Adult Aspies are socially 11 years old?
swbluto
Veteran

Joined: 26 Feb 2011
Age: 38
Gender: Male
Posts: 2,899
Location: In the Andes, counting the stars and wondering if one of them is home to another civilization
I don't think so. I think it's more like having the social perceptions of an 11-year old, although I don't know that this is accurate either.
Well, the major difference between someone whose 42 years old and 11 years old is a difference in experiences, so I think there'd be some fundamental "social perceptiveness" that goes beyond experience. I'm not going to say that understanding would be *exactly* the same, as experience has a lot to do with understanding, but I'm guessing the "nuance", "subtlety" or "complexity" of your understanding would err towards the level of an 11 year old.
For example, let's imagine you see a female who's crying while a similar aged boy is walking away.
What just happened?
An 11 year old girl might assume that the boy said something hurtful to her.
An older girl may notice other clues, like the way she's crying and the way she appears to regard the person from her stance, to get a more accurate/complex understanding. Since she's not attacking him and doesn't appear angry and has a look of loss, maybe he just broke up with her?
Of course, *my* ToM might not be necessarily high enough to provide a "realistic" example (Like I really know how 11 year old girls perceive social situations), but I'm thinking that "social perceptiveness" might be at least partially characterized by something along these lines - an ability to intuit and understand other people.
Last edited by swbluto on 05 Nov 2011, 8:17 am, edited 1 time in total.
Verdandi
Veteran

Joined: 7 Dec 2010
Age: 55
Gender: Female
Posts: 12,275
Location: University of California Sunnydale (fictional location - Real location Olympia, WA)
I wouldn't say I'm socially immature, as in communication. I think I'm emotionally immature sometimes, like getting into huffs and storming off to my room slamming the door. I know a lot of people who do this, but I still think it's rather immature.
Yeah, I don't feel socially immature overall. I feel in a lot of ways I was more mature than my peers when I was a teenager. But in a lot of other ways I was immature and naive (and I think still immature and naive). Like Chronos (I think) said, it's uneven development, not a single across the board level.
Well, if you're stupid, I'm stupid, because I have very similar gaps in "adult knowledge." I don't think I'd know any better what to advise than you did in a similar situation.
Well I think I appear stupid to other people, because I have not got any intelligence to show either. I'm bad at maths, I don't have a very wide vocabulary (I use basic words, ''vocabulary'' and ''intelligence'' are even big words for me), I don't seem to know anything unless I've experienced it myself, I am no good at predicting outcomes (whoa, big words for me!), and I am no good at standing up for myself because it's part of Social Phobia what I have got (and I fear conflicts). But I do know when the right time is for me to stand up for myself, but I'm afraid to do it, so other people think I don't know that I know when the right time is (sorry, my explanations are poor). And I act daft all the time, like always getting in people's way in shops more than other people do, and also my severe object blindness. At least I'm aware of how stupid I appear to others. The only thing I'm quick at is when someone is explaining something to me and I understand what they're talking about before they've finished, so they're still saying every little detail as though I haven't understood, so I nod and say, ''yer, I understand, mate.'' I bet people don't see that coming. Nobody suspects Autism in me. They just suspect learning difficulties.
ps. By ''big words'' I meant words what have more meaning, rather than using boring words.
_________________
Female
CockneyRebel
Veteran

Joined: 17 Jul 2004
Age: 50
Gender: Male
Posts: 118,420
Location: In my little Olympic World of peace and love
I think "just can't walk in someone elses shoes" is spot on. I work in an elementary school, ages 4 to around 11. The kids have really no concept of that. It isn't that they are ungrateful animals, it just isn't developed at all.
Elementary kids live in the here and now. If I do A, the B happens, usually isn't even on their radar screen. Good or Bad.
Good as in "If we all clean up really fast, we will get 10 minutes more of recess."
Bad as in "If I kick that soccer ball into that boy's head, a whole lot of grief will be coming my way."
Girls have the slight edge in elementary school. I have had some girls (young as 7), spontaneously help out or ask if they can help out do some odd task. Any boys that do, usually come from a family with a really strong public service back ground,. (boy scouts, religious groups). Boys are just behind on the development curve, and don't start catching up until 12/13.
The thing that got my husband trashed at work was the small social stuff. Now, if I'm heading to the supply closet, and see Biff could use use black pens, I might say, "Heading that way, need some pens?" He may say yes or no. Either are fine to me.
Fior wouldn't even know what is happening around him.
Fior's thinking--->I need pens---->closet--->back. Now, sometimes you have to be that way, when stuff is flat out crazy, but Fior has no clue about other peoples needs. He isn't a selfish jerk. If you ASKED him to get pens, he would gladly do it. It never occurs to him to pay attention to his surroundings.
My biggest fights with my Aspie hubby (Fior) is over the total lack of thinking besides his immediate wants/needs. An 11 year old you would say, "I need your help making the bed. If you help, we can go (insert place) much faster, than if I have to do it all myself." Fior sees me struggling with some household task. He has no clue to ask me if I need help. And to tell you the truth, I get really tired explicitly stating I need A so we can get to B quicker. This is what toasted him at work. Having to have everything explicitly stated.
There must is be a certain point where NTs learn when it is a good time to help out without asking/or start small talk. In a work place situation or social event, Fior flounders. Between his over the top anxiety (what if I do something wrong--not realizing that sometimes it's when you do NOTHING can be worse), and Aspie social blindness, makes his life a living hell.
BUT this week Fior did something that makes me so very very proud. He helped out at my daughters holiday party at school.
This would usually be a nighmare, that Fior would decline, and I wouldn't push.
1) 24 sugared upped 7 year olds
2) teachers and parents he does not know from Adam
3) situation where there is nothing "set in stone". The party would be over in 45 minutes, but there wasn't an outline per say.
Fior's therapist told him he had to start working on his isolation issues for the sake of his family, and if he didn't, he would have 2 months to find another therapist. (It has been 2 years of stagnation since he lost his job)
So..Fior said yes. I told him, if he got dressed, went to the school, and then had to bale, no harm, no foul. I would just tell people that he was paged at work and had to go back. I would assign him to the treat table. He could just hand out the food.
He made it to the party, and actually ran one of the games with another parent. This is from a guy who hasn't seen really another person beside immediate family in 2 years.
Asked him later if it was a chore or enjoyable, and Fior said he had a good time. Though he did tell me the anxiety before the party was unreal.
I'll let you in on something NTs never talk about. We all get nervous before big events. I have met extremely few people that don't. I was nervous before that stupid party. I figured, we got music, juice and cookies. That's all a 7 year old needs to have a good time. And I stopped worrying after that.
Tawaki
You might find this website interesting. It has a lot of explanations of psychosocial development, and gives an idea of "normal" social development through different age groups. Not exactly a checklist, though!
http://www.sasked.gov.sk.ca/docs/social ... it_six.htm
Here's another description of school age, adolescence and early adulthood. It's interesting to compare it to ASD development, in terms of everything from cognition to self-concept. In many ways, people with ASD may be more mature than others their age, as they are aware of their own strengths, limitations, unique personality etc.
http://www.angelfire.com/ky/IBMS/person ... ge%20stage:
(adapting and copying for discussion purposes)
School age
The school age stage occurs from six years to twelve years of age. Children move out of their homes into worlds where they have to find their places, therefore their self concepts, value systems and cognitive capacities change. In addition, children enter the world of peer groups and their behavior is increasingly influenced by their peers (5). The child's competence in communication increases as physical, cognitive, and social development increase (1). Attending school implies new expectations from a child. They now represent their families who want to be proud of their child (4). At this stage, the child starts comparing him/her self with class mates or playmates (2). Such circumstances stimulate the child to be as better as possible so that pride of one self if achieved (3). This is the time when transition from ascribed to achieved status starts to take place. In school it does not matter how a child is in his/her family (loved, neglected, older or younger sibling) except when those factors have affected the child's personality in a way or another (5). In school, a child is treated as a part of a collectivity rather than as individual at home and this requires the child to forget many desires that may not enable him to fit into the group (7). All the previous demands organize the child's personality so that the child is able to prepare himself to live within a larger society rather than in a family (9). During this stage of development, a sense of belonging which makes the child feel accepted and as an integral part of the group and of the broader society occurs. This sensation involves identification of the society the child is a part of, beside commitment to its values and ethics. In addition, a sense of responsibility involving a capacity and willingness to live up to the expectations one has aroused evolves at this stage of development in the child's personality (4). The school child's evaluation of himself starts when adults, school mates and playmates evaluate him/her. A self concept that enables the child to regulate his ambitions and ways of relating to others is then established. A new set of values is acquired by the child and he/she starts to view his/her society from different perspectives (6). At this stage, children have rigid standards of what is right and what is wrong. Industry Vs inferiority represent this stage in the psychosocial theory of development (4). The developmental tasks of the school age child are: developing the social and physical skills needed for playing games, learning to get along with others, learning behavioral attitudes appropriate to one's own sex, learning basic reading, writing, and arithmetic skills, developing a conscience and morals, and developing a good feeling and attitude about oneself. During the later part of the school age child's development, often called preadolescence, the child begins to show more refinement and maturity in the following areas: becoming an independent adult and learning to depend on oneself, developing and keeping friendships with peers, understanding the physical, psychological, and social roles of one's sex, developing greater muscular strength, coordination, and balance, learning how to study (10).
Adolescence stage:
The adolescence stage of growth and development, which represent the industry Vs role confusion stage of the psychosocial theory of development, occurs from 12 to 20 years of age (4). The developmental tasks faced by the child at this age are accepting changes in the body and appearance, developing appropriate relationships with males and females of the same age, accepting the male and female role appropriate for one's age, becoming independent from parents and adults ,developing morals, attitudes, and values needed for functioning in society (10). During adolescence, although emancipation from parents in order to achieve independence and learning to accept responsibility for one’s self takes place, an adolescent still fluctuates between child-like dependency and stubborn independence. Peer groups play a critical role in the process of socialization and social interaction and self concept is gradually acquired as a result of reactions of his peers towards him (1). As mentioned previously, an adolescent undergoes active mental maturity since an adolescent becomes capable of more than abstract mode of thinking and the capacity of receiving new information reaches its peak. This sort of development results in endless speculations about abstract issues. In spite of that, the adolescent still feels uncertain i.e. lacks the ability to direct him/her self and the confidence to translate his/her thoughts and ideas into a definite course of action. Persistent arguing and pretended wisdom are characteristic features of adolescents (7). Moreover, an adolescent rethinks about matters of life he learnt to be true from his/her parents early in life (3). What the adolescent needs by the end of this stage is to find out what sort of person he or she is and what his/her abilities and limitations are, therefore the period of adolescence can be called the period of readjustment (8).
Young adulthood stage:
The stage of young adulthood occurs from 20 to 40 years of age. Psychological and social developments continue during this stage. A personal life-cycle develops during this period. Generally, it is during this period that a person establishes a relationship with a significant other, a commitment to something, and competence (5). Marital and vocational choices represent the determinants of one’s overall personality development in general and future personality development in particular, since they are two of the most significant decisions of a lifetime whose responsibility is born by the young adult (4). Commitment of oneself to a specific way in life takes place through marriage and child raising. A person has attained adult status with the completion of physical maturation, and, he/she has become sufficiently well integrated and emotionally mature to utilize the opportunities and accept the responsibilities that accompany it (6). His/her independence from their parental families motivates them to achieve an interdependence and find their places in society. Through vocation and marriage he/she becomes united to networks of persons, find tasks that demand involvement, and gain roles into which he/she fit which help define their identities (3). Most individuals will give up their much sought independence to share with another in marriage. Then the life cycle rounds to the point at which young adults are again confronted by the start of life, but now as members of the parental generation, and they often undergo profound personality reorientations as they become involved in the unfolding of a child’s life (10). This stage of life ends when a person has achieved stable positions in society and the time when his/her children no more need his/her attention. Intimacy Vs isolation is the representative of this stage in the Psychosocial theory (4). Developmental tasks of young adulthood include: choosing education and occupation, selecting a marriage partner, learning to live with a spouse and developing a satisfactory sex life (10).
J.
I'm definitely more mature than an 11 year old in some ways. In other ways I'm more childlike. I definitely have more intelligence, wisdom, and empathy than an 11 year old. My emotional intensity is closer to a child than an adult. I need more fun in my life. I feel like I was happier as a child. I don't fit into the adult world. I don't understand the joy of going to a "party" so you can stand around making small talk. I understand kids better because they prefer activity, actually doing things together, as opposed to standing around talking.
http://www.sasked.gov.sk.ca/docs/social ... it_six.htm
Here's another description of school age, adolescence and early adulthood. It's interesting to compare it to ASD development, in terms of everything from cognition to self-concept. In many ways, people with ASD may be more mature than others their age, as they are aware of their own strengths, limitations, unique personality etc.
http://www.angelfire.com/ky/IBMS/person ... ge%20stage:
(adapting and copying for discussion purposes)
School age
The school age stage occurs from six years to twelve years of age. Children move out of their homes into worlds where they have to find their places, therefore their self concepts, value systems and cognitive capacities change. In addition, children enter the world of peer groups and their behavior is increasingly influenced by their peers (5). The child's competence in communication increases as physical, cognitive, and social development increase (1). Attending school implies new expectations from a child. They now represent their families who want to be proud of their child (4). At this stage, the child starts comparing him/her self with class mates or playmates (2). Such circumstances stimulate the child to be as better as possible so that pride of one self if achieved (3). This is the time when transition from ascribed to achieved status starts to take place. In school it does not matter how a child is in his/her family (loved, neglected, older or younger sibling) except when those factors have affected the child's personality in a way or another (5). In school, a child is treated as a part of a collectivity rather than as individual at home and this requires the child to forget many desires that may not enable him to fit into the group (7). All the previous demands organize the child's personality so that the child is able to prepare himself to live within a larger society rather than in a family (9). During this stage of development, a sense of belonging which makes the child feel accepted and as an integral part of the group and of the broader society occurs. This sensation involves identification of the society the child is a part of, beside commitment to its values and ethics. In addition, a sense of responsibility involving a capacity and willingness to live up to the expectations one has aroused evolves at this stage of development in the child's personality (4). The school child's evaluation of himself starts when adults, school mates and playmates evaluate him/her. A self concept that enables the child to regulate his ambitions and ways of relating to others is then established. A new set of values is acquired by the child and he/she starts to view his/her society from different perspectives (6). At this stage, children have rigid standards of what is right and what is wrong. Industry Vs inferiority represent this stage in the psychosocial theory of development (4). The developmental tasks of the school age child are: developing the social and physical skills needed for playing games, learning to get along with others, learning behavioral attitudes appropriate to one's own sex, learning basic reading, writing, and arithmetic skills, developing a conscience and morals, and developing a good feeling and attitude about oneself. During the later part of the school age child's development, often called preadolescence, the child begins to show more refinement and maturity in the following areas: becoming an independent adult and learning to depend on oneself, developing and keeping friendships with peers, understanding the physical, psychological, and social roles of one's sex, developing greater muscular strength, coordination, and balance, learning how to study (10).
Adolescence stage:
The adolescence stage of growth and development, which represent the industry Vs role confusion stage of the psychosocial theory of development, occurs from 12 to 20 years of age (4). The developmental tasks faced by the child at this age are accepting changes in the body and appearance, developing appropriate relationships with males and females of the same age, accepting the male and female role appropriate for one's age, becoming independent from parents and adults ,developing morals, attitudes, and values needed for functioning in society (10). During adolescence, although emancipation from parents in order to achieve independence and learning to accept responsibility for one’s self takes place, an adolescent still fluctuates between child-like dependency and stubborn independence. Peer groups play a critical role in the process of socialization and social interaction and self concept is gradually acquired as a result of reactions of his peers towards him (1). As mentioned previously, an adolescent undergoes active mental maturity since an adolescent becomes capable of more than abstract mode of thinking and the capacity of receiving new information reaches its peak. This sort of development results in endless speculations about abstract issues. In spite of that, the adolescent still feels uncertain i.e. lacks the ability to direct him/her self and the confidence to translate his/her thoughts and ideas into a definite course of action. Persistent arguing and pretended wisdom are characteristic features of adolescents (7). Moreover, an adolescent rethinks about matters of life he learnt to be true from his/her parents early in life (3). What the adolescent needs by the end of this stage is to find out what sort of person he or she is and what his/her abilities and limitations are, therefore the period of adolescence can be called the period of readjustment (8).
Young adulthood stage:
The stage of young adulthood occurs from 20 to 40 years of age. Psychological and social developments continue during this stage. A personal life-cycle develops during this period. Generally, it is during this period that a person establishes a relationship with a significant other, a commitment to something, and competence (5). Marital and vocational choices represent the determinants of one’s overall personality development in general and future personality development in particular, since they are two of the most significant decisions of a lifetime whose responsibility is born by the young adult (4). Commitment of oneself to a specific way in life takes place through marriage and child raising. A person has attained adult status with the completion of physical maturation, and, he/she has become sufficiently well integrated and emotionally mature to utilize the opportunities and accept the responsibilities that accompany it (6). His/her independence from their parental families motivates them to achieve an interdependence and find their places in society. Through vocation and marriage he/she becomes united to networks of persons, find tasks that demand involvement, and gain roles into which he/she fit which help define their identities (3). Most individuals will give up their much sought independence to share with another in marriage. Then the life cycle rounds to the point at which young adults are again confronted by the start of life, but now as members of the parental generation, and they often undergo profound personality reorientations as they become involved in the unfolding of a child’s life (10). This stage of life ends when a person has achieved stable positions in society and the time when his/her children no more need his/her attention. Intimacy Vs isolation is the representative of this stage in the Psychosocial theory (4). Developmental tasks of young adulthood include: choosing education and occupation, selecting a marriage partner, learning to live with a spouse and developing a satisfactory sex life (10).
J.
Then I guess I'll be in the 12-20 stage for life as I really have no interest in sex or producing spawn, yet I really cannot function emotionally with no close relationship to anyone. Whenever I'm living completely on my own, lonliness and despair collapse my motivation to even want to continue the struggle for my existence.
I must admit, it is easier being a child than an adult - and most people I know say that. I didn't fear rejection when I was a child, and you don't need to follow so many rules, and it doesn't matter if you say stupid things because all children say stupid things (I used to like watching the programme ''Children Say The Funniest Things''). And you're allowed to be shy and untalkative too. Say if you went to a party, you have an excuse to have your mum by your side, and you don't have to talk to anyone if you don't want to, and nobody thinks you're unfriendly or untalkative. But me, I have to make conversation, and if I don't say anything people keep asking why I'm not talking, which gets me mad.
But now I would prefer to stand around chatting at a party than to run around and play. I don't like running around playing any more (I have matured in that way). But if only I wasn't so ''scared'' of speaking up in social situations with people I don't really know.....*sigh*
_________________
Female
The Sally Ann test sounds interesting. As an adult I would answer it in a number of ways. (For those who didn't Google it, Sally puts a marble in her basket. She then leaves the room. Anne then takes the marble and puts it in her box. Sally returns.)
Q. 'Where will Sally look for her marble?'
A(1). Nowhere. She is a doll.
A(2). In the correct place, because the person who controls her knows the answer.
A(3). In Anne's box. She would not "look for" her marble in her own basket because we only "look for" things when they are lost. In this closed system there are only two possible locations, and it is not possible to "look for" it in the basket. Ergo, if the question implies looking, it must be in the box.
A(4). Nowhere. She put the marble away, so does not want to play with it.
A(5). In the British Museum (Greek historical joke)
A(6). Anywhere at random. She went out for no reason and came back for no reason. She is clearly not rational.
A(7). In Sally's box. These dolls are owned by the psychologist. They have been used for this task many times. Sally must have learned by now that Anne always steals her marble.
A(8). Anywhere at random, because Sally has "lost her marbles."
The assumption is that NTs can see the other person's point of view. I doubt this, given the number of wars. NTs may be better on superficial measures such as controlling resources, but these abilities evolved for small hunter gatherer societies where murder was common. To understand humanity objectively we need, well, objectivity. NTs are too involved. If I wanted world peace I would choose Mr Spock, not Captain Kirk.
Q. 'Where will Sally look for her marble?'
A(1). Nowhere. She is a doll.
I remember this being one of my first reactions too. It probably would have been my answer as a child. That is, if I would have answered at all.
Given my kid-persona, it's reasonable to assume that I'd have remained silent and upon further attempts to get me to answer, I'd have cupped my ears and started to wail because of the social intrusion the test naturally imposes.
Doing so would have meant that I'd officially "failed" the Sally Ann test - without ever taking it, of course. But I'd have "proven" that autistic children "fail" the test because they have "no TOM".
Or perhaps, someone would have been smart enough to promise me a large amount of ice-cream or a box of marbles as a reward for playing the adults creepy game of talking puppets.
_________________
Autism + ADHD
______
The trouble with having an open mind, of course, is that people will insist on coming along and trying to put things in it. Terry Pratchett
Hmm. Interesting. Actually, it happened recently that I played with children rather than talked with their parents... And I'm not that afraid of speaking up in social situations, even with people I don't know very well. I'd say, it depends.
I am afraid of speaking up in social situations. Here's why:-
That came from a Social Phobia/Anxiety webpage and Autism is not mentioned anywhere, so I share a lot more in common with people who have Social Phobia/Anxiety than other Autistics, since other Autistics are all different and have all different reasons why they avoid social contact and social events.
_________________
Female
Similar Topics | |
---|---|
I feel socially broken |
Yesterday, 12:10 am |
Have you been assaulted? ( as an adult) |
04 Jun 2025, 2:37 pm |
Quashed conviction after nearly 40 years |
13 May 2025, 4:52 pm |
Elk Could Return to the UK After 3K Years In Rewilding |
07 May 2025, 6:50 pm |