Self-loathing and relationships

Page 6 of 6 [ 86 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6

goldfish21
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 17 Feb 2013
Age: 43
Gender: Male
Posts: 22,612
Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada

08 Apr 2018, 7:32 pm

sly279 wrote:
nick007 wrote:
sly279 wrote:
Doubt nick talked about it either so you’d accused him of not doing anything either.
Your rite. I didn't talk about what I was doing to treat my depression & issues a whole lot cuz I was more focused on the negatives when I was posting, especially when I was posting about wanting a realtionship. I did bring up what I was doing when I got accused of not trying or when I thought it was really relevant to a post.

Which I’ve done but It’s ignored, or said it’s not enough. They don’t care I’m doing all I can, they accuse me of lying about my difficulties and experiences.


Many people, besides myself, have suggest that you focus on ANYTHING more positive than wanting to die, and post about it, share it, get support from others.

I haven't seen you do that ever. Please feel free to cross post to anywhere you've done so. Even better, make a commitment to yourself to do so from here on in.

Post & share about how you're doing all you can. Others will be ecstatic to hear of it compared to your regular messages, and you'll get positivity and encouragement for it.

No one has accused you of lying about your difficulties and experiences. They have called you out for your generalizations about women and others when they're not factual and may be considered hurtful or harmful.


_________________
No :heart: for supporting trump. Because doing so is deplorable.


goldfish21
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 17 Feb 2013
Age: 43
Gender: Male
Posts: 22,612
Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada

08 Apr 2018, 7:34 pm

RetroGamer87 wrote:
Raleigh wrote:
So you may still want to die.
Just don't post about it.
Because that upsets people.
And makes them uncomfortable.
Only post positive stuff.
Because that's not fake at all.
And everyone else will feel better.
So, win-win, right?


How can we talk them out of suicide if they're forbidden from talking about it?

Suicidal thoughts are a serious concern that should be discussed without taboo.

If we tell suicidal people they can't talk about it, it will make them feel more alone and then they'll be more likely to do it.

I would prefer to talk about someone's suicidal thoughts then have them act on them. I would prefer to risk feeling uncomfortable rather than risk their life.

Depressed people are already isolated enough so let's not take away their chance to call for help.


No one is suggesting any such thing.

What has been suggested, many times, is that those who have been posting multiple times per day for months or years on end that they want to die should make some sort of effort to acknowledge and treat their depression instead of ignoring every bit of advice suggesting that they do so. No one wants them to simply stop posting that they're suicidal. We want them to actually not be suicidal.


_________________
No :heart: for supporting trump. Because doing so is deplorable.


goldfish21
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 17 Feb 2013
Age: 43
Gender: Male
Posts: 22,612
Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada

08 Apr 2018, 7:36 pm

sly279 wrote:
RetroGamer87 wrote:
Raleigh wrote:
So you may still want to die.
Just don't post about it.
Because that upsets people.
And makes them uncomfortable.
Only post positive stuff.
Because that's not fake at all.
And everyone else will feel better.
So, win-win, right?


How can we talk them out of suicide if they're forbidden from talking about it?

Suicidal thoughts are a serious concern that should be discussed without taboo.

If we tell suicidal people they can't talk about it, it will make them feel more alone and then they'll be more likely to do it.

I would prefer to talk about someone's suicidal thoughts then have them act on them. I would prefer to risk feeling uncomfortable rather than risk their life.

Depressed people are already isolated enough so let's not take away their chance to call for help.


I think he was being sarcastic?

For many of us here wp is all we have left. Yet the minority here tell us to keep quite. Don’t say anything unless it’s positive. To create a fake political correct world here just like we have in the rest of the world. Basically thst we aren’t wanted anywhere.


No one here has said any such thing that I've ever read. People here don't want you to stop saying you're suicidal. They want you to actually not feel suicidal. There's a big difference.


_________________
No :heart: for supporting trump. Because doing so is deplorable.


goldfish21
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 17 Feb 2013
Age: 43
Gender: Male
Posts: 22,612
Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada

08 Apr 2018, 7:39 pm

goldfish21 wrote:
sly279 wrote:
goldfish21 wrote:
@ nick007:

The difference between yourself and other posters is that you made an effort to treat your depression, to work on improving yourself, to try meds, to try seeing a psychologist etc.

The posters we're talking about never talk about changing themselves, trying to treat their depression, ruling out treatment methods and trying others etc - even when they're asked about those things.

Instead it's persistent blaming everyone else for their problems, or posting multiple times per day that they want to die. Those are not attractive qualities in someone to date. No one I know has dated someone severely depressed and said "Wow, what an amazing ball of depressive negativity! I thoroughly enjoyed feeling so down while we were together! I can't wait to spend a the rest of my life feeling so low with them!" In fact, it's been the opposite, I know people who have had to gently break it to their dates that they didn't see a future with someone chronically clinically depressed. They're not rude or wrong for choosing happiness over someone who's always a dark cloud, IMO.

Even if you hadn't, and have not ?, completely overcome your depression before you got into a relationship, at least you were trying. Even the act of caring enough about yourself and potential partner to Try to get better is significantly more attractive. People are people, human, and experience ups and downs of emotions. That's acceptable. But to be suicidally depressed and seeking a date or partner is just setting yourself up for rejection & failure when you'd have a much greater chance of successfully forming a relationship after getting your mental health in better order first.

Doubt nick talked about it either so you’d accused him of not doing anything either.
Just like you accuse me despite how I’ve said I am. You just like being mean to people is all so you assume we don’t do anything cause by your logic, if we were we’d fixed it already or not being posting about our problems and loneliness. Yiu just want us to shut up and go away so yiu don’t have to deal with reality. But you don’t have to be here, you say your life is fantastic. Why don’t you go live your fantastic life and live us with crappy lives alone.

Honestly, if I got a gf tomorrow and it worked out I wouldn’t be in here. Many users who got gfs or bfs are gone. Their life got better and thus they didn’t need a support site anymore. I’m baffled by people who have great lives who come to a support sit to bash those who don’t.


If you are in fact making an effort to treat your depression, and are making progress, then good for you. It would be SO MUCH BETTER to read you make threads and posts about that instead of dwelling on the darkest most negative thoughts that pass through your mind. I have noticed that in the last few weeks you've significantly reduced the frequency at which you post that you want to die, so, that's something & a start at least. People would MUCH RATHER support your efforts at improvement than hear about only the negative things in your life.

That was rude. I'm not mean. It's incredibly rare that I'm mean to anyone, ever, in any aspect of my life, and when I am they most certainly deserve it. I can't even think of the last time I was ever mean to someone tbh. I'm a very giving, generous, charitable, and helpful person. To call me mean is the result of some very distorted thinking.

So focus your posts and thread topics on your healing efforts and progress, not on things you dislike about yourself and your life. It would make a big difference in your healing process.

I've never ever told you to shut up or go away. I have suggested that you stop complaining so much and focus on anything positive instead. There's a big difference between what I said and what you interpret it as.

You are right, sly, for a 35yo autistic man renting from his parents my life IS pretty fantastic! I was at beaches around 120 times last year both hanging out and kiteboarding, and dozens of times already this year. I'm pretty fit, my sex life is as good as I want it to be, I have many friends & family members to spend time with when I want to, I can get jobs and work whenever, I'm not depressed or anxious much at all ever anymore, I've accumulated some financial wealth, I drive a brand new car, and I'm going to pursue the most ambitious undertaking of my life when I return to University studies at least part time this year, and then full time as finances allow.. my ASD symptoms are well under control compared to how they once were.. etc etc etc. I don't share these things to boast or rub it in, I share them to show others that it's 100% entirely possible to change your entire life for the better. That one can go from $110K in debt, bankrupt, almost homeless & living in a construction site, very unhealthy, out of shape, with strong ASD symptoms, executive functioning issues to the nth degree, horrific depression & crippling anxiety... to who I am today. I share to inspire, not to belittle. I offer advice & suggestions to help, not to be mean. I hang around here because I've grown to like many of the personalities I interact with here.. plus it's addictive.. and I've had a LOT of free time this Winter - once I decide to work full time+ hours again I won't be online here anywhere near as much as I have been. If everyone who bettered themselves left a support forum like this, who would be around to do any supporting? What quality of interactions or advice would transpire if only the most depressed people were online? This forum is a bit like doing the Tough Mudder.. we don't quit & we don't leave anyone behind. If I get to the top first, I don't carry on running. I stop, look back, reach my long strong arm down & pull the next person up. In fact, I literally pull a dozen+ people up until I physically can't anymore and then I move forward, with them. People like me don't give up on people like you anywhere near as easily as you do. It's not in me, or anyone like me, to let you fail.

The probability of you getting a gf tomorrow and it working out is slim to none. That's reality. That's why myself and others consistently remind you that you'd be better off working on improving yourself in every way so that you're a much more datable sly before you try to jump into the dating world. You would have a MUCH greater chance of success after you've overcome your depression & anxiety, and perhaps gotten yourself into better physical shape, and worked towards a more prosperous financial life, too. Even without physical fitness & money, you'd be a MUCH better candidate for a date than someone who is highly anxious and suicidally depressed. If I were mean I wouldn't care whether you got better or not, and I certainly wouldn't have offered to pay for some of the resources I think could help you learn and grow.

Again, I haven't ever come here to bash anyone. I come to learn things I need to learn, to discuss things of interest with personalities I've gotten to know and like, and to offer my advice to others who have yet to achieve the things I have on my journey because I've done them and am in a better position to offer helpful advice on how to achieve them than other people who have not.

Offer's still open, sly. I would still pay for that book/audiobook, and if you were open to trying other things that have worked for me I'd be open to discussing paying for them, too. If you have a will to learn, grow, heal, overcome your depression & anxiety, get in better physical shape etc then I would gladly volunteer my time to advise you how to best do it (based on the best of my knowledge & experiences) at the lowest possible dollar cost and even pay for things you Need along the way. I'm someone who went from $110K in debt and unable to work to making $150/month and spending 100% of it on bettering my health until I was able to work more and earn more, and then on to working more than full time, saving and investing, and catching up to & even surpassing many of my peers, so I know a thing or two about how to do this. But I also know it takes having a will to do it. If you do, I'll help you do it, and it won't be that many months-to-a-few-short years until you, too, are living a relatively fantastic life.


Quoted for emphasis just in case sly is pretending he didn't read this at the bottom of the previous page.


_________________
No :heart: for supporting trump. Because doing so is deplorable.


RetroGamer87
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 30 Jul 2013
Age: 38
Gender: Male
Posts: 11,185
Location: Adelaide, Australia

08 Apr 2018, 7:43 pm

sly279 wrote:
RetroGamer87 wrote:
Raleigh wrote:
So you may still want to die.
Just don't post about it.
Because that upsets people.
And makes them uncomfortable.
Only post positive stuff.
Because that's not fake at all.
And everyone else will feel better.
So, win-win, right?


How can we talk them out of suicide if they're forbidden from talking about it?

Suicidal thoughts are a serious concern that should be discussed without taboo.

If we tell suicidal people they can't talk about it, it will make them feel more alone and then they'll be more likely to do it.

I would prefer to talk about someone's suicidal thoughts then have them act on them. I would prefer to risk feeling uncomfortable rather than risk their life.

Depressed people are already isolated enough so let's not take away their chance to call for help.


I think he was being sarcastic?


I think you're right. I didn't realise Raleigh was being sarcastic.


_________________
The days are long, but the years are short


AngelRho
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 4 Jan 2008
Age: 48
Gender: Male
Posts: 9,366
Location: The Landmass between N.O. and Mobile

08 Apr 2018, 9:25 pm

sly279 wrote:
RetroGamer87 wrote:
Raleigh wrote:
So you may still want to die.
Just don't post about it.
Because that upsets people.
And makes them uncomfortable.
Only post positive stuff.
Because that's not fake at all.
And everyone else will feel better.
So, win-win, right?


How can we talk them out of suicide if they're forbidden from talking about it?

Suicidal thoughts are a serious concern that should be discussed without taboo.

If we tell suicidal people they can't talk about it, it will make them feel more alone and then they'll be more likely to do it.

I would prefer to talk about someone's suicidal thoughts then have them act on them. I would prefer to risk feeling uncomfortable rather than risk their life.

Depressed people are already isolated enough so let's not take away their chance to call for help.


I think he was being sarcastic?

For many of us here wp is all we have left. Yet the minority here tell us to keep quite. Don’t say anything unless it’s positive. To create a fake political correct world here just like we have in the rest of the world. Basically thst we aren’t wanted anywhere.

Sly:

First of all, I really am glad you in particular are posting in this thread. I mean that. I was hoping you would, and there are others who share your perspective and who are already posting.

Whether I agree or with you or them is totally irrelevant in this thread.

I WILL NOT try to isolate you, tell you to stop whining, or say it’s wrong to express suicidal thoughts in this thread. I WILL NOT outright accuse anyone of being an “emotional vampire.” I WILL NOT dictate what anyone can/can’t say.

If you want to vent, vent away. I’m not comfortable offering much validation, so don’t be surprised if I don’t do the whole “aw, poor baby” thing. It’s nothing personal. It’s just it’s not my thing, and there are better people than me who know what to say without coming across as condescending. People always know right away when I’m being disingenuous, so please don’t misread my apparent lack of sympathy as hate.

As I recall from your other posts, you largely suffer from a lack of independence. I think you were probably tricked into making some poor choices, same as I and many others of our generation, and you don’t have much way out of it (student loans, I think). You are stuck in an unfortunate family situation. You lack a lot of control over your circumstances which make turning things around EXTREMELY difficult. You think those things disqualify you from attracting girls. Am I in the neighborhood?

The solution to fixing your problem, if I understand correctly, is simply a matter of boosting your freedom. How willing are you, and be honest, to take steps to do that?

To anyone else reading this...that is PRECISELY what this thread is about. Do you love (take care of) yourself enough to make things happen to propel your life in a positive direction and succeed in relationships?

Sly: I really do think you have a good chance of getting it together and succeeding. I know you have a number of things that are legitimately holding you back. If you really want to, I believe more than anything you’re ready for a relationship. The challenge is a matter of reconciling relational pursuits to the obligations you already have dragging you down. You can do it. It always comes down to willingness, or how close you are to that breaking point and you make up your mind that, for example, you will NEVER AGAIN spend an entire weekend alone.