This Valentine's Day, reach out to someone
thumbhole wrote:
Anyway the moral of the story is: don't pretend to people that they have an admirer when they don't. It may temporarily make them feel happy, but in the long run, it will only make them more sad.
Edit: just wanted to add that it wasn't such a stupid idea as it might appear, because my sister is actually EXTREMELY attractive, so she did have lots of admirers at the time even if they weren't bothering to send her any flowers. (It was her teenage years. Teenage boys don't usually bother with flowers and romantic gestures).
If she had been an extremely ugly or unpopular person, then it would have been cruel to send the flowers and create a false hope of there perhaps being somebody out there who liked her. In my sister's case there were (and still are) loads of boys who like her!
Edit: just wanted to add that it wasn't such a stupid idea as it might appear, because my sister is actually EXTREMELY attractive, so she did have lots of admirers at the time even if they weren't bothering to send her any flowers. (It was her teenage years. Teenage boys don't usually bother with flowers and romantic gestures).
If she had been an extremely ugly or unpopular person, then it would have been cruel to send the flowers and create a false hope of there perhaps being somebody out there who liked her. In my sister's case there were (and still are) loads of boys who like her!
I'll explain. Whether she is popular or not the gesture gave her false hope. It doesn't stop you from loving someone any less when you are popular. When it is such a kind gesture from someone you thought really fancied you back, only to discover that person never had feelings for you. It's like discovering someone who loves you and then suddenly that person has died because they never existed in the first place. You build up all your hopes on that person and the gesture that they gave to you, only to find out they never even loved you. It would have made her feel like an idiot. It would feel very painful and a very cruel joke.
But I didn't mean it as a cruel joke. I meant it to cheer her up.
Can we drop this subject now and get back to the thread? I didn't expect so many people to hone in on my post and comment on it. The reason I posted it was as an example of what NOT to do. I think we're all in agreement that what I did isn't a good idea, so can we stop discussing it now? It's making me feel upset. I meant well, I really did. It was not my intention to be cruel or hurt her. It was my intention to make her feel special and happy. Please can we stop talking about it? As I've said, I vowed never to send anonymous things again, so you don't need to bother telling me not to do it again. I already learned that. Thank you.
thumbhole wrote:
:(
But I didn't mean it as a cruel joke. I meant it to cheer her up.
Can we drop this subject now and get back to the thread? I didn't expect so many people to hone in on my post and comment on it. The reason I posted it was as an example of what NOT to do. I think we're all in agreement that what I did isn't a good idea, so can we stop discussing it now? It's making me feel upset. I meant well, I really did. It was not my intention to be cruel or hurt her. It was my intention to make her feel special and happy. Please can we stop talking about it? As I've said, I vowed never to send anonymous things again, so you don't need to bother telling me not to do it again. I already learned that. Thank you.
But I didn't mean it as a cruel joke. I meant it to cheer her up.
Can we drop this subject now and get back to the thread? I didn't expect so many people to hone in on my post and comment on it. The reason I posted it was as an example of what NOT to do. I think we're all in agreement that what I did isn't a good idea, so can we stop discussing it now? It's making me feel upset. I meant well, I really did. It was not my intention to be cruel or hurt her. It was my intention to make her feel special and happy. Please can we stop talking about it? As I've said, I vowed never to send anonymous things again, so you don't need to bother telling me not to do it again. I already learned that. Thank you.
Don't worry about it. I'm going to be completely candid right now and tell you that if I knew someone in your sister's situation, I would have considered doing the same thing. If you're going to make a mistake, making a mistake out of compassion for another person is about the best kind you can make.
thumbhole wrote:
:(
But I didn't mean it as a cruel joke. I meant it to cheer her up.
Can we drop this subject now and get back to the thread? I didn't expect so many people to hone in on my post and comment on it. The reason I posted it was as an example of what NOT to do. I think we're all in agreement that what I did isn't a good idea, so can we stop discussing it now? It's making me feel upset. I meant well, I really did. It was not my intention to be cruel or hurt her. It was my intention to make her feel special and happy. Please can we stop talking about it? As I've said, I vowed never to send anonymous things again, so you don't need to bother telling me not to do it again. I already learned that. Thank you.
But I didn't mean it as a cruel joke. I meant it to cheer her up.
Can we drop this subject now and get back to the thread? I didn't expect so many people to hone in on my post and comment on it. The reason I posted it was as an example of what NOT to do. I think we're all in agreement that what I did isn't a good idea, so can we stop discussing it now? It's making me feel upset. I meant well, I really did. It was not my intention to be cruel or hurt her. It was my intention to make her feel special and happy. Please can we stop talking about it? As I've said, I vowed never to send anonymous things again, so you don't need to bother telling me not to do it again. I already learned that. Thank you.
I'm sorry things didn't work out the way you had planned. In hindsight the anonymous thing might've given her the wrong impression, but she had no right to get so frustrated with you. I imagine she was taking out her anger on the first available target, which was you. I've been there. My sister is much the same way...there's a lot about her life with which she's not happy, and I recently made a mistake with her and she really pounced on me in an unfair way.
Go forward, and keep trying to reach people. I think the people who react angrily to kindness are people you don't want to be around too much, but that shouldn't be a reason to write off everyone. Keep displaying that kindness until you find someone who returns it.
The_Face_of_Boo wrote:
thumbhole wrote:
I tried doing this for somebody years ago and it went spectacularly wrong. If you do send someone a Valentine to cheer them up, make sure you don't do it anonymously!
My sister was crying her eyes out over a break-up and was having very low self-esteem. I sent her some flowers and a teddy bear anonymously, and stressed with the florist the importance of not giving away who they were from. I wanted my sister to think they were from a secret admirer.
My sister cheered up remarkably, but unfortunately she and her best friend started doing some detective work to try and find out who had sent the flowers. They started to formulate a theory that the flowers were from my sister's best friend's brother.
Things got rather awkward from his point of view, so I phoned my sister and confessed that the flowers had actually been from me.
I was expecting her to be appreciative of the fact that I had wanted to cheer her up and had spent all that money on her and didn't want her to feel sad. Instead, she was angry to find that her best friend's brother didn't have a crush on her after all, and she had been made to look foolish by asking him if the flowers were sent by him.
She took it out on me. She raged and ranted angrily at me in tears, and said things like: "how COULD you? How could you do such an awful thing?"
I will never understand NT logic. Apparently, sending your sister expensive anonymous flowers because you think she's awesome and want to cheer her up = "an awful thing."
Be careful. If you try to cheer somebody up on Valentine's Day out of the kindness of your heart, you may be accused of being a hurtful nasty scumbag.
After this hurtful experience I vowed never to send anonymous Valentines ever again (unless, of course, I really mean them. There's nothing wrong with sending an anonymous Valentine to somebody you genuinely like, but sending one to someone you don't have a crush on may seem kind, but will only generate false hopes).
My sister was crying her eyes out over a break-up and was having very low self-esteem. I sent her some flowers and a teddy bear anonymously, and stressed with the florist the importance of not giving away who they were from. I wanted my sister to think they were from a secret admirer.
My sister cheered up remarkably, but unfortunately she and her best friend started doing some detective work to try and find out who had sent the flowers. They started to formulate a theory that the flowers were from my sister's best friend's brother.
Things got rather awkward from his point of view, so I phoned my sister and confessed that the flowers had actually been from me.
I was expecting her to be appreciative of the fact that I had wanted to cheer her up and had spent all that money on her and didn't want her to feel sad. Instead, she was angry to find that her best friend's brother didn't have a crush on her after all, and she had been made to look foolish by asking him if the flowers were sent by him.
She took it out on me. She raged and ranted angrily at me in tears, and said things like: "how COULD you? How could you do such an awful thing?"
I will never understand NT logic. Apparently, sending your sister expensive anonymous flowers because you think she's awesome and want to cheer her up = "an awful thing."
Be careful. If you try to cheer somebody up on Valentine's Day out of the kindness of your heart, you may be accused of being a hurtful nasty scumbag.
After this hurtful experience I vowed never to send anonymous Valentines ever again (unless, of course, I really mean them. There's nothing wrong with sending an anonymous Valentine to somebody you genuinely like, but sending one to someone you don't have a crush on may seem kind, but will only generate false hopes).
Well, dude...this has nothing to do with NT/AS conflict.
What you did was plain stupid.
lol

