Why would my family say these bad things about marriage?
The_Face_of_Boo
Veteran

Joined: 16 Jun 2010
Age: 43
Gender: Non-binary
Posts: 33,451
Location: Beirut, Lebanon.
The_Face_of_Boo
Veteran

Joined: 16 Jun 2010
Age: 43
Gender: Non-binary
Posts: 33,451
Location: Beirut, Lebanon.
* "When your wife yells at you, you will be quiet and listen to her! She does it because she cares about you."
* "You will meet a woman someday, and she'll care about you very much!" (said in an angry tone)
* "When your wife cooks something, you will eat it and be thankful for it, even if it's something you don't like!"
None of this is healthy. I'll keep any further comments to myself as I don't really want to insult your parents... but you should probably seek advice from other people (therapists, friends, etc... about what a marriage looks like)...
Aspie 1, I guess I will never understand your family. Either that, or your view of things they have said and done is so distorted it doesn't resemble the reality at all (not impossible for anyone with ASD, just due to the communication and perception differences, based on my experience with my own son, at least). I will never know with certainty which is true, but I am sorry you've experienced so many challenges with your family all these years either way. I know that your frustrations are certainly real and valid, and I wish you didn't have so many of them to deal with and sort through.
_________________
Mom to an amazing young adult AS son, plus an also amazing non-AS daughter. Most likely part of the "Broader Autism Phenotype" (some traits).
Are you living in some den of abusive relationships or something? Then better stay single, away from your family.
I'm sure a typical narcissist or alcoholic doesn't mean to be abusive, too. People seldom mean to be abusive, they are quite often unaware they are.
Yes, they may sincerely believe this is how it all works.
And we say: it doesn't have to.
Anyway, if you don't want to get married, don't get married. It's your non-dirty freedom to choose.
_________________
Let's not confuse being normal with being mentally healthy.
<not moderating PPR stuff concerning East Europe>
The_Face_of_Boo
Veteran

Joined: 16 Jun 2010
Age: 43
Gender: Non-binary
Posts: 33,451
Location: Beirut, Lebanon.
Dw mom:
These things:
* "When your wife yells at you, you will be quiet and listen to her! She does it because she cares about you."
* "You will meet a woman someday, and she'll care about you very much!" (said in an angry tone)
* "When your wife cooks something, you will eat it and be thankful for it, even if it's something you don't like!"
is a VERY typical and common dynamic scenario from wife to husband; my mom frequently used to yell at my dad when he does something she doesn't like - very rarely he ever yelled at her (only in very very very few anger moments). My aunt and her husband are the same but her man is less polite.
I noticed it too in married friends, a lot of male married friends joke about it when we are in guys-only outing and they're like "I have to leave early, or else wife is going to yell at me ". And a lot of times wives make snarky remarks at their husbands in public.
Wife yelling/snarky commenting at husband, and showing a kind of revulsion/annoyance at husbands, is a very common and typical thing, and there's no social boundary for it because it's not considered verbal abuse when it's coming from a woman against man.
It's a lot more common to see control freak wives than husbands, even in this part of the world - surprisingly no?
Typically, when men are bothered about something in wife, they shut up, they bottle it up forever - but typically women don't.
And you have this: https://www.inquisitr.com/1474808/scien ... -husbands/
Because it's ok for a woman to be emotional, but a man has to be stoic. I noticed this in my relationship as well. My wife said that she can yell at me because she is a girl and I am not allowed to yell because I am a boy.
The_Face_of_Boo
Veteran

Joined: 16 Jun 2010
Age: 43
Gender: Non-binary
Posts: 33,451
Location: Beirut, Lebanon.
Because it's ok for a woman to be emotional, but a man has to be stoic. I noticed this in my relationship as well. My wife said that she can yell at me because she is a girl and I am not allowed to yell because I am a boy.
You're Russian, right? Do many Russian wives have this attitude?
AngelRho
Veteran

Joined: 4 Jan 2008
Age: 47
Gender: Male
Posts: 9,366
Location: The Landmass between N.O. and Mobile
Because it's ok for a woman to be emotional, but a man has to be stoic. I noticed this in my relationship as well. My wife said that she can yell at me because she is a girl and I am not allowed to yell because I am a boy.
I look at this two different ways.
On the one hand, it’s trendy for men to be henpecked because the pattern has always been that men were dominant and could abuse women without any thought to consequences. The more liberal society becomes and favors women, the more pressure men have to deal with a double-standard.
It’s a consequence of feminism being so widely adopted that husbands have become so neutered. I’ve dated women who were like that, who seemed to claim ownership of me without like reciprocation, i.e. I have no right to “be a man.”
While I fundamentally disagree with the OP reasoning for avoiding relationships, I firmly believe that if that’s what relationships are all about, there are better and more important things in life. My objection is just that not all relationships are like that, nor do they have to be like that.
The other side of the coin just deals with what roles you choose for yourselves in a lifelong relationship such as marriage. My wife sees me more as an executive. A decision-maker, someone who establishes a shared vision and provides a big-picture direction for the family. She sees herself as a details person, a doer, an “operations director” of sorts. At home, she would say the best thing I can do is stay out of her way and let her work. If I want to step in and help, it has to be done HER way. Because she works hard in and out of the home, she’s really not up for dealing with my needs or urges, so intimacy is strictly on HER terms.
If that’s the dynamic we’re talking about, then fine. I don’t mind her being the boss. And she doesn’t feel so much pressure because our ultimate success or failure is on me. She gets praised for the good stuff, I take blame for the bad stuff.
I don’t feel neutered because she allows me to do what I need to do and what others need me to do. We share one vehicle for the whole family, so the one night a week I have to get to my other job before she gets off work I change clothes and run 5-6 miles across town where she joins me later on with the kids. I work that into my exercise routine, and I work out a few times per week besides.
If I played in a band and had gigs, she wouldn’t give me a hard time about it. If I actually had friends to hang out with, she’d be ok with it. When I need to buy a new musical instrument, she doesn’t give me a hard time over it. Actually, I did buy a new piano for gigs and made the money back in about 3 months and was able to bring in a lot more for a year after that. Took some online classes to get my teaching license reinstated, bought a new high end laptop with music software and sample libraries and it’s like I never spent a dime for it. She’s just that cool because she knows those things end up benefitting us both.
A lot of women would be, like, ok, you didn’t spend money on ME??? How come YOU get nice things and I don’t?
If letting a woman run the house means that I can do what I need to do, I’m all for that and don’t mind getting bossed around a little.
There is a line between that and abuse. There is absolutely NO REASON WHATSOEVER for any woman to yell at a man or for a man to yell at a woman. My wife and I treat each other like reasonable adults. We talk business when we have to. We debate important things. We disagree sometimes. We get frustrated. The frustration is usually about things we find we can’t both get our way on. We’ll reach a point where we agree that there’s just no way to get what we want, so we let it go and move on to something else. We both have those “line in the sand” moments sometimes that we have to work through. But for the most part, we avoid zero-sum games in our life together.
We don’t yell our insult each other. We don’t trash each other around other people, neither around each other or even in private. People think I dominate her because I have the final say, but they really don’t understand what it’s like being us.
What disturbs me about it all is our society has pushed female dominance so much that people sometimes make fun of us BECAUSE I don’t necessarily back down and obey my wife, like being “the man of the house” is something to be ashamed of. Like she SHOULD yell at me, or we should come to blows on things. Or if we don’t agree on something she should blab our private business to her friends. Instead, she’s publicly supportive of me and brings relational and personal issues directly to me.
And we fix things, and hold hands in public, and don’t avoid each other like there’s something to be ashamed of. We work as a team.
The idea that a man should dominate a woman or a woman should dominate a man is absolute trash. I’m married, not neutered. We’re allowed to work together as equals, sharing everything and not complaining about it. I think it’s the best way to go.
The_Face_of_Boo
Veteran

Joined: 16 Jun 2010
Age: 43
Gender: Non-binary
Posts: 33,451
Location: Beirut, Lebanon.
If that’s the dynamic we’re talking about, then fine. I don’t mind her being the boss. And she doesn’t feel so much pressure because our ultimate success or failure is on me. She gets praised for the good stuff, I take blame for the bad stuff.
But that exactly what I was talking about that wives are far more likely to be control freaks.
ClosetGenius, where are you?
The other side of the coin just deals with what roles you choose for yourselves in a lifelong relationship such as marriage. My wife sees me more as an executive. A decision-maker, someone who establishes a shared vision and provides a big-picture direction for the family. She sees herself as a details person, a doer, an “operations director” of sorts. At home, she would say the best thing I can do is stay out of her way and let her work. If I want to step in and help, it has to be done HER way. Because she works hard in and out of the home, she’s really not up for dealing with my needs or urges, so intimacy is strictly on HER terms.
...
I don’t feel neutered because she allows me to do what I need to do and what others need me to do. We share one vehicle for the whole family, so the one night a week I have to get to my other job before she gets off work I change clothes and run 5-6 miles across town where she joins me later on with the kids. I work that into my exercise routine, and I work out a few times per week besides.
To be honest, I'm as surprised with myself as my family is. Back when I was 18, I was really desperate for a girlfriend, and I was willing to sacrifice almost anything to keep one in my life. Because I wanted sex, companionship, and a guaranteed date for events; things that normally come with relationships. I never thought in a million years that down the road, I'd be actively avoiding not only relationships, but also escorts.
AngelRho
Veteran

Joined: 4 Jan 2008
Age: 47
Gender: Male
Posts: 9,366
Location: The Landmass between N.O. and Mobile
If that’s the dynamic we’re talking about, then fine. I don’t mind her being the boss. And she doesn’t feel so much pressure because our ultimate success or failure is on me. She gets praised for the good stuff, I take blame for the bad stuff.
But that exactly what I was talking about that wives are far more likely to be control freaks.
ClosetGenius, where are you?
Control freaks in what context? Making a home run smoothly? Or taking over her husband’s life to the level he can’t do anything without her permission? My wife and I can do pretty much whatever we want within reason and not have to ask permission. We both often check with each other first, but it’s not like either of us has an “I own you” mentality to the point we abuse each other.
Is a dominant role in any given context necessarily belittling of a man? Is a woman running a household smoothly emasculating?
BTW, women maintaining the home has long been a traditional female role. This is nothing new. Men refusing to insist on decent and respectable treatment from wives at present day levels IS a new thing that has ramped up since the 1960s. The previous generation had no problem with men slapping women around if they so chose. Now the attitude seems to have shifted to “a man is female genitalia is he DOESN’T take excrement from his wife.” I’m saying men have a choice whether they believe they do or not. You don’t have to end up with a woman like that, nor do you have to tolerate it if she treats you that way.
Dw mom:
These things:
* "When your wife yells at you, you will be quiet and listen to her! She does it because she cares about you."
* "You will meet a woman someday, and she'll care about you very much!" (said in an angry tone)
* "When your wife cooks something, you will eat it and be thankful for it, even if it's something you don't like!"
is a VERY typical and common dynamic scenario from wife to husband; my mom frequently used to yell at my dad when he does something she doesn't like - very rarely he ever yelled at her (only in very very very few anger moments). My aunt and her husband are the same but her man is less polite.
I noticed it too in married friends, a lot of male married friends joke about it when we are in guys-only outing and they're like "I have to leave early, or else wife is going to yell at me ". And a lot of times wives make snarky remarks at their husbands in public.
Wife yelling/snarky commenting at husband, and showing a kind of revulsion/annoyance at husbands, is a very common and typical thing, and there's no social boundary for it because it's not considered verbal abuse when it's coming from a woman against man.
It's a lot more common to see control freak wives than husbands, even in this part of the world - surprisingly no?
Typically, when men are bothered about something in wife, they shut up, they bottle it up forever - but typically women don't.
And you have this: https://www.inquisitr.com/1474808/scien ... -husbands/
Perhaps I should have put in quotes from the more recent comments that inspired me to write what I did. I had addressed the four original questions earlier.
And I have no statistical and anecdotal evidence either way on which spouse is more often the control freak. It seems about even to me, but who knows.
_________________
Mom to an amazing young adult AS son, plus an also amazing non-AS daughter. Most likely part of the "Broader Autism Phenotype" (some traits).
Similar Topics | |
---|---|
Family won't let me do things because of mental illness
in Bipolar, Tourettes, Schizophrenia, and other Psychological Conditions |
21 Jun 2025, 4:42 pm |
Family conflict and shame |
15 Jun 2025, 1:02 pm |
Accommodating diagnosis-avoidant autistic family member |
02 May 2025, 3:21 pm |
Syrian Druze sheikh's family told of his murder hours afte |
Yesterday, 6:54 am |