Thanks for all the insightful and also funny replies, you guys! Really paints a nice picture of how everyone individually deals with this. I'm quite surprised how many of you also feel uncomfortable when being complimented. I can get behind what whirlingmind said about seeing one's own inadequacies and expecting others to see them, too.
Reading your posts, I have to say I'm a bit embarrassed that I forgot to mention I actually do say 'Thank you' in general when I receive a compliment.
Max000 wrote:
OTOH, I do take criticism to heart.

That will piss me off. People usually mean it when they criticize you. What I really, really hate is when someone gives me a bunch of negative feedback, little or none of it constructive criticism, and then adds one little insignificant stupid compliment to try and make me feel better. F**k that, I'm ready to go postal at that point.

Dang, that sounds so annoying. I guess the compliment is meant to 'cushion the blow', except the people in question aren't doing a very good job at it. I know what it's like to be on the receiving end of a disproportionate amount of negative feedback, so I can guess where you're coming from.
VMSmith wrote:
or when people are complimenting me and i know they are but really it seems inappropriate to say thank you because i am not responsible for what the compliment is directed to. like being complimented on my shirt. i didnt make the shirt why are they telling me it's nice? i dont know if i should say thank you so i dont. the designer might be pleased though.
Yeah, I feel something similar. I think the point of the compliment is that they like your taste in clothing. I myself tend not to be too concerned about what I wear, as long as it's comfy, so when it ends up looking good in someone else's eyes. it's more of a coincidence... and unintentional on my part.
Toy_Soldier wrote:
Yes, there are quite a few types of negative, manipulative or useless compliments.
But there are also positive ones, genuninely meant, with good intention. Sometimes it is an expression of appreciation and at other times admiration. Rebuffing a genuine complimentor is like throwing food in the face of someone trying to share their meal with you.
That's an apt metaphor. Speaking for myself, it's rare that I encounter a compliment and expect an ulterior motive, it's more that I find it difficult to come up with the approprate thing to say... and then I lose the moment while trying to think of something.
_________________
clarity of thought before rashness of action