Callista wrote:
I'm a psychology student, and... well, some of my classmates really don't have much intellectual curiosity. They just want to get the grades and get out. But it's hard to get into graduate school, and they're undergrads. I don't think a lot of them will be making it to a profession in clinical psychology, because while they can spend the sort of effort you have to expend to get the sky-high grades you need to get into clinical psychology graduate programs, they don't really enjoy learning. They'll probably get their undergrad degree and go into a field unrelated or peripherally related to psychology.
But if some of those non-curious people who don't like to think very much were to get that graduate degree and end up as psychologists and counselors, yeah, I could see them causing some serious problems. They're not bad people; they're just not people who like to think things through thoroughly--they're not natural scientists. A psychologist needs to be capable of--and enjoy--critical thinking and ongoing education. About three-quarters of the ones I've met do enjoy learning and thinking, but there are quite a few that don't. And those people, I can run circles around. It's sad when an undergrad like me knows more about psychology than a guy with a doctorate, but it can happen, if the undergraduate is an information sponge and the guy with the doctorate isn't really interested in learning. When I get somebody like that, I try to find somebody else. If I want to consult an expert about my weird neurology, I want them to actually be able to tell me things I don't know already, and to be willing to explain things to me and answer my questions instead of just expecting me to take it all on authority.
There are plenty of people who use psychology and psychiatry degrees as a path to money and social status. These people don't need to know much, just more than people know know nothing. Many clinicians aren't too particular about what diagnosis and treatment they give as long as they're collecting a check every week or two. I don't know what's worse; these people trying to treat clients or them teaching people to treat clients.