This is a commonly reported characteristic, that is, the feeling as the OP describes it. It's to do with our wiring, and every peculiar characteristic we have has a natural purpose, or we wouldn't be wired this way!
It does cause lots of problems socially, as we just aren't meant to feel or socialize exactly the same with the NT world, and the possible reasons are complex, and would probably frighten some timid folks (like superstitious NT's).
The simple fact is that we don't really know fully who we are, and neither does the world. I feel that I know, but knowledge is something that each person has to discover and realize for himself, as long as we live in a world devoted to Ignorance rather than Knowledge.
The important thing, is to express what we feel; I understand your frustration, most everyone here does to one degree of another, we've all experienced what you describe.
Don't feel discouraged, despite our difficulties with NT's, we're still the Alpha's of the Mental world. 
_________________
He who sees all beings in the Self, and the Self in all beings, hates none -- Isha Upanishad
Bom Shankar Bholenath! I do not "have a syndrome", nor do I "have a disorder," I am a "Natural Born Scholar!"