Meeting the AS criteria later in life
I was told that some people go from autistic to Aspergers because they meet the Asperger criteria now. But I don't get it because it says in it there is no speech delay and developmental delay but doctors say because they are no longer developmental delayed and speech delayed they meet the AS criteria now. Has anyone ever been told this?
I was told this by my online friend and even my therapist said the same about me. She told me because my mother worked with me, I am no longer delayed in those area so now I meet the AS criteria.
Nah, it doesn't work like that.
People can start off with Autistic Disorder, and move up to a manifestation that's the same as Asperger's when they're older. Lorna Wing wrote of one child who had this happen in her first paper on AS.
They usually define this change of label due to these things changing: a strict desire for routine, social and emotional indifference, frequent "stimming", attachment to "useless" objects, etcetera, moving to the typical presentation of AS, which is socially odd and eccentric behaviour that's manifested in a one-sided and verbose approach to others, plus the all-encompassing cerebral interest.
Here's her case study:
The following case history is of a boy who at first was classically autistic and later developed the characteristics of Asperger syndrome.
C.B. is aged 13. His mother dates C.'s problems from the age of six months when his head was accidentally bruised. From this time he became socially aloof and isolated, and spent most of his time gazing at his hands which he moved in complicated patterns in front of his face. At one year old he began to watch the passing traffic, but still ignored people. He continued to be remote, with poor eye contact, until five years of age. He passed his motor milestones at the usual ages and, as soon as he was physically able, he spent hours running in circles with an object in his hand, and would scream if attempts were made to stop him. At the age of three he began to be able to recognise letters of the alphabet and rapidly acquired skill at drawing. He then drew the salt and pepper pots, correctly copying the names written on them, over and over again. For a time this was his sole activity. Following this he became fascinated with pylons and tall buildings and would stare at them from all angles and draw them.
He did not speak till the age of four, then for a long time used single words. After this, he acquired repetitive phrases and reversed pronouns. C. had many stereotyped movements as a young child, including jumping, flapping his arms and moving his hands in circles.
After the age of five, C.'s speech and social contact markedly improved. He attended a special school until aged 11, where they tolerated a range of bizarre, repetitive routines. At one point, for example, he insisted that all his class and the teacher should wear watches that he had made from plasticine before lessons could begin. Despite all the problems, he proved to have excellent rote memory, absorbed all that he was taught, and could reproduce facts verbatim when asked. C. was transferred to a normal comprehensive school at the age of II - He has good grammar and a large vocabulary, though his speech is naive and immature and mainly concerned with his own special interests. He has learnt not to make embarrassing remarks about other people's appearances, but still tends to ask repetitive questions. He is not socially withdrawn, but he prefers the company of adults to that of children of his own age, finding it difficult to understand the unwritten rules of social interaction. He said of himself, 'I am afraid I suffer from bad sportsmanship'. He enjoys simple jokes but cannot understand more subtle humour. He is often teased by his classmates.
His main interest is in maps and road signs. He has a prodigious memory for routes and can draw them rapidly and accurately. He also makes large, complicated abstract shapes out of any material that comes to hand, and shows much ingenuity in ensuring that they hold together. He has never had pretend play but is deeply attached to his toy panda to which he talks as if it were an adult when he needs comfort.
His finger dexterity is good, but he is clumsy and ill-co-ordinated in large movements and therefore is never chosen by the other children for sports and team games.
C. is of average intelligence on the WISC, with better verbal than performance skills. He does well on tasks needing rote learning, but his teachers are deeply puzzled and concerned about his poor comprehension of abstract ideas and his social naivety. They find him appealing but sadly vulnerable to the hazards of everyday life.
If you had a history in which you were delayed in one or several areas the criteria say you can't have a delay in, then that counts even when you're no longer delayed.
If you were delayed in those certain areas then you do not meet AS criteria - you really don't.
Because AS criteria demand that no matter how old you are, no matter how good you have become, you had to have no speech delay ever, no delay in adaptive behaviours and self-help skills and an age appropriately developed curiosity about your environment until the age of 3.
Some people just don't understand that, some others don't think it's important and some people have their own understanding of the disorder based on personal experience or personal opinion.
_________________
Autism + ADHD
______
The trouble with having an open mind, of course, is that people will insist on coming along and trying to put things in it. Terry Pratchett
In addition I would say there is an element of unfairness in this strictness.
Because either you look at AS from a biological point of view, that would require neurological diagnosis only (without considering childhood development).
Or you can look at AS from a psychological = symptomatical point of view. But then why considering symptoms that are no longer relevant?
Similar Topics | |
---|---|
ASD diagnostic criteria should be a little bit more broad |
30 Jun 2025, 4:48 pm |
Meeting Someone |
27 May 2025, 11:14 pm |
Meeting in the wild |
11 Jul 2025, 11:21 am |
Meeting girls at the beach. |
19 Jun 2025, 12:40 am |