How far would you go if a pre-natal test for Autism emerged?

Post Reply New Topic

How would the test determine where the fetus might lay on the spectrum? The child could be LFA or HFA. would that have to be a part of criteria?
What if well meaning people decided that 'nearsightedness' was a detriment to society, or 'deafness', or 'blindness'.
I would think that once any difference in a persons ability to 'function' in the world has been identified then all similar things that cause various dysfunctions should also be tested for. Like hair color, eye color, skin color. What if in a mixed marriage the childs skin color was tested for? Would the ACLU allow that?
A long time ago a political group in Germany had thoughts about testing people to weed out various characteristics that were deemed less than desireable in society and that experiment didn't work out to well.

How would the test determine where the fetus might lay on the spectrum? The child could be LFA or HFA. would that have to be a part of criteria?
What if well meaning people decided that 'nearsightedness' was a detriment to society, or 'deafness', or 'blindness'.
I would think that once any difference in a persons ability to 'function' in the world has been identified then all similar things that cause various dysfunctions should also be tested for. Like hair color, eye color, skin color. What if in a mixed marriage the childs skin color was tested for? Would the ACLU allow that?
A long time ago a political group in Germany had thoughts about testing people to weed out various characteristics that were deemed less than desireable in society and that experiment didn't work out to well.

you at it again mr garyww?

Actually, I would do none of the above, as far as the polling options go. In my experience, you don't win value wars by radical means, or even protesting. It's a matter of education, more than anything. You have to change hearts and minds.

One look at the mess we've been in here in the US with abortion will tell you that the above is true.

Nothing? 'As you like it' If it's voluntary.

I've been waiting for revolution since 1967.

With all the trash on the media lately about all the downfalls of autism, it would severely decrease the amount of children with autism born. You only have to look at china's population of girls vs boys right now to get the idea of the future if the test came.

In the minds of a scary amount of people, the choice they'll hear if asked if they want to carry a autistic child to term is 'do I want to look after this screaming, violent child who has no feelings, will suffer, be in constant pain (where did they get that from?), never say a word to me and have the IQ of a toddler forever. Because thats all that autism is people, spectrum is too much of a difficult concept ironically , and the idea that a child who can't express feelings or intelligence actually has them doesn't get through to people either.

Now if someone actually did a documentary of the acheivements of autistics. They could talk about history's greats, such as einstein and explain why those like him were said to have autism, how it contributed to his achievements. How many people with the diagnosis are productive members of society (every NT i'm talked to so far think that most diagnosed can't possibly hold down a job, get married, go to university). Then some of the acheivements of current diagnosed autistics, perhaps even comparisons between NT's and autistics, such as proportion of high achieving scientists with traits.

Then it could end by highlighting terrible goals of places like 'autism speaks' with an appeal to not let them jeprodise the future of people on the spectrum. A nice poll of those diagnosed who say that autism speaks speaks for them or doesn't would be useful too.

Seesh, I really want something like that on tv. With all the rubbish on, that I would love to see, something that actually put the right facts out there instead of all this misinformation.

I'm pro-choice. I wouldn't oppose it. Some people don't want what they assume is going to be a "damaged" child. As offensive as I may find that, I have to allow them to make that decision.

What about them? If it's your body and your pregnancy, then it's your choice. If it's not, then go away.

Don't bother giving me that "it's one of us" BS or mentioning genocide.