Canaspie wrote:
It has been shown scientifically that such an argument between two extremely opinionated people such as these women is highly unlikely to change anyone's opinions. In fact, it would just make people on both sides believe in their viewpoint more strongly. There is no better way to convince someone their opinion is right than to tell them that it is wrong. When our viewpoints are challenged we simply feel much more determined to defend them.
So, in answer to your question, they would both win and they would both lose. See, it would depend on who you ask: people with more conservative viewpoints are going to declare Malkin to be the winner, while people with more liberal viewpoints will declare that Maddow is the winner. There simply cannot be one decisive winner.
Thanks for the insightful response, Canaspie. Very refreshing – more than I've been used to, of late.
envirozentinel wrote:
I'd like to know what would happen if someone developed an instant transport machine, something like a fax machine, where you put any object (cake, book, etc etc) in at your side and it dematerializes as you "fax" it anywhere in the world and it "reconstructs" or clones itself, at the other end. In other words, you could send anything anywhere!
Funnily enough, I saw an episode of
The Fabric of the Cosmos recently that showed such a theoretical transporting device. At both ends (starting point and destination) there are atoms that are linked at the subatomic level. What happens at one end instantaneously – and I mean instantaneously (irrespective of distance

) – affects atoms at the other end. In such a device, an object enters at one end and is scanned; the atoms at the other end make an exact copy of that object. Unfortunately, the original object is physically deconstructed in the process (something to do with the laws of subatomic physics), and is thus destroyed.
Which is fine for cakes, I guess. In theory, it would work for a person, too. And such a person's memories would, in theory, be retained in the new copy, even if the original person is destroyed in the process. Raises all kinds of interesting metaphysical questions.
What would happen if such a technology became available? Would you personally go through it? Under what circumstances might people in general use it?
_________________
It is easy to go down into Hell;
Night and day, the gates of dark Death stand wide;
But to climb back again, to retrace one's steps to the upper air –
There's the rub, the task.
– Virgil, The Aeneid (Book VI)