Adamantus wrote:
ScrewyWabbit wrote:
Maybe I need to update my definition of what it is that I listen to. Solaris International, which is what I listen to most plays a lot of "Trance and Progressive" but I don't know whether I'm sure what the difference is. I hate the boring linear banging baseline and chavy vocals but I like the tracks with more subtlety to them. Some of my favourites are:
Bent - As you fall.
Come Home - Alpha 9
Diamonde - Asymetric Soul
Drifting - Dale Corderoy
My Sanctuary - First State
Pictures in my mind - Dave 202
I think those tracks are probably worth more than 80% of the other tunes I have, put together.
I never quite got the difference either except trance and prog are supposed to be sub-genres of house music, which is by definition supposed to use a 4/4 beat (i.e. four to the floor, thump thump thump thump with the drums on the main drum line, but also with some drum rolls, drum breakdowns etc). I think prog tends to have a bit of a deeper, bassier sound where trance is a bit more repetitive and relies more on a synth lead sound, especially in some of the hard core trance sub-genres, like goa-trance or psy-trance. Breaks by definition is not house music, as it doesn't use a regular 4/4 beat but instead uses a variety of different, more irregular beats.
Having said all that, I find that even when two people agree on the definition of what constitutes a genre of music, they might well both listen to the same song and disagree as to its genre. So I'm not sure there's a "right" and "wrong" to any of this stuff.
As to the tracks you mentioned, I'm certainly no expert at classifying this stuff but here's how I interpret them:
Bent - As you fall - is there a particular remix of this you are thinking of because I just listened to it on youtube and its WAY too downtempo to really be thought of as trance :
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYwpUt0JoMc[/youtube]
Come Home - Alpha 9 - probably would be considered more prog or vocal trance
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ABQ8M35oJpU[/youtube]
Diamonde - Asymetric Soul - couldn't find it on youtube
Corderoy - Drifting - This would probably be trance in my book, the trancy-est track so far
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5TvlN-lCbU&feature=related[/youtube]
My Dictionary - First State - to me this is really not trance, there isn't a steady uptempo beat - this would probably be considered downtempo, chillout, or even ambient or minimal....
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0OYeWQxmY_k[/youtube]
Pictures in my mind - Dave 202 - yes, this I think I would classify as trance
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=95FRokI5e34[/youtube]
Some older tracks I think would be considered as classic trance would be things like:
Cafe Del Mar - Energy 52:
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RVoYWHlxEzE[/youtube]
Robert Miles - Children
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NRCkAumK5b4[/youtube]
Binary Finary - 1998
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IF2wKZMfdiI[/youtube]
Rank 1 - Airwave
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ypDtUUtuNzQ[/youtube]
Or for vocal trance, Tilt - Invisible
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P1DM0I5B1Bo[/youtube]