Diagnosed with autism (Aspergers) despite not having it

Post Reply New Topic

It's not "race" that could make the difference, it's "culture."

There is much "social expectation" within African-American and Caribbean cultures.....but being "black," in and of itself, has nothing to do with it.

A white person growing up in the above-mentioned cultures would possess the same characteristics. They would grow up with the same social expectations.

So in essence , if you were male and grew up in an all female family and were treated like all the females in the family your autism could be of a feminine nature ? or am I getting this wrong

I believe this could happen. Yes.

That's interesting , do you think it's also possible if your Trans.

Yep.

every days a school day , cheers Kraftie

It's not merely about sex/gender. Social expectations enter into it, too.....especially in something like Asperger's.

Social and cultural expectations.

Maybe, I don't see how it's impossible. BTW it was shown that females have the same symptoms as boys do with autism but they just show them differently. But yet I have read that have better social skills, copy them, do better with reading body language and facial expressions, mimic people. Girl autism can also have extreme sensory issues and above normal hearing which is common with autism.

I read somewhere that less black kids are diagnosed with autism and instead they are labeled as having behavior because of their skin color. I also read that black kids get suspended more than white kids. Like if a black child gets upset and pushes another kid, they get suspended while a white kid might only lose recess for the same behavior.

I wasn't black and I'm white but I was treated like I was black by my elementary school because they saw me as a behavior and kids in my 6th grade class can throw things and get out of their seats and no one would bat an eye but if I fell asleep in class or even read a book while the student teacher is teaching, oh no behavior problem I have.

That actually makes a lot of sense. I've noticed huge cultural differences when it comes to how social skills are taught. I've seen parents from various Eastern European countries teach social skills to their kids in a way that would be much more understandable to an autistic child than the learning by copying style that is more usual in my country. My husband insists that my entire country is autistic, and that I shouldn't worry about my lack of social skills, because nobody else has got them, according to him. Which is slightly funny and slightly offensive, but I see why he thinks that. There is a general inability to communicate coupled with blaming everyone else for one's inability to connect and communicate - it's always someone else's fault.

That's why I think the fuzzy end of the spectrum is very dependent on environment, culture and life experiences. I realize that this is anathema to autistics who would like it to be black and white - I don't even know if that is a pun.

@SaveFerris: BAP is not a diagnosis because the logical conclusion to it would be to turn everything into pathology - every character trait as a medical diagnosis.