TonyHoyle wrote:
the sheer tastelessness of teaching a child to basically say 'give me sweets or face the consequences'
Yeah, that's always bothered me a little, too. Halloween is not big here, but on the few occasions I got trick-or-treaters I was tempted to say "trick". (I didn't, though, since I realise they're only kids and they're not the ones who came up with the idea.)
eric76 wrote:
realityasatoy wrote:
Now a days kids hardly trick or treat anymore because people have to be evil and poison the candy or my god put razors in the apples so now they just go to church parties. To me thats not what halloween is supposed to be. It kills the point to decorate, buy candy, kills the point to do anything for it really, you just send your kids to the church parties.
The reality is that it is quite rare for people to put things in the candy.
I did a search through the medical journals a few years ago and finally found precisely one mention in a journal on toxicology. And that mention was so non-specific that it may have been easily the same hysteria as is spread in the news.
The only real cases that we could find had to do with parents doing it to their own kids.
Indeed. Snopes even has two separate articles on the issue:
http://www.snopes.com/horrors/poison/halloween.asp
http://www.snopes.com/horrors/mayhem/needles.asp
Summary: random poisoning rumours are false (0 documented cases); random sharp object rumours are true, but blown wildly out of proportion (10 documented cases of even minor injury, worst case requiring several stitches).