Korean view of Asperger
I just read Korean description of Asperger ( http://english.donga.com/List/3/all/26/252788/1 ) , and it seems like the way they described it is more similar to Cluster A Personality Disorders than to Asperger. Here are some quotes to this effect:
Well, if Asperger is a developmental disorder, then they were supposed to have problems their whole life, not just six or three months. This count of months reminds me of the way schizophrenia is being diagnosed, although of course they haven't mentioned hallucinations in that post. So it makes it seem like perhaps they are describing Schizoid Personality Disorder or something like that.
Well, I admit that one of the ways of "getting theory of mind wrong" is to err on the side of paranoia. But a far more common way of "getting it wrong" for Asperger folk is naivette. Yet that site didn't mention naivette, nor the lack of social skills in general, it just talked about paranoia. This again makes it seem like they are describing Cluster A Personality disorder.
Once again, its possible for those things to be defensive mechanisms of dealing with ostracism. But "possible" isn't the same as "typical". Plus, once again, they haven't said its a defense mechanism, they just presented it as a trait of its own, which again makes it seem like a description of a Personality Disorder -- this time Cluster B.
Well, if Asperger is neurological, why would it correlate with those mental disorders? So again they treat it not as neurological but as a mental illness.
But Asperger, as we know it, can't be cured. So, once again, it seems like they are describing some other disorder.
ASPartOfMe
Veteran
Joined: 25 Aug 2013
Age: 68
Gender: Male
Posts: 39,637
Location: Long Island, New York
The Curious Case of South Korea
So, what’s in a fact? Well, the origin of the interest in South Korea started with this book by Roy Richard Grinker. A father of a daughter with autism by fate and an anthropologist by training, Grinker writes about all things autism and culture. Grinker is a gift to the autism world, because he is really good at what he does. He’s an incredible anthropologist, who spent a lot of years writing about other cultures before he decided to make the personal professional and start studying autism. And study, he did. He spent time in South Korea, he did a lot of interviews. And what he found was this– some parents believe that having a child with a diagnosis of autism means that the family is genetically compromised.
Autism existing in a child means that all members of the family are less eligible for marriage, more likely the objects of discrimination, and more likely to be excluded from important social circles. Families report that they might even struggle to sell their apartment or property, because people don’t want to buy a house that someone with autism has lived in. One mother he interviewed said, “It’s like I’m always in the middle of winter.” He also documented that parents often prefer and try to aquire a diagnosis of Reactive Attachment Disorder (a rare disorder of severe, often irreparable childhood pathology caused by significant abuse or neglect by caregivers. It’s very rare often quite severe, marked by a complete lack of empathy bordering on sociopathy. The only child I’ve ever seen with RAD had to be locked in her room at night to prevent her from murdering her siblings.). This is NOT a good disorder to have. Yet parents in south Korea prefer it sometimes, because it means the mother can take the blame for poor care, as opposed to it being genetically linked to the entire family.
_________________
“Self Acceptance is a process not a performance”
“You are autistic enough. And you always have been”
Professionally Identified and joined WP August 26, 2013
DSM 5: Autism Spectrum Disorder, DSM IV: Aspergers Moderate Severity.
The quote that you gave implies that Koreans know autism is genetic -- in fact they know it so well that they are afraid that the entire family is genetically affected. Yet, the link that I gave shows just the opposite: they treat Asperger as something with onset at a specific time that can be cured within few years, which makes it look not-so genetic. Or are you saying they don't view Asperger as a form of autism: since being autistic is so bad, they have to separate Asperger very far from autism to save the aspies from stereotype -- and they are doing it by claiming that autism is genetic and Asperger isn't?
P.S. How come they ask the doctor to diagnose something else instead of autism, as opposed to simply lying as to what their diagnosis is? I mean, the doctors aren't allowed to tell others about the diagnosis anyway. Or are you saying in Korea they don't have such privacy policy?
I'd like to answer the postscript of the previous poster: It's not so much as the privacy policy is non-existent but that when others find out by either interacting with the child or other obvious signs. Like The Good Doctor was originally Korean and you can SEE basically everything mentioned by the previous posters. They have dramas on other mental illnesses like Doctor Frost. Like you see the general treatment of such individuals but they frame it as these larger than life situtions as opposed to the real small things that make up the bigger things. The reason The Good Doctor could easily be Americanized is BECAUSE some people here still treat autism as a blight on their family registry. Of course, dramas hardly take the place as the most accurate representation of the public's views but considering the projects were seen through to completion and there wasn't any protesting. . . It's kind of hard to believe that there aren't many people who believe this. I accept being autistic by American standards but I wouldn't claim it anywhere else unless I know the actual symptoms. There's a show Called Hello Counselor where people air their greivances for prize money, they treat disease or irrational behavior as something that can be cured by willpower and good intentions alone.
Credentials: I'm a bit of a weeabo.
_________________
I wondered, ". . . So therefore I exist."
