ediself wrote:
Is it really only an OCD thing? I only had a few as a teenager and they were more of the ridiculous kind than the "scary" kind, like, i would picture myself doing something totally random in the middle of class and had to fight laughing fits about it. But since then, I had two children, and i read about post natal depression as one does (at least i did) and it is very tightly associated with it. Could another form of depression trigger them? It could be worth exploring...
I suppose it could be other things; I don't know. All I know is that descriptions written by people with OCD line up with what people have been describing in this thread.
It might be possible that people who experience less disturbing 'intrusions' don't go to a doctor about it, so it isn't known to medicine. In my case the images/impulses line up with what people are saying here: thoughts of shooting my dad in back when deer hunting, images of razor blades cutting apart my hands, eyes, face, etc.
As to whether it's OCD per se, or OCD-ish -- I don't know, but I don't see a fundamental difference on a neurological level. In terms of the DSM, a person may not have enough traits to check enough boxes to be labelled with OCD, but if their experience is very similar to OCD lablled people, even if in isolated ways, it seems likely their brain likely has some OCD-ish wiring.
Or, perhaps there are people w/OCD with a type of autistic inertia. I don't see those two views as being different. The neurology and experiences are what they are, independent of human labels and the kludgy, crude DSM system of categorization.
My main reason for my previous post was just that if the intrusive thoughts are driving someone nuts such that they can't deal with it anymore, OCD might be a direction look in or ask a doctor about. (I'd half expect a doctor who doesn't know better to start thinking "psychosis," so people ought to know that may not at all be what it is.)