Don't forget to score them by using the table method.
Just draw in excel table , three columns : Guy 1, guy 2 , guy 3(already out).
and in rows: Face's Attractiveness, Body's Attractiveness, Masculinity ,Wealth,Health, Determination, Intelligence, Success,Social Status,Social Life,Talents,Romance/Sexual experience ,Niceness....etc ...you know just like comparing 2 similar products' specs side-by-side.
Very practical way indeed.
You can add other traits too, you know better but you should know the guys a bit first ...the third guys is already out so go out with both of 1 and 2 and then fill the table.
Score every trait from 0 to 10 (0 terrible -10 is excellent) and finally calculate the sum of each guy , the highest score is the alpha's score.