Madeleine wrote:
I would like to put in a question:
If you take the existence of God as an absolute truth. Then God can do and create anything, right?
So can he create a stone that is heavier than he can lift?
If he can then he can't lift it and if he can't well then he can' create everything.
Come ON, I can't be the only person in the world who understands the idiocy of the "can god microwave a burrito SO hot' questions. These.. pretend 'paradoxes.'
It's nothing more than a statement combining two questions into one that don't logically fit together in the context of a being without limits, in order to make the answer NEED to have the word 'can't in it regardless, so that it can seem like it doesn't make sense.
If he CAN'T create a stone heavier than he can lift, that doesn't make him not omnipotent. Just because the word CAN'T is in the sentence doesn't mean he has any sort of limit. Think about it. God CAN'T be not able to do X. That's what it's saying.
But I have a feeling nobody's going to understand the subtleties of this concept, so I'll explain it this way:
The question SHOULD have been phrased like this, in two parts:
Can god create a boulder of any mass he wants? Yes.
Can god lift a boulder of any mass? Yes.
It'd be like if I said to you:
Me: Can you microwave a burrito SO hot, that even you can't look at it?
You: Uh.. no...
Me: Well I guess you can't microwave a very hot burrito then.
Anyone intrigued and perplexed by these god boulder idiot sayings are simple minded.