Great input guys. I just got Frances the Mute, and it blew my mind. Here is my comparison based entirely on my subjective human opinion:
De-loused - More consistent, more accessible, in the spirit of fun, distinct songs, more attitude, better singing and melody lines.
Frances - Its high points were higher, its low points were a little less tolerable than on De-loused, I prefer it conceptually, more human, more dark, and I felt like they were taking themselves more seriously this time around.
I guess each of them have different strengths, but both blew my mind, which doesn't happen often with the same artist. I will refrain from trying to judge which is better, since I've only heard Frances once.
Well, it's now the very end of the decade, and I'm still finding it hard to consolidate my feelings on which are the very best, so I'll cheat by making up some categories:
Most culturally significant album - Kid A
Greatest display of technical proficiency - Drukqs
Most beautiful album - Takk
Album I always feel like listening to - Origin of Symmetry
Most lyrically strong album - Lateralus
Just my personal favey
- Deadwing