What Gender is Your Brain: Redux

Post Reply New Topic

There was a thread "What Gender is Your Brain," (http://www.wrongplanet.net/postt111707.html)
which referenced an online "brain gender test," but that test looked like something that someone just made up for fun off the top of their head. Someone in the thread suggested the Bem Sex Role Inventory test, so I decided to set up this thread using that.

The online test is here: Bem Sex Role Inventory test

The scores the test returns are messed up, so I've adjusted the chart below (if you look up Bem SRI info, the scores will be scaled differently).

M-score greater than 70 & F-score greater than 70 ==> androgynous
M-score less than 70 & F-score greater than 70 ==> female sex-typed
M-score greater than 70 & F-score less than 70 ==> male sex-typed
M-score less than 70 & F-score less than 70 ==> undifferentiated

As with any test there are criticisms. This test is basically about fitting gender role expectations and it was written in the 1970's (in the USA), so cultural changes in the last 40 years may have shifted the median scores (the "70" cut-off values in the chart). (Note: the online test returns weirdly scaled values, so I had to adjust the chart. If you look up stuff for the BSRI it will be in a different scale.)

Undifferentiated and Androgynous have the same scores. Is that intended?

53.509 masculine
72.5 feminine
59.167 androgynous

A little more feminine than I figured.

Ah crap, I think I did the conversion wrong -- I need to fix the chart.

Masculine 50.835
Feminine 69.167
Androgynous 57.5

Which is undifferentiated, apparently, just by a hair.

37.5 masculine
25 feminine
35.833 androgynous

Undifferentiated, then.

It would need a new thread to reset.

Ah well. Maybe there will be enough responses to dilute the error of the pre-correction responses.

I gave up after about 20 questions (question #20 was "feminine", which also rather threw me! - I answered "neutral"), because I kept having to answer "neutral", either because I simply didn't understand the question, or because I could give both of the two possible extreme answers simultaneously.

I'm still not very clear about the whole Aspie/NT thing (I'm slowly soaking it up, trying to form an intuition), but I felt the whole test (or what I bothered to read of it) was from a rather NT perspective. I would be quite surprised to learn that a lot of Aspies could answer these questions without having the kind of difficulty I had. Specifically, a lot of the questions seemed to be asking you to judge your own character as if from a generalised other person's perspective, and this is a real stretch for me.

OK, having got that off my chest, I pressed on to the end (like a man!):

Masculine 20/100
Feminine 61.7/100
Androgynous/neutral 38.3/100 [What does that mean? Is it just a coincidence that Feminine + Androgynous = 100, exactly?]

So, according to the test (which I take with a pinch of salt), I'm even less masculine than I thought, and a little bit more feminine than I thought. Overall, according to the classification given in the OP, I come out as "undifferentiated", which is what I expected, although this ignores my exceptionally low score for masculinity. I'm male, by the way, and for a long time I have wished I were female (although when I was growing up, I just wanted to have no sex organs at all, and to wear girls' clothes).

You scored 65.833 out of 100 masculine points, 57.5 out of 100 feminine points, and 63.333 out of 100 androgynous (neutral) points.

@Twirlip

I always find multiple-choice tests annoying, so I just went for it anyway. I always end up wanting to write an essay for each question. I'm not taking this test too seriously, though, so I'm content to just let people muddle through as best they can and see what happens.

As far as the scores, 1/3 of the questions are "male," 1/3 are "female," and 1/3 are neutral. The instructions for scoring says to ignore the neutral questions (though that does seem pointless and weird).

You scored 65 out of 100 masculine points, 57.5 out of 100 feminine points, and 53.333 out of 100 androgynous (neutral) points.

48/100 Masc 51/100 Fem 51/100 Androgynous