As far as physical appearances go, this is pretty much a non-issue for me when it comes to women, minus unhealthy obesity. I don't mind a little chubbyness, mind you, but when your weight is a potential health hazard, then I have to draw the line. For the most part, yeah, physical apperances matter not to me in women.
Personality-wise, I'm attracted to a woman who's emphatic, understanding, open-minded, loving, accepting, patient, and non-judgemental. Like me, I'm also attracted to a woman who's intelligent and can hold a pretty good conversation over anything without it becoming a heated, hateful debate or argument.
Another thing I'm attracted to in a woman (and this is probably gonna piss a lot of women off who fit in the two previously mentioned categories, but not this one. Oh well) is how chaste they've been/they are. I'm a virgin, and when/if I ever meet a woman who fits the previous two categories AND is a virgin, then she's got me hooked (assuming that she has any attraction to me, that is). I find that saving yourself for marriage and being a virgin is something that's highly respectable and commendable in my book. It takes a lot of willpower not to give into your bodily urges for a quicky.