auntblabby wrote:
common sense. yes, i have some, believe it or not.

i know i am not an Adonis but neither am i Quasimodo. i am not bill gates rich and smart but neither am i presently homeless, i have a roof over my head that i own, and i am [so far, god-willing] financially solvent. that puts me squarely in the middle between a 0 and a 10. i hope that made sense.
Okay, so by your own rating of yourself, you were a 5/10. That's great. However, you're self-rating is irrelevant; perhaps the women you considered to be 5/10 may have realistically seen you as a 3/10 IN THEIR EYES. After all, they're the ones who have to decide how attractive you, regardless of how attractive you believe you are.
Men really can't judge the looks of other men; rather, we can't assume guys we commonly see as decent or ugly are perceived the same way through the eyes of women. When we see a "good-looking" guy struggling and assume it can't be his looks, in the perception of the opposite sex, that man may be considered hideous. When we see an ugly guy with a pretty girl, there is a chance he's not as ugly in their eyes as we perceive him to be.
I remember you saying you thought Elliot Rodger was a gorgeous specimen of a young man. But don't assume your perception of his attractiveness is how the average woman would have seen him. No, I'm not talking beauty/beholder individual stuff. I mean, collectively, guys we think look decent may, in fact, be seen a below the passable looks threshold in the eyes of most women.
Adonis/Quasimoto are the extremes. Nearly everyone can tell a male model will be very appealing to women, vs the circus freak who doesn't even look human. But with a group of men that we see and think of as all being "average, ordinary," the opposite sex may see as "some are passable vs. others who are ugly."
So, anecdotal stories from men about "I think my one friend is better looking than my other friend, but the better looking one struggles with women, maybe he needs confidence." How do you know, in the eyes of women, which one is actually more attractive?