People are constantly telling me that I always look bored. The only thing is, I'm actually NOT bored. The facial expressions that NTs use on a day-to-day basis feel so awkward for me. My real smile doesn't even look like an actual smile unless I totally stretch my face and contort it. LOL
Facial body language just feels *so* fake, dramatic and over-the-top when I use it, but then I look in the mirror, and I actually look like an NT!
I think I'm just hypersensitive to every little twitch and movement in my face.
Is this an Aspie thing or is this just me being an oddball?

I also rarely laugh out loud. I do this weird silent laugh thing with my unsmiley smile, and it just looks like I'm smirking but my body is shaking from laughing. Weird...
And from inside my head, my voice sounds expressive, but when I listen to what I sound like on tape, I sound monotone!
Nope, it's not just you. I can feel like I'm smiling, but then look in the mirror and see nothing of the sort. I can say the same is true with my voice. It doesn't sound monotone to me, but people when they are honest will admit I have limited intonation. I am 47 years old and still don't have the smile lines (or naso-labial furrows) that most everyone has by age 30. In an article I read about autism, it was found in one autistic female's brain that the facial nucleus was much smaller than typical. To try to consciously do facial expressions is an exercise in futility.