V4der wrote:
When did I say anyone on a forum is automatically an idiot? I'm saying a story or account posted by a forum user isn't a reliable resource. Forum users could say anything. Doesn't mean they made credible research beforehand or have a single strand of real evidence.
Same can be said about any research. Any statement, argument, rhetoric, incident, speech, etc. Could be a lie.
There have been cases of even credible scientists producing full paged texts, whom have lied, altered, or presented a proof that is inaccurate.
However, just from a bigger notion.
I would have doubts that BK would be wrong if he said that the forum at least had some semblance of credibility. Each person is a DIFFERENT source. Therefore, it would be likely someone was telling the truth.
An example:
Many people hate wikipedia...yet I have yet to find a single better source on the planet. Any time I compare many credible sources, or highly regarded sources against it, many times they are much looser, and lack many of the details presented in a website like wikipedia.