Autism Genotypes and Cure

Post Reply New Topic

Question to anyone who opposes cure, just to explore the matter (I am anti-cure, too, so it ain't like I want to offend anyone). Since autism likely is caused by many different genetic deviations, it is possible that there could actually be different kinds of autism, genetically speaking. Like, people with one mutation could be more like Asperger's, while others with another mutation, could be more like high-functioning autism, or low-functioning autism, etc., and still others could have autism along with certain physical health problems (like seizures, GI problems, etc.). Now the question is: if there were genetically different yptes of autism, would you want one to be cured but not the other? Suppose there were a cure for some autistic mutation that includes severe health problems, would you support that cure, assuming that it would be the only way to cure the health problems apart from current management (which is usually poor, eg. some people with epilepsy cannot be treated with anticonvulsants)? What if "low-functionign autism" were a distinct genotype from "high-functioning autism"/Asperger's (as some family research is already suggesting)?

It is not likely my support or non support will affect a cure or no cure, at all. At some point I feel it is just an intellectual exercise with no real affect on the practices of the world.

but then, I have always felt on the outside looking in.

There probably are different causes. As I have often said, Autism is just a collection of symptoms. It is quite possible for someone to have brain damage and present sufficient symptoms to be diagnosed as autistic, whereas another person with the same diagnosis might be genetically predisposed to it.

The question about a cure is futile at this point, but you might well be on to something with regard to different autistic genotypes.

Hans Asperger described "little professors", aged from 6 to 11(?), who were linear thinkers and who would talk endlessly about their subject of interest. However, at that age some of us where rather inclined to flap and watch sunbeams reflect off of dust motes and had no interest in conversing at length. Are these two different genotypes?

Equally interesting is the genetic relationship among various neurological conditions such as autism, ADD, OCD, and anxiety. Is there a genetic relationship among these conditions, and the physical conditions you mentioned as well?

Well, I'll be stupid and point out the same thing I always do-- that two people can have the same behavior for completely different reasons, or completely different behavior for the same reasons.
The child who sits and stares at something for hours on end may have very similar reasons for doing so as the one who talks about that something for hours on end. Both are obsessing and neither is actually paying any attention to anybody else, despite the fact that the talkative one is talking, they're still not interacting.
The brain is just too complicated, and too many different factors interact with each other to produce any given result. You can talk about what causes something, but then you have to keep going, and think about what caused the cause, and what's being caused by the effect.

It is Genetic, so there is nothing that can be done. Reprograming genes is science fiction, along with nanobots, chip implants.

All suggested treatments are the same as deleating part of a computers opperating system, it may be causing a problem, but without it nothing boots.

The Bernie Madoff gene does a lot more social damage, go study it.