To each their own. I'm thin and always have been. Never really tried to diet except a few times to lose five or ten lbs, but never stuck to it and I'd lose them in a couple of months anyway because of my metabolism. I've never cared for heavy men. I've never cared for skinny men either. I've always liked my guys to be well built and muscular, but I don't require bodybuilders, although they are nice!
My older daughter is thin like me and has my metabolism. My younger daughter is overweight and has my MIL's metabolism. She tries to lose, but it's difficult, but she's hardly desperate! She has no problem finding a bf, and wouldn't ever want to be with a guy who thought he was "settling" with her, and certainly not one who had to settle for less than his ideal because of some problem he has. She's never gone out with heavier guys though. I don't know what she thinks about them, she's never told me. Even though she's pretty big (not reality show big, maybe 225 but she's also got boobs and a butt) she's pretty, she's popular, she's fun to be around, she has lots of friends and she certainly does not have to just "take what she can get".
My older daughter has been with her bf for five years. He's tall and well built, but he's gotten kind of chunky before. He put on some weight for about a year, and now he's lost it again and they go running and bike riding together.
Neither of my girls would choose or reject a guy because of weight. However, that doesn't mean that they, like everyone else, don't have a preference for body type.
My oldest son is with a heavy girl. She's also crazy and covered in tattoos. When I say crazy I mean truly seriously mentally ill crazy. She's also not very pretty although when I first met her I thought she had a nice personality. Everybody says he can do better, and he can, and by that I don't mean her weight or looks, (although some do, he's very handsome) I mean her craziness.
My younger son doesn't like heavy girls at all. That's just his preference.
I have a friend my age who is a single guy who absolutely hates girls who are under 200 lbs. He's a big guy himself. A One Percenter. He thinks skinny women look terrible. That's his prerogative and he certainly doesn't feel that he's settling if he dates a big girl.
So, to each their own.
Don't assume that heavy girls will date anybody and be grateful just because they are heavy. My younger daughter is very picky and can certainly affford to be, even though she is heavy. She is asked out as much as my older, thin daughter was before she had a steady bf.
Maybe we should start a thread on skinny boney guys and why they would be easy to date because they are desperate (as you seem to assume that heavy girls are).
_________________
I'm giving it another shot. We will see.
My forum is still there and everyone is welcome to come join as well. There is a private women only subforum there if anyone is interested. Also, there is no CAPTCHA.

The link to the forum is
http://www.rightplanet.proboards.com