing to turn to him and say, "Honey please hold me."
99% of the time, I do just that. As you probably can tell, I'm not one to suffer in silence if I can see a way to fix things. But there is that painful 1% of the time, when I'm so hurt or disturbed that I'm unable to be his emotional helper in the situation and just need him to take the initiative and be my emotional helper without prompting. It's sort of like, if one has to ask their partner for flowers, then the giving of the flowers loses its heartfelt meaning and just becomes a duty -- the point of giving flowers is then lost. The dynamics involved in the origins of a caring behavior does matter. I mean, I'm laying there crying precisely because he's not emotionally available much of the time.
And I think you will find that most women feel this way, if not most people in general. We can't always tell each other, while we are not doing well ourselves, what would be the best move to make next. Later, though, like the next day or at our next counseling meeting when I'm able to be more objective, I usually do tell him how he could've handled it better. But that sometimes is the only help I can offer him.
_________________
Cleopatra, in love and at her wits' end, clutches the blessed serpent to her breast, and expires.
Please visit my blog at: http://www.wrongplanet.net/modules.php? ... er=Feyhera
Being empathic isn't always all it's cracked up to be. Sometimes hanging out here can be very depressing.
Sorry, Willmark.
I am just trying to understand. Does it accomplish nothing to turn to him and say, "Honey please hold me."
99% of the time, I do just that. As you probably can tell, I'm not one to suffer in silence if I can see a way to fix things. But there is that painful 1% of the time, when I'm so hurt or disturbed that I'm unable to be his emotional helper in the situation and just need him to take the initiative and be my emotional helper without prompting. It's sort of like, if one has to ask their partner for flowers, then the giving of the flowers loses its heartfelt meaning and just becomes a duty -- the point of giving flowers is then lost. The dynamics involved in the origins of a caring behavior does matter. I mean, I'm laying there crying precisely because he's not emotionally available much of the time.
And I think you will find that most women feel this way, if not most people in general. We can't always tell each other, while we are not doing well ourselves, what would be the best move to make next. Later, though, like the next day or at our next counseling meeting when I'm able to be more objective, I usually do tell him how he could've handled it better. But that sometimes is the only help I can offer him.
I've had that same problem with a lot of men I've dated who weren't Aspie (including my husband). I think the problem isn't Aspergers as much as it's a common guy thing (maybe even a people thing in general as my friends don't hug me or anything, but I wouldn't want that from girls). Maybe the problem isn't that guys aren't there for us emotionally as much as we expect them to be. I don't know. I'm just talking here, not sure where I'm going with it.
Being empathic isn't always all it's cracked up to be. Sometimes hanging out here can be very depressing.
Sorry, Willmark.
I am just trying to understand. Does it accomplish nothing to turn to him and say, "Honey please hold me."
99% of the time, I do just that. As you probably can tell, I'm not one to suffer in silence if I can see a way to fix things. But there is that painful 1% of the time, when I'm so hurt or disturbed that I'm unable to be his emotional helper in the situation and just need him to take the initiative and be my emotional helper without prompting. It's sort of like, if one has to ask their partner for flowers, then the giving of the flowers loses its heartfelt meaning and just becomes a duty -- the point of giving flowers is then lost. The dynamics involved in the origins of a caring behavior does matter. I mean, I'm laying there crying precisely because he's not emotionally available much of the time.
And I think you will find that most women feel this way, if not most people in general. We can't always tell each other, while we are not doing well ourselves, what would be the best move to make next. Later, though, like the next day or at our next counseling meeting when I'm able to be more objective, I usually do tell him how he could've handled it better. But that sometimes is the only help I can offer him.
I've had that same problem with a lot of men I've dated who weren't Aspie (including my husband). I think the problem isn't Aspergers as much as it's a common guy thing (maybe even a people thing in general as my friends don't hug me or anything, but I wouldn't want that from girls). Maybe the problem isn't that guys aren't there for us emotionally as much as we expect them to be. I don't know. I'm just talking here, not sure where I'm going with it.
Exactly. It is primarily a "guy thing". And I have experienced emotional clueless-ness from other guys in previous relationships. There's just that added "Mr. Spock" aspect, that AS disconnect that makes it that much more difficult for me to muddle my way through alone. Maybe this is just happening to me (us), but even if I roll over and ask for the hug, and he complies and holds me, he still really has absolutely no understanding of why holding me when I'm distraught is the right thing to do. In his world -- a world that has no room for anything new or foreign -- he seeks solitude when he's upset, so, it follows that that is what others will receive from him when they are. It's that cold, strange distance, that lack of empathy to the extreme, that brings me to these boards seeking understanding and tools. For handling this sort of thing and others...
As I'm typing this, he has put the phone on speaker and just dialed the number of an acquaintance, and as the phone starts to ring at the other end, he's just rushed past me to go to the toilet. He is now pissing in our very echo-y bathroom and I can hear a woman's voice answering. *sigh* Why doesn't he KNOW how gross that is... I've told him a thousand times... so it's also this sort of social weirdness ALL the time that just wears me out and makes it pretty tough to assert my own needs at the end of the day... wow, he just flushed the toilet and is still chatting away...
Believe me... I'm ready to hear some advice.
_________________
Cleopatra, in love and at her wits' end, clutches the blessed serpent to her breast, and expires.
Please visit my blog at: http://www.wrongplanet.net/modules.php? ... er=Feyhera
""Believe me... I'm ready to hear some advice.""
Ok you asked for it....
Got to the store and buy a fresh bag of crunch chips.
Give Him a call from the store while eating said chips
It helps to stand outside so the wind can hit the phone.
Ask him what he would like to have for dinner ect.
Sip on a soda can, Continue eating chips,
Burp if possible
Quoting Tantybi:
This is interesting. I agree. It's a guy thing for the most part, but the most interesting part of this for me is, why is it a guy thing? Or more importantly, where did/do we, females both NT and Aspie, get our expectations of how guys should behave towards gals?
My theory is we get it from reading fiction, from music, and mostly form television and movies. We (society) follow the movie "stars" and the rock "stars" and the "heroes" of classic literature and popular fiction. Their authors give us what we crave, and I feel certain that first and foremost, it's what the authors crave as well: idealized love relationships, excitement and adventure, and all the finest qualities of the main characters, both male and female that any human creature could have. We forget that these people are only performing according to scripts or lyrics that were written purposely to grab our attention, love, affection, loyalty, money - and then we're dumbfounded and seriously dismayed when our significant others don't measure up.
This is not to dismiss bad behavior or an unwillingness to be aware of a love partner's emotional needs. That has to be addressed and resolved, and one partner should not have to carry the entire load of making the relationship work. But as a personal example: My husband (NT) completely forgot our 50th wedding anniversary
I think women tend to romanticize more than men, and while it may be true that Aspie women romanticize less than NT women, I think it would be safe to say that for the most part it's a gal thing.
Last edited by cosmiccat on 01 Aug 2009, 4:11 pm, edited 1 time in total.
I think it might help for people here to hear his side. Otherwise it's impossible to really know what's going on from his perspective. Just because he has AS doesn't mean we automatically know what's going on. As all of us are different.
As I'm typing this, he has put the phone on speaker and just dialed the number of an acquaintance, and as the phone starts to ring at the other end, he's just rushed past me to go to the toilet. He is now pissing in our very echo-y bathroom and I can hear a woman's voice answering. *sigh* Why doesn't he KNOW how gross that is... I've told him a thousand times... so it's also this sort of social weirdness ALL the time that just wears me out and makes it pretty tough to assert my own needs at the end of the day... wow, he just flushed the toilet and is still chatting away...
Believe me... I'm ready to hear some advice.
I can assure you that this is not restricted to AS either. My husband does this, and I hate to say it will even take the phone into the bathroom and do his BM while talking. Sometimes he leaves the door open too. It completely grosses me out.
He just does not have the hang ups that I do regarding biological functions.
As I'm typing this, he has put the phone on speaker and just dialed the number of an acquaintance, and as the phone starts to ring at the other end, he's just rushed past me to go to the toilet. He is now pissing in our very echo-y bathroom and I can hear a woman's voice answering. *sigh* Why doesn't he KNOW how gross that is... I've told him a thousand times... so it's also this sort of social weirdness ALL the time that just wears me out and makes it pretty tough to assert my own needs at the end of the day... wow, he just flushed the toilet and is still chatting away...
Believe me... I'm ready to hear some advice.
I can assure you that this is not restricted to AS either. My husband does this, and I hate to say it will even take the phone into the bathroom and do his BM while talking. Sometimes he leaves the door open too. It completely grosses me out.
He just does not have the hang ups that I do regarding biological functions.
Yea. I don't think it's an aspie/autistic thing. I'm the opposite. For #2's I prefer to have a door that locks. Multi-stall public restrooms aren't private enough for me.
i guess they hate us for not doing things that they think we should be doing from them saying things in a way we are not able to understand
they should just tell us directly what they want and not make us go through basically cia level cryptography to figure out what they are wanting and refuse to say directly
I think men are missing out on a very important piece of their education that is supposed to be coming from their Father. Many guys are raised these days by single Mothers, most of whom do a marvelous job by themselves, but a boy still misses out badly by not having a Father in their life. Some who had a Father may have had a Father who is distant for whatever reason; he could not relate to his son, or whatever. I dare say most men have no clue how deeply wounding many seemingly, to him, minor behaviors can be to his partner. Why did my Father leave that out of my education? It's just simple how to lovingly treat your woman stuff. Why was that stuff left out of my upbringing. Trust me. These things don't just occur to most guys. Most get to discover from the school of hard knocks.
As to Feyhera's situation, I am not an MBTI INTJ which I am guessing her husband probably is, so it's hard to totally see from his perspective. Personally I have trouble sitting in the presence of a crying woman without being moved to cry with her, but I know from experience that it is hard to for me to know what to say when I know that the reason my wife is crying is because of something I have done, or failed to do. I try to put myself in her place and try to imagine receiving a hug from the perpetrator of her pain. What do I do, apologize? She has seen this in me before. Why would she think my apology would make any difference?
I also understand that everyone, even NT's are limited by the limitations of their own brain. Due to some of my own experiences, this has been personally demonstrated to me often.
I was given a little insight over the weekend by a friend of my wife. She was describing one of her neices that had been diagnosed as HFA, and she said that the neice would say these terribly blunt and cutting things to her friends and family, but she would not know that what she said was deeply cutting and she would get her feelings deeply wounded by the response of her friends. She could not understand why people kept getting mad at her. In her mind she was doing nothing wrong. She has no ability to perceive that her own responses to people's statements are the cause of her frustration.
wollstonecraft
Tufted Titmouse
Joined: 30 Jul 2009
Age: 73
Gender: Female
Posts: 34
Location: Philadelphia, Pa.
This is beautiful, Fiz! But that said, I suspect that Mary Shelley was an Aspie. She nailed how those seen as--and who see themselves as--normal, accepted, average, and mainstream, feel threatened by those who are different. I've always wondered if Mary Shelley was an Aspie who wrote Frankenstein from the perspective of being a kind of Frankenstein herself.
wollstonecraft
Tufted Titmouse
Joined: 30 Jul 2009
Age: 73
Gender: Female
Posts: 34
Location: Philadelphia, Pa.
I'm not around Aspies as a group, so I couldn't say whether or not we're more accepting than NTs, but I'm sure there is cruelty among us as well. I try not to let my painful experiences with NTs color my view of them. A lot of them have treated me with cruelty, scorn, and rejection, and I guess they felt threatened by me because I'm different.
I agree, Fiz, it's a gift. I wouldn't want to be any other way.
As to Feyhera's situation, I am not an MBTI INTJ which I am guessing her husband probably is, so it's hard to totally see from his perspective. Personally I have trouble sitting in the presence of a crying woman without being moved to cry with her, but I know from experience that it is hard to for me to know what to say when I know that the reason my wife is crying is because of something I have done, or failed to do. I try to put myself in her place and try to imagine receiving a hug from the perpetrator of her pain. What do I do, apologize? She has seen this in me before. Why would she think my apology would make any difference?
I also understand that everyone, even NT's are limited by the limitations of their own brain. Due to some of my own experiences, this has been personally demonstrated to me often.
I was given a little insight over the weekend by a friend of my wife. She was describing one of her neices that had been diagnosed as HFA, and she said that the neice would say these terribly blunt and cutting things to her friends and family, but she would not know that what she said was deeply cutting and she would get her feelings deeply wounded by the response of her friends. She could not understand why people kept getting mad at her. In her mind she was doing nothing wrong. She has no ability to perceive that her own responses to people's statements are the cause of her frustration.
I have trouble empathizing with blunt aspies as well. I'm the type that comes off as awkward and shy (even though I don't see my true self as being that way). I have too much anxiety to risk getting into conflicts with people so I'm always questioning myself and asking "will this offend them" before I speak. I'm a conflict avoider, almost to a pathological degree. I've gone to aspie meetings expecting to find others like me yet I found that some of them made me very uncomfortable. Of course I've also run across NT men with a similar personality who made me uncomfortable. I don't think being "blunt" is either universal or exclusive to people on the autism spectrum.
If I try to put myself in the shoes of Feyera's husband what I imagine is feeling guilty that she is upset because of something I did. Therefore it's awkward to try and comfort. It feels too contrived, like I'm being forced to do something out of guilt rather than true compassion. The compassion might be there under the surface somewhere but the guilt overwhelms it if I'm being blamed for something. I might walk away because I'm unable to face someone when it feels like I'm being shamed into it.
But this might not be what's going through Feyera's husband's mind. It might just be that he can't comprehend why she would be upset and the lack of comprehension frustrates him so much that he refuses to be supportive.
This reply is off subject but I am a lot like you. At my core I am very outgoing, but the exterior often feels like the connection between myself and others is made of cold molasses. With most people I need to know them well before I am able to feel at ease with them. There are exceptions but they are uncommon. I do spend a lot of time wondering will this statement be taken wrong. My self talk when deciding how to approach a person is more about "Will this cause me to be rejected?"
This reply is off subject but I am a lot like you. At my core I am very outgoing, but the exterior often feels like the connection between myself and others is made of cold molasses. With most people I need to know them well before I am able to feel at ease with them. There are exceptions but they are uncommon. I do spend a lot of time wondering will this statement be taken wrong. My self talk when deciding how to approach a person is more about "Will this cause me to be rejected?"
With me I don't think it's rejection I'm afraid of. It's really a paranoia of not knowing exactly what someone else thinks of me and whether some unspoken conflict will cause tension between us. I have a weird personality where I'm passive most of the time but I also have the autistic tendency to fly off the handle when I'm under stress or upset. I'm both shy and unexpectedly explosive sometimes. Therefore most of my coping strategy is avoiding tension and conflict. I react very badly to being scolded or yelled at.
Oh. This is an autistic tendency? Hmmm.
This is not an unusual trait or else I am unusual too. Avoiding tension and conflict used to be my strategy, but this approach can make one vulnerable to people who would take advantage. I have decided to work instead on my response. I now respond to being scolded and/or yelled at by going silent, which is also a rather passive approach, but I think it's an improvement on exploding in their face, which is a response my wife considers to be totally unacceptable.
